Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
Work smarter with a Pro licence Learn More
Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Venezuela – Democracy in Action

Venezuela – Democracy in Action

by Julie Webb-Pullman

In a country where the electoral rules strictly honour and serve the rights of the people rather than the other way around, polling booths didn't close until almost midnight, so that everyone waiting in a queue could exercise their Constitutional right to vote. Although opposition candidates began clamouring for closing of the booths from 4pm, the President of the Electoral Council Tibisay Lucena repeated continually on national television that the booths would NOT close until everyone who wanted to, had voted.

Click to enlarge

Casting an electronic vote behind the screen

Visiting polling booths throughout the day to observe the process and talk to the locals revealed an extremely high level of voter confidence in the process. With 100% electronic voting backed up by a paper-trail, two thumb-prints required for identification prior to voting, and a purple-stained pinky once they'd done so, irregularities were confined to minor infringements. Some 106 people out of 10 million voters were fined for irregularities such as ripping up the paper receipt instead of putting it in the paper ballot box in case a recount was needed – a number unlikely to realistically affect any challenged outcome!

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading

Are you getting our free newsletter?

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.

Click to enlarge

Crowds throng the streets around Miraflores Palace waiting for the results

Voters were universal in their praise for the conduct of the elections and other electors, citing the calm respectful atmosphere as a first. Although opposition and PSUV voters were sometimes queued together for several hours in the hot sun, which might have been expected to frazzle tempers and spill over, it just didn't happen. All interviewees were adamant that everyone had the right to vote, and to have their opinion respected, and they were all happy not only to demand that respect for themselves, but also to accord it to their fellow citizens.

Click to enlarge

Dipping the pinky after voting

The elderly and people with disabilities had their own line, and were prioritised through the system. People on crutches and in wheelchairs were carried up and down flights of stairs as necessary, under the watchful eye of the National Guard.

Click to enlarge

Priority given to elderly and people with disabilities

Record Turnout
Some 65% of voters turned out, making it the highest ever recorded for regional and municipal elections. Despite the increased turnout over last year's referendum vote, the proportions of support were little different from previous elections – about 6 million votes (70%) to Chavez-supporting United Socialist Party of Venezuela candidates (PSUV), and 4 million (30%) to the opposition. PSUV thus managed to pick up another million or so who abstained last year, while opposition support remained static.

Click to enlarge

Simon Bolivar presente!

Caracas goes Right
However there were a few surprises – the Mayoralty of Caracas was lost to the opposition, and as they also took five of the six surrounding mayoralties it will make for a tough four years for Chavistas to maintain their revolutionary momentum in the capital. Although they'll be assisted by an 8-12 Chavismo majority in Council in Grand Caracas, which should see some pretty interesting debates, there is concern whether continued funding of numerous social initiatives by the local consultative councils will be the first victims of the incoming Mayor.

Click to enlarge

Thumbprint check at San Antonio

The opposition also picked up the governorships in Miranda, Carabobo, and Tachira, demonstrating what is considered to be widespread grassroots dissatisfaction amongst Chavistas with gross mismanagement and lack of confidence in the Chavista incumbents, especially Bernal in Libertador and Rangel in Pitari.

Click to enlarge

Thumbrint onto electoral roll list before voting

The opposition didn't have it all their way – in the two states of Aragua and Sucre turncoat-Governors of the party Podemos who were elected under Chavismo last elections but jumped the fence into the opposition camp during their term, were rewarded by being ousted by the voters, and replaced by genuine Chavistas.

Click to enlarge

Voters at San Antonio finding their electoral 'table'

Not a Vote Against Chavez
Overall, the result saw 17 out of 23 governorships go to the PSUV, while only 6 went to the opposition. While the loss of three governorships to the opposition is clearly food for thought for the PSUV, who are already dissecting the results, it would be a grave error to interpret these losses as a vote against Chavez. This is a party only some six months old, after all, and they did manage to wrest back two states from the opposition. If anything, it reaffirms the commitment of over 70% of voters to the Venezuelan socialist project of the 21st Century, a majority enjoyed by few western democratic governments.

Click to enlarge

Voters queue outside the National Library in Caracas

Chavez himself warned several months ago that the opposition would have three theatres of operation in which they would concentrate their efforts – "half-moons" in the east and west, and Caracas in the centre. While the opposition was successful in getting their half-moon in the west with Zulia and Tachira, they missed out on Sucre and Monargas in the east, getting only Nueva Esparta, and managed only partial success in the centre with Carabobo and Caracas. Given that two of the candidates were not even the preferred candidates (who were barred from standing because of corruption charges), the opposition may well have garnered even more support – food for thought for the PSUV.

While the PSUV searches its soul over the next few months, some of the issues they are sure to be addressing include pre-selection processes, given the widespread dissatisfaction on the ground with many of the PSUV candidates. Disillusionment with the slow rate of change is another issue they will no doubt be looking at, and taking up.

The considerable success of the PSUV in mobilising at the local level is an extraordinary achievement in such a young party, and is a base that will surely continue to be built upon.

As Chavez said after the results were announced, these elections reaffirmed that the overwhelming majority of Venezuelans want to continue moving towards socialism. He also emphasised that the results give no grounds for a coup, and that the country's laws will be applied to ensure the expressed wishes of the people are upheld. Viva democracy!!


© Scoop Media

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading
Top Scoops Headlines


Join Our Free Newsletter

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.