Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Judgment: Pora (Appellant) v The Queen (Respondent)

PRESS SUMMARY

3 March 2015

Pora (Appellant) v The Queen (Respondent) [2015] UKPC 9

On appeal from the Court of Appeal of New Zealand

JUSTICES: Lord Kerr, Dame Sian Elias, Lord Reed, Lord Hughes and Lord Toulson

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

Susan Burdett was raped and murdered in her home in March 1992. In May 1994 Teina Pora (“the Appellant”) was convicted of the rape and murder of Ms Burdett and the aggravated burglary of her home. In 1999 the New Zealand Court of Appeal quashed his convictions and ordered a re-trial following the conviction of Malcolm Rewa on the charge of rape of Ms Burdett. In March 2000, after his second trial the Appellant was again found guilty. The Appellant appealed to the Court of Appeal against conviction unsuccessfully in October 2000. He now appeals from that decision.

On 18 March 1993 the Appellant, then aged 17, was interviewed by the police in relation to a stolen vehicle. In the course of this interview he asked whether the police had apprehended anyone for the murder of Ms Burdett. When he was told that they had not, he said that he knew who had committed the crime. There then followed a series of interviews over the course of four days during which the Appellant gave various accounts, first of his knowledge of and later his involvement in the burglary, rape and murder of Ms Burdett. These confessions were put to the jury in both of his trials by the Respondent as evidence of his guilt.

Mr Rewa was convicted of the attack on Ms Burdett on 17 December 1998. He has been convicted of 27 rapes in most of which he apparently acted as a lone predator. He suffered from erectile dysfunction, which the Appellant suggested explains his lone offending. The fact of his erectile dysfunction was not before the jury at the Appellant’s re-trial, although the thesis that he acted alone and the fact of his conviction for Ms Burdett’s rape were put to the jury.

The Appellant now appeals to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. He relied principally upon two grounds of appeal:

(1) Whether the confessions which he made concerning his complicity in the crimes have been shown to be unreliable by new evidence, in particular evidence that the Appellant suffers from a neurodevelopmental disorder; and

(2) Whether evidence of Mr Rewa’s erectile dysfunction should have been admitted at the appellant’s trial.

JUDGMENT

The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council humbly advises Her Majesty that the appeal against conviction should be allowed. Lord Kerr gives the advice of the Board.

REASONS FOR THE JUDGMENT

The Appellant sought to adduce evidence from Dr McGinn, a clinical neuropsychologist, and Dr Immelman, a psychiatrist. Dr McGinn concluded that the Appellant fulfils the diagnostic criteria of an alcohol-related neurodevelopmental disorder, consistent with undiagnosed foetal alcohol syndrome disorder (“FASD”). She noted that the Appellant’s executive mental functions, those required to plan and think through to the consequences of one’s actions, showed significant deficits. Her tests showed that the Appellant tended to respond without due consideration, especially in complex situations, that he tended to confabulate without realising that he was doing so and that, while he could not comprehend more complex words or sentences, he tended to respond as if he understood. In particular, she emphasised that persons with the Appellant’s condition could not be considered as reliable informants [37].

Dr Immelman found that the Appellant had great difficulty in understanding questions put to him and remembering the content of the question when composing his reply. He had no demonstrable capacity for abstract thought and a strong tendency to maintain a position even when it was shown to be entirely untenable [45]. He confirmed Dr McGinn’s diagnosis of the Appellant’s FASD and stated that this condition meant that responses in an interview setting can be unreliable [46].

The Board permitted the reports of both Dr Immelman and Dr McGinn to be admitted, on the grounds that the evidence that the Appellant suffered from a form of FASD, which could potentially have had a significant impact on the safety of the conviction, was not before the jury [40, 42, 48]. The overriding question was whether the evidence was relevant and reliable [41]. The Board held that, since this evidence was not before the jury at either of the Appellant’s trials, it meant that there was no explanation for his having confessed to the crimes [55]. In the absence of any explanation for giving a false confession, the intuitive reaction of a jury to a confession of guilt will be to assume that it is true [57]. The combination of the Appellant’s frequently contradictory and often implausible confessions with the diagnosis of FASD leads to the conclusion that reliance on his confessions gives rise to a risk of a miscarriage of justice. Therefore the Board deemed that his convictions must be quashed [58].

The Board refused to allow evidence of a third expert, Professor Gudjonsson, to be admitted on the grounds that he had exceeded his remit as an expert witness by asserting that the Appellant’s confessions were unreliable and advancing a theory as to why this was so [24]. It also refused to admit other evidence which the Appellant sought to adduce. Evidence from those involved in the investigation of Ms Burdett’s death was neither fresh, nor would it have been admissible at trial [50]. Affidavits from the Appellant were clearly not fresh evidence and of dubious credibility. In any case, there was no risk of a miscarriage of justice if they were excluded [49].

On the matter of Mr Rewa, the Board was not satisfied that the failure to adduce evidence of his erectile dysfunction at the Appellant’s retrial gave rise to a risk of miscarriage of justice. The suggestion that the jury would have been more disposed to find that the Appellant was not present because of Mr Rewa’s erectile dysfunction was speculative [54]. New evidence which the Appellant sought to adduce about Mr Rewa’s erectile dysfunction was therefore not relevant to the safety of the Appellant’s conviction and inadmissible [51].

The Board also gave the parties the opportunity to make written submissions as to whether a re-trial of the Appellant should take place [60].

References in square brackets are to paragraphs in the judgment.

NOTE

This summary is provided to assist in understanding the Committee’s decision. It does not form part of the reasons for that decision. The full opinion of the Committee is the only authoritative document. Judgments are public documents and are available at: www.jcpc.uk/decided-cases/index.html.

Scoop copy of judgment: JCPC_2013_0081_Judgment.pdf

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On National's Great Leap Backwards

It isn’t surprising that at the height of its disarray, National should have looked for certainty and picked the least introspective candidate on offer. With Judith Collins, there is absolutely no risk that the leader will suddenly have an angst attack about whether they’re really up to the job. You would have to go all the way back to Robert Muldoon to find a National Party leader less prone to self-doubt, and more willing to use fear as a weapon to maintain discipline within the rank and file... More>>

 

Gordon Campbell: On The Todd Muller Resignation

Given the factions within National’s own caucus, anyone picked as the new leader of the National Party will struggle to unify their own troops, let alone to convince the electorate that National is a coherent government-in-waiting. Even all of that ... More>>

Green Party: Unveils Clean Energy Plan

The Green Party is today unveiling part one of its plan for a fossil-fuel free Aotearoa, including an immediate ban on new industrial coal boilers. To ensure a just transition away from fossil-fuels, the Green Party’s Clean Energy Plan will: Establish a Clean ... More>>

ALSO:

National Departures: Press Statement From Michelle Boag

Today I am announcing that I have resigned my membership of the NZ National Party. The last few days have underscored for me the unhealthy relationship I have developed with politics. For 47 years, I have devoted much of my professional and personal ... More>>

ALSO:

Govt: Statement From Rt Hon Winston Peters

Deputy Prime Minister and New Zealand First Leader Rt Hon Winston Peters has announced he is taking a short stint of medical leave this week. More>>


Isolation: Government And Air NZ Agree To Manage Incoming Bookings

Bookings for seats on Air New Zealand flights into New Zealand will be managed in the short term to ensure the Government is able to safely place New Zealanders arriving home into a managed isolation or quarantine facility, says Housing Minister Megan ... More>>

ALSO:

Government: New Investment Creates Over 2000 Jobs To Clean Up Waterways

A package of 23 projects across the country will clean up waterways and deliver over 2000 jobs Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Environment Minister David Parker announced today. The $162 million dollar package will see 22 water clean-up projects ... More>>

ALSO:

Eenrgy & Environment: Snail Like Progress On Government Vehicle Emissions Targets

First published in Energy and Environment on June 2, 2020. The latest data on the Government’s attempts to reduce the emissions of its transport fleet show no discernible progress. The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment’s data on reducing ... More>>

Conservation: New Protection For Dolphins

Extensive new protections are being put in place as part of an updated plan to look after New Zealand’s native Hector’s and Māui dolphins, announced Minister of Fisheries Stuart Nash and Minister of Conservation Eugenie Sage today. More>>

ALSO:

David Seymour: ACT Leader's Address To Election Campaign Launch - ASB Waterfront Theatre, 12 July 2020

Introduction Thank you very much. Elections in New Zealand – like everywhere - are a very special tradition, because they are driven by you. They’re an opportunity to change your future. If you think about it, the Government doesn’t do much. It ... More>>

Foreign Affairs: New Zealand To Review Relationship Settings With Hong Kong

Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters has announced that the New Zealand Government is reviewing the settings of its relationship with Hong Kong. “China’s decision to pass a new national security law for Hong Kong has fundamentally changed the environment ... More>>

ALSO:


Covid-19 Patient Info Leak: Hamish Walker - A Personal Statement And An Apology

I have spoken to National Party Leader Todd Muller and informed him that I passed to members of the media, by email, information containing Covid-19 patient details that was given to me by a source. I did this to expose the Government’s shortcomings ... More>>

ALSO:

Economy: Infrastructure Investment To Create Jobs, Kick-Start COVID Rebuild

A new package of infrastructure investments will help kick-start the post-COVID rebuild by creating more than 20,000 jobs and unlocking more than $5 billion of projects up and down New Zealand. Finance Minister Grant Robertson and Infrastructure Minister ... More>>

ALSO:

Covid-19: Isolation System To Be Beefed Up After Stress

A range of improvements are already underway to address issues identified in the rapid review of the Managed Isolation and Quarantine system released today, Housing Minister Megan Woods said. The review was commissioned just over a week ago to identify ... More>>

ALSO:

Election 2020: Parties Get Into Gear

ACT has today announced its list for the 2020 General Election. “The calibre and experience of our candidates will impress voters of every persuasion. We have candidates from all walks of life. People who have built their homes, families and businesses ... More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 


 

InfoPages News Channels