Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


National Standards no model for Social Services delivery

National Standards no model for Social Services delivery

Martin Thrupp

It was astonishing to see Social Development Minister Anne Tolley recently suggest on the Q+A programme that National Standards provided a model for public service targets for the delivery of social services. Actually it’s the limitations of the National Standards policy that are much more instructive. They have mostly been a distraction in education and a social services version is likely to be worse if it involves payment by results.

To start with, the National Standards do not provide clear targets. They involve a crude scale with four very broad categories of achievement. In reading, writing or maths, your child is just ‘well below’, ‘below’ ‘at’ or ‘above’. These simplistic labels make a mockery of the assessment that teachers do beneath them.

Even so, research has been showing that a child judged ‘at’ by one school will often be judged ‘below’ at another. Schools have diverse characteristics that colour teachers’ judgements. National Standards also leave out important aspects of primary schooling. Overall it’s wise to shy away from using the published results to compare schools or judge their performance.

The Minister would have been better off using the National Standards to remind us how difficult it will be to devise useful measurable targets for the social services. What constitutes ‘success’ with vulnerable groups in particular contexts will often be hard to capture.

The National Standards are also time-consuming for teachers and principals to administer. There is a lot of checking and moderation, especially where schools are most earnest about getting them right. There is opportunity cost with this preoccupation and the same likely danger for social services of being required to fiddle while Rome burns.

Thankfully the National Standards policy has not yet become closely linked to performance pay or school closures. Research on high-stakes accountability in education shows that moving in this direction would have increasingly perverse effects such as curriculum narrowing and fabrication of assessment data.

Payment by results in the social services will lead to similarly predictable outcomes. Agencies will prioritise the meeting of targets over any broader view of success with the groups they are supposed to be serving. Contractors can be expected to give preference to easier social services work, just as private providers tend to do in the education sector.

Few people are in a position to really understand the workings of National Standards. The same would be true of performance against social services indicators and targets. It will be too easy to be seduced by the tidy rows of figures and not question what lies beneath them.
So if the National Standards are no model to be followed, what’s the alternative? In education, National Standards divert attention from inadequate resources and the hollowing out of professional culture. Reinvestment in those areas, for instance reintroducing a cadre of school advisors on permanent rather than short term contracts, would make a big difference.

It may not be politically fashionable at the moment but a reinvestment in resources and professional culture seems to be what’s needed in New Zealand’s public social services as well. Inequality is creating an increasingly intractable problem as new generations become raised in poverty. It is unrealistic to expect payment by results to be genuinely feasible, nor any silver bullet.

Martin Thrupp is Professor of Education at the University of Waikato


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Madrid Climate Talks: Decade Ending 2019 Likely To Be Hottest On Record

Exceptional global heat driven by greenhouse gas emissions mean this decade will most likely go down as the warmest on record, according to the World Meteorological Organization...

The agency also finds that 2019 is on track to be the second or third warmest year in history, with the global average temperature during January through October, roughly 1.1 degrees Celsius above the pre-industrial era.

“If we do not take urgent climate action now, then we are heading for a temperature increase of more than 3°C by the end of the century, with ever more harmful impacts on human wellbeing.” More>>


NZ First Conflicts Of Interest: New Details Around Timeline

New information has emerged showing it was the New Zealand First chief of staff who identified potential conflicts of interest between a forestry company and two senior government ministers, sparking a series of declarations. More>>



Five New Cancer Meds In Six Months: Pharmac Funds More Cancer Medicines, Faster Assessment

PHARMAC has confirmed that two new medicines – olaparib for ovarian cancer and fulvestrant for breast cancer – have been approved for funding... Rituximab and bortezomib, which are already funded, have also been approved for widened access following successful commercial proposals from new suppliers. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Stoking Fears About Cannabis Law Reform

It was always going to be hard to have a rational debate on cannabis reform. Far easier for politicians to win votes by stoking alarm... More>>


Tūhoronuku Mandate Recognition Ends: "New Opportunity" For Ngāpuhi Treaty Negotiations

The Crown is providing an opportunity for the hapu of Ngāpuhi to rebuild its framework from the ground up for collective negotiations to deal with its historical Treaty claims... More>>


Pike River: Next Phase Of Recovery Underway

“Fresh air will be pumped into the Pike River Mine drift this week, following acceptance of the plan for re-entry beyond the 170m barrier by New Zealand’s independent health and safety regulator WorkSafe." More>>


Peters Stoic: Russia On Afghan Firing Range Deaths

The foreign minister won't be calling in the Russian ambassador concerning comments made about New Zealand soldiers in Afghanistan. In a media briefing late last month, Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova said New Zealand must investigate crimes against civilians. More>>


Christchurch Call: Online Crisis Response Workshop In Wellington

Governments and tech companies are holding a two-day workshop, hosted by YouTube/Google in Wellington, to test the Christchurch Call Shared Crisis Response Protocol. More>>





InfoPages News Channels