Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


McAllister v Solicitor-General - Appeal on contempt of court

[Full judgment: McAllister_v_SolicitorGeneral.pdf]

[2013] NZHC 2217


Hearing: 12 August 2013
Appearances: D P H Jones QC and K Venning for Appellant
M Downs and A R van Echten for Respondent
Judgment: 29 August 2013

This judgment was delivered by me on 29 August 2013 at 4 pm,
pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.



[1] On 10 July 2013, Mr McAllister was selected to serve on a jury that was to hear a criminal case in the Auckland District Court. The case was to be presided over by Judge Dawson. Mr McAllister refused to take the oath or affirmation required to be taken by all persons who are selected to serve on a jury, and was stood down from the jury panel. After it subsequently became apparent that it would not be possible to select a juror to replace him, Mr McAllister relented and told the Judge he could serve on the jury after all. The Judge declined Mr McAllister’s offer, and aborted the trial.

[2] The following day the Judge held Mr McAllister to be in contempt for his acts, and sentenced him to ten days imprisonment.

[3] Mr McAllister appeals to this court against the Judge’s determination that he was in contempt of court. He also contends that the penalty the Judge imposed was manifestly excessive.


Summary: result

[91] I now summarise my conclusions and make the following orders:

1. Mr McAllister was in contempt when he refused to take the oath. His conduct was deliberate, and it interrupted the court process. It also disobeyed the Judge’s earlier direction requiring him to serve on the jury, and occurred in circumstances where Mr McAllister had no lawful excuse for doing what he did. The appeal against the Judge’s conclusion that Mr McAllister was guilty of contempt for refusing to take the oath is accordingly dismissed.

2. The appeal against the Judge’s conclusion that Mr McAllister was guilty of contempt for subsequently saying he could serve impartially on the jury is allowed.

3. The appeal against sentence is allowed, and the sentence of imprisonment is quashed. In its place Mr McAllister is fined the sum of $750.

[Full judgment: McAllister_v_SolicitorGeneral.pdf]

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Politics Of Why We’re Not Getting An Inquiry Into The White Island Disaster

The Ardern government has made an art form out of reviews and inquiries- when to hold them, when to fold them, and when to shelve the findings, virtually untouched. Among other things, the WorkSafe criminal proceedings into the Whakaari /White Island disaster look like the outcome of a conscious political strategy. The government is choosing this route instead holding a proper inquiry, because it can conveniently narrow the focus only to (a) the events prior to the eruption and (b) solely to possible violations of our labour laws... More>>


UN SDG: A Greener, Cleaner, Brighter Future

'The world has a high fever and is burning up. Climate disruption is daily news – from devastating wildfires to record floods. The damage to people and the environment is immense and growing.' - UN Secretary-General António Guterres ... More>>


Carbon Neutral Policy: Gov Declares Climate Emergency

The Government has launched a major new initiative to combat climate change that will require the public sector to achieve carbon neutrality by 2025. More>>


Pill Testing: Govt Moves On Drug Checking To Keep Young New Zealanders Safer This Summer

The Government will pass time limited legislation to give legal certainty to drug checking services, so they can carry out their work to keep New Zealanders safer this summer at festivals without fear of prosecution, Health Minister Andrew Little ... More>>


Tax: Government Fulfils Election Undertaking On New Top Tax Rate

The Government will today keep its election promise to put in place a new top tax rate of 39 per cent on income earned over $180,000. More>>


Media: Stuff Holds Itself Accountable For Wrongs To Māori

Stuff has today published the results of an investigation into itself, and issued a public apology, for the way the media organisation has portrayed Māori, the indigenous people of Aotearoa New Zealand, from its first editions to now. Tā Mātou Pono | More>>


Economy: Crown Accounts Reflect Govt’s Careful Economic Management

The better-than-expected Crown accounts released today show the Government’s careful management of the COVID-19 health crisis was the right approach to support the economy. As expected, the Crown accounts for the year to June 2020 show the operating balance ... More>>





InfoPages News Channels