Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Asbestos court victory over ACC after lung cancer death

Asbestos court victory over ACC 'bittersweet' after lung cancer death

Sarah Robson, Reporter

The family of a woman who died of cancer caused by inhaling asbestos says their victory over ACC in the High Court is bittersweet.

Deanna Trevarthen Photo: Supplied

Deanna Trevarthen died at the age of 45 in 2016 of mesothelioma, a lung cancer caused by asbestos fibres.

After her death her family continued a legal fight over ACC's rejection of her claim financial help.

Ms Trevarthen said she had been exposed to asbestos as a child, while her father was working as an electrician - an occupation that at the time had high exposure to asbestos.

Between the ages of four and 10, she would hug her father when he was wearing his work clothes and she would also sometimes play at his work sites.

Her claim to ACC for financial help was turned down because she had not been exposed to asbestos at work.

The case ended up in the High Court, which has ruled Ms Trevarthen was entitled to cover because her exposure to asbestos and development of mesothelioma was a personal injury caused by an accident.

Her sister-in-law, Angela Calver, who continued the legal fight after Ms Trevarthen's death told Morning Report they kept on in the hope it would change the outcome for other people.

"There were days when I thought about chucking it in - but I made a promise to her.

"I made a promise to someone that I loved, so I kept on keeping on, as you do."

"I hope it is part of her legacy. She definitely left behind a group of people who love her dearly" - Angela Calver duration 3:53
from Morning Report

Click a link to play audio (or right-click to download) in either
MP3 format or in OGG format.

Ms Calver said Ms Trevarthen's exposure to asbestos was an accident.

"As a child she can remember running up to dad and hugging him when he got home from work ... she also remembers going a couple of his workplaces and breaking up plasterboard. They were her childhood memories," she said.

The family couldn't understand why Ms Trevarthen wasn't eligible for ACC cover when others exposed to it at work were, she said.

"You could hire a builder to come around to your house, he could knock some asbestos, you could both breathe it in, you could both get mesothelioma many years in the future, and the builder would be covered and you wouldn't," she said.

"Mesothelioma is a killer - there is no one who has survived - and it's a man-made killer and so it was always really important to Deanna to rectify that situation."

Ms Calver hoped ACC would make changes as a result of the High Court judgment and offer the same help to people who have mesothelioma through secondary exposure to asbestos outside of their work.

"It's kind of bittersweet. All of us would much rather Deanna was here, 100 percent, but it's good that her legacy will change it and make it better for other people."

The family manged to raise $8000 every three weeks for the cancer drug Keytruda.

"It definitely extended her life and gave her some good times with the family before that stopped being effective against the mesothelioma."

They were not so concerned about reimbursement from ACC as about changing things for other people.

"At the end of the day, that money, we would have found it one way or another - as you do when someone in your family is terminally ill."

"I guess for us, setting a precedent for others to have some hope in being able to access funds, because not all people will be able to solve that problem every three weeks.

One of the family's lawyers, Tom Lynskey, said if ACC honoured the judgment it would set an important precedent.

"For the people who are affected it would mean a great deal, because it changes the treatment they can access, it changes the entitlements that they can access, it potentially changes that the surviving family have access to it as well," he said.

Mr Lynskey told Morning Report the disease had a long latency period and hits very suddenly.

"Your prognosis is very poor, you'll be forced out of work very quickly and it is important that those people be able to access treatment which understandably may not be available under the public health system."

"What we hoped to achieve was to establish when you are exposed to asbestos not in the workplace that it can be considered a accident" - Lawyer Tom Lynsksey duration 3:38
from Morning Report

Click a link to play audio (or right-click to download) in either
MP3 format or in OGG format.

Mr Lynskey said the court finding was unlikely to apply to types of cases, because mesothelioma was a unique disease for which there was no known safe level of exposure to asbestos.

"For another disease such as asbestosis you need cumulative exposure ... whereas with mesothelioma low levels of exposure can cause the disease."

The estate would get some entitlements because there was now ACC cover but the family also wanted to establish a precedent for people in the same situation, he said.

Occupational health expert Professor Bill Glass said this sort of recognition of the implications of secondary exposure to asbestos had been a long time coming.

"Let's hope that it now opens the door to other young children - and they're mainly girls - who unexpectedly developed this dreadful mesothelioma, a life-threatening disease, in middle age."

ACC said was considering the judgment and was not commenting further.

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


Binoy Kampmark: Budget Cockups In The Time Of Coronavirus: Reporting Errors And Australia’s JobKeeper Scheme

Hell has, in its raging fires, ringside seats for those who like their spreadsheets. The seating, already peopled by those from human resources, white collar criminals and accountants, becomes toastier for those who make errors with those spreadsheets. ... More>>

The Dig - COVID-19: Just Recovery

The COVID-19 crisis is compelling us to kick-start investment in a regenerative and zero-carbon future. We were bold enough to act quickly to stop the virus - can we now chart a course for a just recovery? More>>

The Conversation: Are New Zealand's New COVID-19 Laws And Powers Really A Step Towards A Police State?

Reaction to the New Zealand government’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic and resultant lockdown has ranged from high praise to criticism that its actions were illegal and its management chaotic. More>>

Keith Rankin: Universal Versus Targeted Assistance, A Muddled Dichotomy

The Commentariat There is a regular commentariat who appear on places such as 'The Panel' on Radio New Zealand (4pm on weekdays), and on panels on television shows such as Newshub Nation (TV3, weekends) and Q+A (TV1, Mondays). Generally, these panellists ... More>>

Jelena Gligorijevic: (Un)lawful Lockdown And Government Accountability

As the Government begins to ease the lockdown, serious questions remain about the lawfulness of these extraordinary measures. Parliament’s Epidemic Response Committee has indicated it will issue summonses for the production of legal advice about the ... More>>

Caitlin Johnstone: Do You Consent To The New Cold War?

The world's worst Putin puppet is escalating tensions with Russia even further, with the Trump administration looking at withdrawal from more nuclear treaties in the near future. In addition to planning on withdrawing from the Open Skies Treaty ... More>>

Binoy Kampmark: Why Thinking Makes It So: Donald Trump’s Obamagate Fixation

The “gate” suffix has been wearing thin since the break-in scandal that gave it its birth. Since Watergate, virtually anything dubious and suggestive, and much more besides, is suffixed. Which brings us to the issue of President Donald Trump’s ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Ethics (and Some Of The Economics) Of Lifting The Lockdown

As New Zealand passes the half-way mark towards moving out of Level Four lockdown, the trade-offs involved in life-after-lockdown are starting to come into view. All very well for National’s finance spokesperson Paul Goldsmith to claim that “The number one priority we have is to get out of the lockdown as soon as we can”…Yet as PM Jacinda Ardern pointed out a few days ago, any crude trade-off between public health and economic well-being would be a false choice... More>>

Binoy Kampmark: Brutal Choices: Anders Tegnell And Sweden’s Herd Immunity Goal

If the title of epidemiological czar were to be created, its first occupant would have to be Sweden’s Anders Tegnell. He has held sway in the face of sceptics and concern that his “herd immunity” approach to COVID-19 is a dangerous, and breathtakingly ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Trans-Tasman Bubble, And The Future Of Airlines

As the epidemiologists keep on saying, a trans-Tasman bubble will require having in place beforehand a robust form of contact tracing, of tourists and locals alike - aided by some kind of phone app along the lines of Singapore’s TraceTogether ... More>>


  • PublicAddress
  • Pundit
  • Kiwiblog