Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Transparency, oversight and engagement

Transparency, oversight and engagement – supporting public trust in government

Within months, the coronavirus became a global public health threat and source of unprecedented economic dislocation. In this crisis, people have looked to government to respond with effective measures to protect public health and offer some relief from the widely felt economic hardship. Citizens have also looked to government for timely and reliable information to protect themselves, their families and their communities. In short, on top of the major challenges to public health and livelihoods, the crisis has also “put to the test”, in quite stark terms, public trust in government. Some governments have risen to the occasion. Others have not, with dire consequences for citizens.

In this context, the release this week of the 2019 Open Budget Survey (OBS) report is particularly timely. In its 7th biennial report since 2006, with global coverage of 117 countries, the Washington-based International Budget Partnership (IBP) and its network of independent country researchers provide a comprehensive assessment of three key elements underlying public trust in government:

the scope and timelines of public access to substantive and reliable information about government finances and policies;

the strength of public sector accountability mechanisms through legislative oversight and independent audit; and

the scope and quality of opportunities for direct public engagement with government during budget formulation and implementation, as well as in legislative review and audit processes.

NZ’s performance in 2019 OBS – consistent strengths and persistent areas in need of improvement

Consistent strengths
• New Zealand continues its streak atop the “headline” Open Budget Index (OBI) focusing on the availability of information about government finances, now reaching its 4th consecutive round (since 2012). An OBI score of 88 (out of 100) earns NZ a share of the top spot with South Africa (as in the 2017 round). Underlying NZ’s consistently strong performance in budget/fiscal transparency are a legal framework in which comprehensive legal requirements are embedded (Public Finance Act) and application of robust accrual accounting practices to public accounts.

• Survey questions underlying the OBI focus on public availability of information across 8 “key documents” covering the full budget cycle. New Zealand’s consistently high rank in the OBI can be primarily attributed to content of its Budget Policy Statement (BPS) at the start of the budget cycle, the package of budget documentation presented on Budget Day (including both the Estimates and BEFU), as well as the mid-year report (HYEFU) and OAG’s annual audit report for central government. All of these perform well against specific OBI criteria.

• The scope and strength of OAG audit oversight is also an area of consistently solid performance.

Persistent areas in need of improvement
• Accessibility vs availability of information – Unpacking the consistently strong overall OBI scores reveals some of the 8 “key documents” continuing to “underperform”. In particular, “Citizens Budget” documentation is still not meeting expectations for making information about Government policies and finances broadly accessible (or attractive) to “non-specialists”. The BEFU, HYEFU, Financial Statements are rightly recognised as rich sources of information for “specialists” or other particularly dedicated readers, and Treasury’s recently developed “Basics” series is certainly a step in the right direction to make some of the content of these three documents more accessible to a broader audience. But both the presentation and scope of information in the “Basics” documents stand to be improved. Meanwhile, another clear opportunity exists to more effectively communicate information about public resources to a broader audience by greater investment in web-based data visualisations (“info-graphics”).

• Will Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO) help to strengthen Parliamentary oversight? Parliamentary oversight in New Zealand has, in recent OBS rounds, been assessed as either “weak” or “limited”. Although 2019 OBS results deliver an improved assessment of “adequate”, the same underlying institutional challenges remain for this critical dimension of public sector accountability. The PBO, to be operational from July 2021, could constitute a significant institutional change, with potential to bolster relatively constrained/weak legislative oversight. But it remains to be seen whether PBO’s mandate, capacity and activities will extend beyond a narrow electoral cycle-focus on costing party platform proposals. Opportunities exist for PBO to support more regular/routine Parliamentary review processes across the budget cycle.

• Opportunities for routine annual public engagement/dialogue with Government remain limited – The 2019 OBS assesses opportunities for public engagement with each of the three core public sector “segments” – Government (executive), Parliament and OAG. The latest OBS results show the composite score slipping (from 59 to 54), indicating an overall lack of “adequate” opportunities for public engagement in budget processes on a routine annual basis (noting score of 60 as the cut-off “adequate”). But trends for the three specific “segments” are quite distinct, with OAG holding steady at 67, Parliament increasing significantly from 59 to 78. Meanwhile, the scope for public engagement with Government during both budget formulation and implementation has dropped sharply from borderline “adequate” (59 in the 2017 OBS) to “few” (33 in the 2019 OBS). To an extent, the observed patterns reflect the specific focus of OBS assessment criteria, which only allow for consideration of engagement opportunities that occur on a routine annual basis and which focus on Government (executive) engagement on the part of either Treasury or possibly SSC. Parliamentary and OAG tend to maintain relatively routine annual mechanisms for public engagement, with Parliamentary process obviously focusing on hearings, and the scores from one OBS round to the next depending largely on documentable evidence of actual public engagement in the form of written submissions and/or oral testimony. In the case of OAG, public engagement comes through public submissions during formulation of the annual audit work-plan and OAG’s consultation with the public during the conduct of certain types of audits. Those processes have not varied much, if at all, from year to year.

For the Government (executive), it is a different story. In short, the 2019 OBS results reflect the discontinuation of two panels previously operating under Treasury management (but inclusive of a few outside experts) having a role in evaluating certain proposed budget initiatives. For budget implementation, a curtailment in the scope of reporting for the KiwisCount survey for public services contributes to the declining score. On a more general level, the results reflect Treasury’s primary commitment to substantive public engagement for specific “events” that are not part of routine annual budget processes, such as the periodic Investment Statement and Long-Term Fiscal Statement (both legally mandated by the PFA to be produced at least once every four years) or for specific major policy reviews such as the Tax Working Group. Generally, in such cases when Treasury does engage with the public in a consultative process, the process tends to be thorough, substantive and inclusive. The fundamental problem (at least in terms of meeting OBS standards) is that Treasury (or Government) does not appear to perceive broad (“open”) public consultation (as two-way “dialogue”) to be an integral part of routine annual processes for budget formulation, while consultative processes for service delivery (budget implementation) is generally viewed as being more in the domain of sector-specific agencies rather than specifically a Treasury (or central agency) responsibility.

Closer look at OBI segment points to important opportunities, including some “low hanging fruit”

The 2109 OBS results show New Zealand continuing to be a high performer in the “headline” OBI assessing public availability of information. However, results for specific OBI questions also point to the persistence of specific gaps in public availability of essential information, gaps well within the Government’s (Treasury’s) capacity to address. These include:

strengthening web-based data visualisations (“info-graphics”) making extensive information about sources and use of public funds contained in dense budget documents more readily accessible and informative, beyond limited existing options on Treasury or Budget websites;

improving the scope and presentation of information in plain-language “Basics” series (for BEFU, HYEFU and year-end Financial Statements), to include not just “fiscal aggregates”, but also sector and policy-specic spending and a presentation format that encourages broader public interest, accessibility and engagement, including attention to narrative "story-lines";

making public a comprehensive budget calendar, before the annual budget cycle begins, inclusive of designated entry points for broad-based public consultations on policy priorities;

developing “alternative displays” of public spending illustrating the distribution of either total spending or for specific sectors or policies according to a given characteristic such as income, poverty status, gender, ethnicity, age cohort or geographic jurisdiction, noting the potential alignment such “alternative displays” could have to the “wellbeing” budget framework;

increasing the scope mid-year (and other in-year) reporting on spending for specific programs;

providing comparisons of macroeconomic forecasts and actual outcomes in annual year-end reporting, with explanation for variances;

reporting estimates of forgone revenue for a broader range of tax expenditures in the annual Tax Expenditure Statement (TES); noting, in particular, substantial growth in use of the tax system to deliver targeted relief to businesses and households as part of COVID-19 Response;

Producing the Open Budget Survey – an 18-month global effort

The results released this week are the product an intensive 18-month effort involving:

collection and review of extensive documentation and data, not only for the OBI’s 8 “key documents”, but also including Parliamentary transcripts and submissions, OAG advice provided to MPs/select committees and available evidence/reporting on public consultative processes;

completion of the 150+ survey questions by country researchers, including direct engagement with relevant executive, legislative and audit entity officials for clarifications and verifications;

submission of completed questionnaires for both independent peer and government review;

responding to all comments and alternative assessments raised by reviewers;

tabulating results as scores and rankings, conducting analysis and drafting reporting materials;

and finally, the dissemination of findings for discussions among stakeholders.







© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Twitter Wars, And The Muller Muddles

Whatever the failings of our own politicians, spare a kind thought for the majority of Americans who did not vote for Donald Trump. Sure, it was depressing this week to watch Todd Muller clinging for dear life to his talking points on Q&A, lest he be carried away in the slavering jaws of Jack Tame…. but this was mere incompetence, not malice. At the same time the President of the United States was (a) falsely accusing one of his media critics of murder, and (b) threatening to shut down Twitter for attaching a warning label to Trump’s attempt at poisoning the electoral process by falsely claiming that postal voting has led to extensive voter fraud... More>>


Government: Freshwater Package Backed By Comprehensive Economic Analysis

Decisions on the Action for Healthy Waterways package are supported by comprehensive environmental and economic impact analysis by leading New Zealand research institutes, universities, and private sector firms. More>>


National: "Todd Muller Announces Shape Of Next Government"

National Party Leader Todd Muller has announced the line-up of the next Government. “New Zealand is facing perhaps the toughest time that almost anyone alive can remember. “We are borrowing tens of billions of dollars to get us through this crisis. There ... More>>


Lockdown Rules: Timeline For Moving To Level 1 Needed

The BusinessNZ Network is calling for more clarity about the conditions under which businesses can move to Covid level 1. The network is concerned about large numbers of businesses that are at risk of closure if restrictions continue at the current ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On National’s Day Of Reckoning

Congratulations. You are one of the 55 members of the National caucus being called together tomorrow to choose who will lead you to either (a) catastrophic or (b) honourable defeat on September 19, thereby saving some (but not all) of the jobs currently on the line. Good luck. Your decision process starts NOW... More>>


Budget 2020: Jobs Budget To Get Economy Moving Again

Investments to both save and create jobs in Budget 2020 mean unemployment can be back to pre COVID-19 levels within two years and could see the economy growing again as early as next year. More>>


Covid-19 Response: Law Setting Up Legal Framework For Covid-19 Alert Level 2 Passes

The law establishing a legal framework for the response to Covid-19 has passed its final reading and will become law in time for the move to Alert Level 2 tonight.
This is a bespoke Act designed specifically to stop the spread of COVID-19... More>>


Trans-Tasman Bubble: PMs Jacinda And Morrison Announce Plans

Australia and New Zealand are committed to introducing a trans-Tasman COVID-safe travel zone as soon as it is safe to do so, Prime Minister Rt Hon Jacinda Ardern and Prime Minister the Hon Scott Morrison MP have announced... More>>


Government: Support For Arts And Music Sector Recovery

A jobseekers programme for the creative sector and four new funds have been set up by the Government to help our arts and music industry recover from the blow of COVID-19. Thousands of jobs will be supported through today’s $175 million package ... More>>


Government: New Zealand Joins Global Search For COVID-19 Vaccine

Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters, Research, Science and Innovation Minister Megan Woods, and Health Minister David Clark today announced a COVID-19 vaccine strategy, which will enable New Zealand scientists to contribute to global research efforts ... More>>


The Dig: Steady State Economics: We’ve Got Some (systems) Thinking To Do

In this time of impending economic and ecological crises, we urgently need to aim for a sustainable or ‘steady state’ economy. In order to get there, we will need to adopt a ‘systems-thinking’ outlook taking into account the interconnections of our complex world.

In short, we’ve got some systems thinking to do... More>>


Election 2020: Parties Get Into gear

The Green Party is pleased to reveal its candidate list for the upcoming election. With a mix of familiar faces and fresh new talent, this exceptional group of candidates are ready to lead the Greens back into Government. Using the most democratic list ... More>>


Insight Into Regenerative Agriculture In New Zealand

There is a fast growing movement in New Zealand that has been happening out in paddocks, fields, gardens and hill country across the nation. It is a movement that holds the promise to reshape our productive land use industries towards systems that work with the natural environment to regenerate the land. The movement is that of regenerative agriculture. More>>


Covid-19: Tracer App Released To Support Contact Tracing

The Ministry of Health has today formally released the NZ COVID Tracer app to support contact tracing in New Zealand. Kiwis who download the app will create a digital diary of the places they visit by scanning QR codes displayed at the entrances to ... More>>


Govt: Deep Concern At Hong Kong National Security Legislation
Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters today reiterated the deep concern of the New Zealand Government following confirmation by China’s National People’s Congress of national security legislation relating to Hong Kong.... More>>






InfoPages News Channels