Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Targeting High, Consistent Ethical Standards

Media Release
1 December 2005

Institute Targets High and Consistent Ethical Standards

Environmental professionals have been reminded of the need to be objective and set high ethical standards when acting on behalf of applicants for resource consents.

A seminar for environment professionals, including scientists, consultants and independent advisors has highlighted the role of ethics in achieving the best outcome for resource consent applicants, the environment and the community.

The one-day event in Christchurch was organised by the Environment Institute of Australia and New Zealand (EIANZ) as part of a programme of continuing professional development in an industry which is essentially unregulated. A range of presenters noted that while ethical standards are generally good, there are still some lingering problems, including:

- Selective referencing of information presented in assessments of environmental effects (AEEs)

- Omission of information that may not be favourable to the applicant’s case

- A tendency to advocate on behalf of clients, leading to a loss of objectivity and a more adversarial process which increases costs for all involved.

Former Environment Court Judge Peter Skelton says selective referencing was “more common than one might think” during his 22 years on the bench, but may have improved in recent years.

There had also been some significant cases of outright inaccuracy. “In one case an international expert from a prestigious institute gave evidence in an application for an LPG pipeline which sounded fine until it was reviewed by a University of Canterbury mathematician. It was found to have fundamental errors that caused a gross underestimating of environmental risks associated with proposal. If it had not been checked we would have been none the wiser, and the conditions placed on the approval could have been quite different.”

Peter Skelton said some expert witness make the mistake of advocating for an outcome. “It is often thought that expert witnesses are “hired guns” who will conveniently provide opinions to support a client’s case because they are being paid to do so.

“Unfortunately, such so-called expert witnesses are not unknown to the law and in particular to resource management litigation. However the great majority of expert witnesses do recognise their duty to be independent and thus retain their integrity and credibility.”

Peter Skelton says the resource consent process should have become less expensive and more efficient, with experience, but this had yet to occur. “It should be getting less adversarial, but it is not, and the problem is not in the way the Resource Management Act is worded.”

The EIANZ event urged environment practitioners to be vigilant on good ethical practice by taking a collegial approach and being open to advice and feedback from others.

Co-organiser Leo Fietje says the resource consent process is often hampered by misleading information, significant omissions and selective use of data, leading to increased need for review which results in time delays, increased costs and unnecessary stress all round.

“In my experience applicants who tell it like it is can easily halve the time taken to process their resource consents, because all of the information is there and there is no need for further investigation. In many cases a decision can be made in minutes if the applicant’s representative is thorough and objective.”

“We are essentially an unregulated profession in which people make a living by giving their professional advice, and so it is very important that we are able to self regulate through a professional body that provides guidance and encourages good professional practice.”

EIANZ is considering offering a similar event in other major centres, and may also form an ethics sub group to focus on further professional development.

The Environment Institute of Australia and New Zealand is an association of environmental practitioners established to facilitate interaction among environmental professionals; promote environmental knowledge and awareness; and advance ethical and competent environmental practice.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Why Big Spenders Are Not Our Tourism Salvation

Covid and climate change have been changing the face of tourism. That’s why it seemed oddly premature last week for Tourism Minister Stuart to announce that New Zealand isn’t interested in mass tourism any more, or in attracting the sort of budget visitors who “travel around our country on $10 a day eating two-minute noodles.” Instead, New Zealand aims to focus its marketing efforts on attracting wealthy, big spending tourists. “In terms of targeting our marketing spin,” Nash said, “it is unashamedly going to be at … High-quality tourists.” Really? The comments have raised a few eyebrows overseas, and a few hackles here at home. Nash’s comments have also been something of a gift to an Opposition adept at portraying the Ardern government as a bunch of liberal elitists out of touch with ordinary people...


National: The Heat Is On Tinetti As Strike Action Begins
The heat is on Internal Affairs Minister Jan Tinetti to front up and speak to firefighters as they prepare to take strike action today, National’s Fire and Emergency spokesperson Todd Muller says... More>>

National: Surgical Wait List Hits New Record
A new record has been set for New Zealanders waiting more than four months for surgery, National’s Health spokesperson Dr Shane Reti says... More>>

School Strike 4 Climate: Intergenerational Climate Strike On September 23rd
Once again School Strike for climate Ōtautahi (Christchurch) is asking all students to unite in a call to all council candidates to #voteclimate. Happening on Friday 23rd of September... More>>

Serious Fraud Office: Leave Sought To Appeal NZ First Foundation Decision
Leave has been sought to appeal the decision in the Serious Fraud Office’s NZ First Foundation prosecution... More>>

Government: Wage Growth Best On Record
Workers’ have experienced their biggest pay hike on record, outstripping inflation. Stats NZ figures show median weekly earnings from wages and salaries jumped by 8.8 percent in the June year... More>>

Human Rights Commission: Urgent Government Action Needed To Support Renters’ Human Rights
An immediate freeze on rent increases could give renters some reprieve during the cost-of-living crisis says Te Kahui Tika Tangata, the Human Rights Commission... More>>




InfoPages News Channels