Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Health and Safety Sentencing Inconsistent?


Health and Safety Sentencing Inconsistent?

Employers who plead not guilty to a breach of health and safety law may end up getting a lighter sentence if found guilty than those who admit an offence.

The latest issue of health and safety newsletter Safeguard Update says this is in spite of the Sentencing Act making it clear that a guilty plea must be seen as a mitigating circumstance when sentencing.

Safeguard Update says while no two prosecutions are comparable in all respects, research shows that the courts may sometimes be persuaded to take a softer stance if they have heard the defence case argued.

In one example a company recently pleaded guilty to failing to notify a serious harm accident and was fined $3,000. Another company which pleaded not guilty to the same offence was fined $1,000.

Two other employers were charged after workers had their arms crushed in conveyor belts at each company. The company which pleaded not guilty was fined $10,000, while the company which pleaded guilty was fined $30,000. Both had previous convictions for similar incidents and the reparation ordered was almost identical.

“The timing of a guilty plea is important, with most credit expected to be given to those who save the courts time and money by admitting responsibility at the first opportunity,” Safeguard Update says.

“Again, however, the reality doesn’t always match up, with some judges giving full credit for late, and even last minute, plea changes, and sentences seldom showing any significant advantage associated with an early admission of guilt.”

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

NIWA: Scientists Say Methane Emitted By Humans ‘vastly Underestimated’

NIWA researchers have helped unlock information trapped in ancient air samples from Greenland and Antarctica that shows the amount of methane humans are emitting into the atmosphere from fossil fuels has been vastly underestimated... More>>

ALSO:

SMC Expert Reaction: Record Dry Spells And Effects On Forests

With no rain forecast before Sunday, Auckland is about to break a record for the city's longest dry spell. Niwa says Auckland is likely to hit 40 consecutive days without rain this weekend . The upper North Island is seeing severe meterological ... More>>

ALSO:

Reserve Bank: Official Cash Rate Remains At 1.0 Percent

The Monetary Policy Committee has decided to keep the Official Cash Rate (OCR) at 1.0 percent. Employment is at or slightly above its maximum sustainable level while consumer price inflation is close to the 2 percent mid-point of our target range. ... More>>

ALSO:



Science Media Centre: Novel Coronavirus Detected In China – Expert Reaction

The virus was detected after more than 40 people were hospitalised with pneumonia in Wuhan City, China and the outbreak traced to a large animal and seafood market. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that person-to-person transmission ... More>>

ALSO:

Science Media Centre: Flooding could release toxic gas – Expert Reaction

A chemical substance known as ouvea premix stored at an old paper mill in Mataura could release toxic ammonia gas if it comes in contact with water.More>>

ALSO: