Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Judgment: H (SC 97/2018) v The Queen

3 July 2019


H (SC 97/2018) v THE QUEEN

(SC 97/2018) [2019] NZSC 69


This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court’s judgment. It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment. The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document. The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at Judicial Decisions of Public Interest www.courtsofnz.govt.nz


This judgment is subject to a suppression order under s 203 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011. The publication of the names, addresses, occupations or identifying particulars of the complainants is therefore prohibited. The appellant’s name is not suppressed. However, the Court refers to him as Mr H in this press release and in the judgment because otherwise, given their relationship to Mr H, the complainants could be identified.


Mr H was convicted in 2017, after a jury trial, of eight charges of sexual offending against his sister “Dianna” and his daughter “Emily” (not their real names). The offending is historic and took place over a period of two decades. The earliest offending, a rape of Dianna, occurred between 1 December 1955 and 21 July 1959. At the time of the rape, Mr H was aged between 16 and a half and 20 years old and Dianna between four and eight years old.

At issue in this appeal is whether the charge of rape should have been dismissed under s 322 of the Oranga Tamariki Act 1989 because it may have been committed when Mr H was a “young person” (for these purposes a person aged between 14 and 17).

In summary, s 322 provides that a charge against a young person may be dismissed if the time that has elapsed between the date of the commission of the alleged offence and the hearing has been unnecessarily or unduly protracted.

Both prior to trial in the High Court and at the end of the Crown case, Mr H applied for a stay of proceedings and a dismissal of the charges under s 147 of the Criminal Procedure Act because of the delay in bringing the charges. The High Court declined both applications.

The Court of Appeal dismissed Mr H’s appeal against his subsequent convictions. In particular, the Court of Appeal held that the charge of rape should not have been dismissed under s 322 of the Oranga Tamariki Act as that provision did not apply to Mr H because he was charged as an adult. It said that s 322 applied only to cases before the Youth Court. Even if it did apply, s 322 would have little bearing on the case because Mr H had long been a mature adult. Finally, there were no other factors that could not be considered under the stay or s 147 dismissal procedures.

The Supreme Court has unanimously dismissed Mr H’s appeal against the Court of Appeal’s decision.

The Supreme Court’s decision

The Crown and Mr H both accepted before the Supreme Court that s 322 applied to Mr H because ss 2(2)(d) and 2(3) of the Oranga Tamariki Act provide that s 322, with all necessary modifications, applies to persons charged as adults with an offence committed as a young person. The Supreme Court agreed.

The Crown and Mr H both submitted that there would have to be an element of fault (usually on the part of the Crown) for proceedings to be “unnecessarily protracted”, but this did not apply to the phrase “unduly protracted”. The Supreme Court accepted this was the case. It found that in Mr H’s case, while there was no question of fault on the part of the Crown, the proceedings had been unduly protracted in terms of s 322.

Mr H argued that s 322 should have been considered by the High Court when deciding whether to stay the proceeding or dismiss it under s 147 of the Criminal Procedure Act.

The Court did not accept this submission. While there could be common factors to be considered under s 322 of the Oranga Tamariki Act and under applications for stay or dismissal under s 147 of the Criminal Procedure Act, s 322 should be exercised independently.

The Supreme Court held that s 322 should be applied consistently with those youth justice principles still applicable to accused persons who are over the age of 17 at the time they are charged.

The Court accepted Mr H’s submission that the general object set out in s 4(f)(ii) of the Oranga Tamariki Act is still relevant to those charged as adults. This provides that, where children or young persons commit offences, they are dealt with in a way that gives them the opportunity to develop in responsible, beneficial, and socially acceptable ways.

The reasons behind the principle contained in s 5(f) of the Oranga Tamariki Act, (that decisions should be made in a timeframe appropriate to a child’s or young person’s sense of time), will also still be relevant to those charged as adults. One important reason for the s 5(f) principle is to enable rehabilitation to occur in line with the general object in s 4(f)(ii). It also recognises that there are particular factors related to the stage of development that may have contributed to the offending of the child and young person which may be seen as reducing or explaining culpability and also as meaning rehabilitation is more likely.

The Court, however, refused to exercise the s 322 discretion to dismiss the charges against Mr H because the charge in question was very serious, Mr H was not very young at the time of the offending, being at least 16 and a half, and because he had continued to offend in a similar manner for an extended period after the rape of Dianna, showing that rehabilitation had not occurred.

Scoop copy of judgment: 2019NZSC69.pdf

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Virtues (and Fluffed Opportunities) Of The Operation Burnham Report

One unspoken rule of thumb in any official public inquiry is : whatever you do, don’t conclude you were made to listen to “a litany of lies” even if the evidence of a deliberate cover-up is right there under your nose. In that respect, the report into the 2010 Operation Burnham military raid in Afghanistan has been a model of decorum. Bad stuff did happen and has been duly noted and lamented - but only as a lapse and departure from usual professional standards. Normal service can be trusted to resume shortly... More>>


Environment: Govt Progress On Climate Change Essential, Risk Assessment Shows

The release of the National Climate Change Risk Assessment shows that the progress this Government has made to solve the climate crisis is essential to creating cleaner and safer communities across New Zealand. “Because of this report, we can see clearer ... More>>

Economy: Investing In The Tourism Sector’s Recovery

More than $300 million in funding has been approved to protect strategic tourism businesses, drive domestic tourism through regional events and lift digital capability in the tourism industry, Tourism Minister Kelvin Davis announced today. A $400 million ... More>>


National On MP Bill: Waka-Jumping Repeal Bill Passes First Reading

The Electoral (Integrity Repeal) Amendment Bill has passed its first reading, marking one step closer to Parliament getting rid of NZ First’s ‘waka-jumping’ legislation, National List MP David Carter says. “I’d like to thank the Greens for voting ... More>>


Covid-19:Legislation For Managed Isolation Payments Introduced

Hon Dr Megan Woods Minister of Housing Legislation to allow the Government to recover some of the costs for managed isolation and quarantine will be introduced to Parliament today, said Minister of Housing Megan Woods. “The Bill will allow the government ... More>>


General Election 2020: Newshub-Reid Research Poll Shows Labour Stratospheric And National In Freefall

The latest Newshub-Reid research poll* shows the National party’s leadership crises have catapulted Labour to its highest heights in this poll’s history. It has climbed to 60.9% - an increase of 4.4 percentage points. And National has been punished, ... More>>


Economy: 30% Believe Households Worse Off, 298,000 Expect To Lose Jobs

64% of New Zealanders feel the economic position of their households is the same or better than a year ago – and 30% think it is worse or much worse, while 298,000 think they will lose their jobs in the next 12 months. Households’ perceptions ... More>>

State Services Commission: Findings Of Investigation Into COVID-19 Active Cases Privacy Breach

Deputy State Services Commissioner Helene Quilter has today announced the findings of an investigation into a breach of privacy regarding sensitive personal information. The investigation looked into who or what caused the disclosure of the information, ... More>>

International Security: New Zealand Suspends Extradition Treaty With Hong Kong

The New Zealand Government has suspended its extradition treaty with Hong Kong and made a number of other changes in light of China’s decision to pass a national security law for Hong Kong, Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters says. More>>


Energy: 100% Renewable Electricity Grid Explored With Pumped Storage ‘battery’

The Government is taking a significant step toward its goal for 100% renewable electricity generation in a move that could be a game changer for consumers and the creation of a low-emissions economy, Energy & Resources Minister Megan Woods said. ... More>>


Election 2020: Campaign Launches

The Green Party has launched its policy platform. Think Ahead, Act Now: Our Green Vision for Aotearoa was unveiled by Co-leaders Marama Davidson and James Shaw at the party’s Annual General Meeting this morning. Marama Davidson said today: “In ... More>>






InfoPages News Channels