Top Scoops

Book Reviews | Gordon Campbell | Scoop News | Wellington Scoop | Community Scoop | Search


Napier City Council monitoring of member Facebook accounts

Napier City Council's monitoring of members' Facebook accounts 'uncomfortable' and 'creepy'

Anusha Bradley, Hawke's Bay Reporter

Six "renegade" Napier councillors who oppose a new pool complex had their Facebook pages monitored by senior council staff looking for code of conduct breaches.

screenshot of
McGrath's Facebook page with some text highlighted in

In one email, Wayne Jack asked for legal advice on whether Mr McGrath had breached the code or any other policies after he posted a link to a Givealittle fundraiser for The Friends of Onekawa Aquatic Centre, which is taking legal action against the council over the proposed pool. Photo: Supplied to RNZ in an OIA

Emails obtained by RNZ show Napier City Council chief executive Wayne Jack ordered staff to compile a dossier of Facebook posts by councillors Maxine Boag, Richard McGrath and Kirsten Wise in the lead up to a crucial council vote on the pool in December, amid discussions about how to discredit the concerns held by those opposing the $41m project.

The social media surveillance comes as some councillors are refusing to comment in the media on divisive issues because of fears they will breach the code.

In one email, a council officer calls the six who oppose the pool "renegade councillors" as they discuss an opinion piece penned by them in the local paper that called the project flawed.

Other emails show Mr Jack and senior managers discussing Facebook posts by councillors and whether they could be used to bring code of conduct breaches against them.

This included the use of a council-owned image of the new pool by councillor Api Tapine in a post questioning whether proper consultation had been carried out.

In another email, Mr Jack asked for legal advice on whether Mr McGrath had breached the code or any other policies after he posted a link to a Givealittle fundraiser for The Friends of Onekawa Aquatic Centre, which is taking legal action against the council over the proposed pool.

Another post by Mr McGrath that drew managers' attention included a picture of dirty water with the caption: "My water today. This would be why we need to prioritise drinking water over swimming pools."

The surveillance of their Facebook posts is being described by the councillors as "disturbing" and "creepy".

"I feel very uncomfortable about council staff trolling through my Facebook pages looking for code of conduct breaches.

"It's creepy," Ms Boag said.

"It seems very inappropriate to me that staff are being employed by us, ratepayers, to spend time tracking through Facebook pages ... without us even knowing it. How can I work in a climate of trust when this is happening?"

Mr McGrath said it was not appropriate conduct for council staff.

"It just looks like anyone who had a differing opinion on the swimming pool was being targeted.

"I don't think it's appropriate for council to be doing it. I would have thought there were more important tasks to be done in the day like sorting out the water and perhaps not spying on councillors."

The emails showed it was time for a shake-up at the council, Mr Tapine said.

"There was clearly some strategy to negate my ability to participate in conversation.

"That's really a concern. It speaks to an environment within the governance and management of Napier City [Council] that is unhealthy, especially when directives such as this can go unchallenged," Mr Tapine said.

There needed to be a focus on the council's management to ensure this culture changed, he said.

Ms Wise said she found the Facebook surveillance "disturbing" and believed council's management had taken the interpretation of the code of conduct "too far".

"I've been threatened with [a breach] on several occasions but it's never been followed through with. As councillors it is important we understand exactly what we can and can't do so we can push back on that when we're told we are in breach when in fact we are not."

Mr Jack is currently on holiday and acting chief executive Adele Henderson declined to be interviewed by RNZ.

"Elected members have standards of behaviour expected from them in the exercise of their duties as a Councillor.

"These are set out in the Code of Conduct for elected members, which are self-imposed as councillors adopt these protocols when first elected," she said in a statement.

"There is no active monitoring of councillor social media pages. However, where published articles are brought to our attention we have an obligation to investigate further, as has happened in this instance."

No concerns had been raised about the social media activity of any of the six councillors who voted in favour of the pools, council documents showed.

One of those included councillor Keith Price, who said he was not worried about his Facebook page being monitored by staff.

"I'm happy if they check mine," he said.

But surveillance of councillors' social media activity was a worry, Victoria University law professor Dean Knight said.

"It raises eye brows and is verging on stepping over the line, beyond the usual neutrality we expect of council staff and officers."

It was also troubling the council's code of conduct was being used "as a weapon" against elected members who disagree with staff, he said.

"If code of conducts are used to suppress half the conversation, the squeaky wheel, the uncomfortable naysayer, then we have an impoverished form of democracy," Dr Knight said.

Acting Napier mayor Faye White was also on holiday and acting deputy mayor Claire Hague declined to comment.

All work on the proposed new pool, including the tender process, has been halted until a new mayor and council is elected in October.

© Scoop Media

Top Scoops Headlines


Gordon Campbell: On The Addiction To Chinese Student Fees

Last week, Australian PM Scott Morrison extended its ban on foreign visitors from or passing through from mainland China – including Chinese students - for a third week. New Zealand has dutifully followed suit, with our travel ban ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Coronavirus, And The Iowa Debacle

As Bloomberg says, the coronavirus shutdown is creating the world’s biggest work-from-home experiment. On the upside, the mortality rate with the current outbreak is lower than with SARS in 2003, but (for a number of reasons) the economic impact this time ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Dodging A Bullet Over The Transport Cost Over-Runs

As New Zealand gears up to begin its $6.8 billion programme of large scale roading projects all around the country, we should be aware of this morning’s sobering headlines from New South Wales, where the cost overruns on major transport projects ... More>>

Gordon Campbell:On Kobemania, Palestine And The Infrastructure Package

Quick quiz to end the week. What deserves the more attention – the death of a US basketball legend, or the end of Palestinian hopes for an independent state? Both died this week, but only one was met with almost total indifference by the global community. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Double Standard That’s Bound To Dominate The Election

Are National really better political managers than Labour, particularly when it comes to running the economy? For many voters – and the business community in particular - their belief in National’s inherent competence is a simple act of faith. More>>

Gordon Campbell : On Dealing With Impeccable, Impeachable Lies

By now, the end game the Republican Senate majority has in mind in their setting of the rules for the impeachment trial of Donald J. Trump is pretty clear to everyone: first deny the Democrats the ability to call witnesses and offer evidence, and then derisively dismiss the charges for lack of evidence. For his part, does former security adviser John Bolton really, really want to testify against his former boss? If there was any competing faction within the Republican Party, there might be some point for Bolton in doing so – but there isn’t. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Why The Dice Are Loaded Against Women..

If they enter public life, women can expect a type of intense (and contradictory) scrutiny that is rarely applied to their male counterparts... More>>


  • PublicAddress
  • Pundit
  • Kiwiblog