Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Scoop Feature: Fiji An Icon Of Pacific Instability

Scoop Feature: Fiji An Icon Of Pacific Constitutional Instability

By Selwyn Manning – Scoop Co-Editor

STATE OF IT: Why Fiji's Army Believes It Has A Right To Overthrow Its Government - Last week, while covering the Forum in Nadi, Fiji, Scoop sought the views of Fijians as to why their military was threatening to over-throw the Fijian government. Should the demands of Fiji's military commander be taken seriously? All said most definitely.


Scoop Audio.ALSO, Scoop Audio (click here to listen): Selwyn Manning on the BBC: Reports how Fiji's government has lost control of its military after its PM Qarase ordered the country's military chief to be sacked. In turn Fiji's Army chief has ordered Qarase's government to resign or be forced from office.


Fiji's military commander, Voreqe (Frank) Bainimarama, cast a long shadow in the week prior the Pacific Islands Forum. Even though Bainimarama was in the Middle East visiting Royal Fiji Military Force soldiers - and no doubt the hundreds of his former soldiers who had been poached by security companies and now operate as private soldiers in Iraq and Kuwait - his ultimatum drew concerns from both the New Zealand and Australian prime ministers who insisted that their personal security be beefed up while attending the Forum and that a 'fast escape' contingency plan be at the reader should soldiers turn up at the Denarau Island Resort where leaders gathered for the Pacific Islands Forum.

When talking to people on Nadi's streets they, taxi drivers and others, both indigenous Fijians and Fijian Indians, said Bainimarama is serious, that he should be taken at his word, and, what's more, all said Bainimarama had their support.

Immediately after Forum leaders left Fiji, the Fiji government displayed just how tenuous is its hold is over the Royal Fiji Military Force. On Tuesday (October 31) Prime Minister Laisenia Qarase sought but failed to have Army Commander Commodore Voreqe (Frank) Bainimarama sacked.

The government had been embarrassed after Bainimarama (on October 16) issued an ultimatum: that Fiji's Prime Minister Qarase had until November 6 to back off two controversial bills (an indigenous coastal rights bill and a reconciliation bill) or face being run out of office by the Fijian Army.

This week, Qarase met with Fiji's president, Ratu Josefa Iloilo, and on Tuesday morning Qarase sought a presidential order demanding Bainimarama to stand down as head of the Military. Qarase urged that Bainimarama be replaced by Lt Colonel Meli Saubulinayau.

Image: Laisenia QaraseThe news organisation FijiLive reported that Qarase had demanded that if Bainimarama did not stand down then he and his government would resign office. However, the bluff backfired after senior military chiefs refused to carry out the order and demonstrated total support for their commander Bainimarama.

Bainimarama then countered the government's order stating that Qarase's government must resign gracefully.

Bainimarama, who was still in Iraq visiting Fijian soldiers based there but scheduled to return to Fiji late this week, told FijiLive the last thing he wanted was violence and that Prime Minister Laisenia Qarase should be held responsible if that were to happen: "Now that they have failed to remove me all that needs to be done is for the Government to resign gracefully. If it does not happen, the military does not want any violence," he told Fijilive. Bainimarama added that the Qarase government was corrupt: "They have to be removed."

So what is it about the two proposed bills that has polarised Fiji? First, it would appear many in Fiji believe recent Fiji general elections held in May were rigged.

The military chief wants Qarase to withdraw an indigenous coastal rights bill and also reconciliation legislation which would see the release from prison of those involved with Fiji's 2000 George Speight-led coup.

The Fiji Times had reported Bainimarama as stating: "At this stage Fiji needs good governance and the military will demand their resignation. There's nothing illegal about this… We don't have to take over because the military will walk into the office of the prime minister and demand his resignation. If the people want us to do this, we will do it."

The drivers said even though a coup would "put Fiji back years" it would be worth it as the coastal rights bill would see anyone, "even criminals and troublesome people" able to wander about on coastal resorts. It would seem tourism operators and those hooked into tourist service businesses are against the bill. Should the bill pass, the men said tourists would end up being robbed and the result would be a severe drop off in tourists to Fiji and more Fijian people out of jobs. The reconciliation bill they said is simply wrong: "Those involved with the Speight coup are criminals. They deserve to be behind bars for what they have done," one of the drivers said.

For a Kiwi, it's a weird rationale to fathom. But for these men, whose livelihood is founded on tourism, it is clear; if the government is not working for the people's and Fiji's interests, then the Military must intercede.

Image: Royal Fiji Military Force Sitting back, one wonders if the sentiment is born within the cultural and ideological roots of military tradition in Fiji. As Melbourne-based journalist Nic Maclellan identified in Pacific Journalism Review (September 2006 edition), etched deep within the Fijian observances of lotu (Christianity and Methodism), turagaism (a belief in the chiefly rights to leadership) militarism, and links between masculinity, rugby, religion, and the bati warrior culture in Fiji, can be found explanations for a contemporary acceptance of a military commander asserting his demands on a government that it shape up or be shipped out. For Australians and New Zealanders the existence of a constitutional divide between the operations of the military and that of the executive is more than just an observance, it is an essential ingredient of stable society. But the Fijian drivers say that is fine "but if the government is corrupt, and an election is rigged, then what option remains?"

The Military (or more accurately those contracted overseas in Iraq and Kuwait as private soldiers) inject millions into the Fijian economy and, as Nic Maclellan reported, by mid-2005 over 1000 Fijian were working in Iraq and Kuwait as soldiers, security guards, drivers and labourers.

Almost 15,000 people had earlier signed applications to work in the Middle East. With Fiji offering an unregulated market, private security companies set up branch offices in Suva. Companies like Britain's Global Risk Strategies began poaching soldiers from the Royal Fiji Military Force. Others included Homeland Securities Limited (a recruiting agency for ArmorGroup), Sabre International Security Fiji Ltd (subsidiary of Britain's Control Solutions) and Meridian Services Agency – all offered soldiers up to $3000.00 Fijian dollars a month to be private soldiers in Iraq. But as Maclellan's investigation showed, while thousands signed contracts in Fiji, many found once inside the Middle East promises of big Fiji bucks deflated, and in some cases (as with Global Risk Strategies) were not paid at all.

Despite the scandals surrounding the private security companies, Fiji remains a nation proud of its military heritage. Its soldiers are highly regarded for the work they have done with United Nations peace keeping forces. Many have been recruited and employed by the British Army. For many of these soldiers it is a family tradition going back generations.

Image: Royal Fiji Military Force On Wednesday FijiLive reported Members of the Fiji military had been asked to resign if they did not support Bainimarama's stand against the Qarase government.

FijiLive reported: 'Military spokesman Major Neumi Leweni said that military commander Commodore Voreqe Bainimarama made the call three weeks ago and was re-emphasised at the barracks following Government House's failed attempt to replace the army chief. "The indications we got yesterday is that everybody was one," said Leweni. "If anything had come out of this, it has made us much stronger. The moral is very high. It showed our resolve.",' the FijiLive report stated.

Fiji has a total population of 846,085 people, made up of 54 percent indigenous Fijian, 37 percent Fijian Indian, and nine percent all other races. But it may surprise many to realize that support for its military issuing commands to the government spans the ethnic divide. With 12 percent unemployment, and an obvious lack of opportunity for many, discontent with the government, at least on Viti Levu, is rife.


UPDATE: - New Zealand's Prime Minister, Helen Clark, has call on Commodore Bainimarama to stand aside. Click here for this article.

File Image: Winston PetersAnd a spokesperson for New Zealand foreign affairs minister, Winston Peters, told Scoop: "New Zealand's government believes that commodore Bainimarama should respect the wishes of the government and stand aside when he returns to Fiji from overseas.

"Fiji's government was democratically elected - in fact it has been encouraging to see all political parties working together in a multi-party government since the election in May - and it appears to have followed the proper process in attempting to deal with Commodore Bainimarama. So we feel that he should follow the constitution himself and agree to stand aside.

"Our position on the role of the military is well known - it does not have any political role in a democratically-elected government, and in fact it should respect the direction given to it by a democratically elected government. If Commodore Bainimarama does not like what is happening in politics in Fiji then he should leave his post as commander and stand for parliament," the spokesperson said.

As a close friend and neighbour of Fiji, the New Zealand government is particularly concerned about the risk of considerable damage to Fiji's economy that a stand-off between the armed forces and the government could have through scaring away tourism and international business. And while it has not followed the Australians' lead in having naval vessels on stand by "we are ready to react to any changes in the situation at short notice," the spokesperson said.

"Similarly we continue to monitor the situation viz our travel advisory and while we have not seen fit to warn against tourist travel at this point, we are advising tourists that there is potential for rapid change in the current atmosphere of calm in Fiji and that they should therefore continue checking the Safe Travel website for any updates."

New Zealand's Ministry of Foreign Affairs Safe Travel advisory currently states: "Tensions between the Government of Fiji and the Fiji Military Forces continue. Although the situation is currently calm, this could change with little warning. New Zealanders planning to visit Fiji should monitor both the media and this website for updates. In the event of the situation deteriorating, New Zealanders in Fiji are unlikely to be targeted but should take measures to avoid being caught up inadvertently in any violence, including by avoiding demonstrations and large gatherings." See… Safe Travel for more.



Pacific News: Clark Urges Fiji Army Chief Bainimarama To Stand Aside

File Image: Helen Clark while in Fiji Scoop News: Selwyn Manning reports
that New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark has called on Fiji's military commander to "step aside" after the island nation's prime minister, Laisenia Qarase failed yesterday to have him removed. Helen Clark has said Fiji's government was legitimately elected and had followed a process to stand down Royal Fiji Military Force's commander, Commodore Frank Bainimarama. Scoop File Image: Helen Clark while in Fiji. See... NZ PM Calls For Fiji Military Boss To Stand Aside ALSO:
  • Scoop Report: Fiji PM Fails To Oust Military Chief
  • Scoop Audio.Scoop Audio: Selwyn Manning and Radio Adelaide's Peter Godfrey discuss: How Fiji's government appears to have lost control of its military after its PM Qarase ordered the military chief to be sacked.

    Australia Department Of Foreign Affairs - Fiji has enjoyed a period of relative political stability since the 2001 elections. In accordance with a Constitutional provision for multi-party representation in cabinet Prime Minister Qarase invited the leader of the Fiji Labour Party Mahendra Chaudhry to consultations on the make-up of cabinet. Chaudhry refused the offer. The latest national elections were held from 6 to 13 May 2006 and Prime Minister Qarase's SDL Government was returned to office with a narrow majority. The Fiji Labour Party (FLP) accepted Prime Minister Qarase's offer to form a multi-party Cabinet, although Chaudhry did not include his own name on the list of MPs nominated by the FLP to be eligible for Cabinet positions.


    © Scoop Media

    Top Scoops Headlines


    Dunne Speaks: Robertson's Budget Gamble On Treasury
    The popular test of the success or failure of Grant Robertson’s fifth Budget will be its impact on the soaring cost of living. In today’s climate little else matters. Because governments come and governments go – about every six to seven years on average since 1945 – getting too focused on their long-term fiscal aspirations is often pointless... More>>

    Keith Rankin: Liberal Democracy In The New Neonationalist Era: The Three 'O's
    The proposed ‘New Zealand Income Insurance Scheme’ (‘the scheme’) has attracted strong debate among the more left-wing and liberal groupings, within New Zealand-Aotearoa. This debate should be seen as a positive rather than negative tension because of the opportunity to consider and learn from the implications and sharpen advocacy... More>>

    Dunne Speaks: Words Matter, Prime Minister
    Words matter, especially when uttered by politicians. History is littered with examples of careless or injudicious words uttered by politicians coming back to haunt them, often at the most awkward of times. During the 1987 election campaign, when electoral reform was a hot issue, Prime Minister David Lange promised to have a referendum on the electoral system... More>>

    Digitl: Infrastructure Commission wants digital strategy
    Earlier this month Te Waihanga, New Zealand’s infrastructure commission, tabled its first Infrastructure Strategy: Rautaki Hanganga o Aotearoa. Te Waihanga describes its document as a road map for a thriving New Zealand... More>>

    Binoy Kampmark: Leaking For Roe V Wade
    The US Supreme Court Chief Justice was furious. For the first time in history, the raw judicial process of one of the most powerful, and opaque arms of government, had been exposed via media – at least in preliminary form. It resembled, in no negligible way, the publication by WikiLeaks of various drafts of the Trans-Pacific Partnership... More>>

    The Conversation: Cheaper food comes with other costs – why cutting GST isn't the answer

    As New Zealand considers the removal of the goods and services tax (GST) from food to reduce costs for low income households, advocates need to consider the impact cheap food has on the environment and whether there are better options to help struggling families... More>>