Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


“Smacking” legal opinion hides real problem

“Smacking” legal opinion hides real problem

18th November 2014

In seeking to challenge and clarify the legal interpretation of section 59, the conservative political lobby group, Family First, are once more attempting to deny the very real psychological impact of physical discipline on our children.

“It’s a shame Family First have to put such a spin on this issue as it leaves little room for reasoned debate and a consideration of the fairly overwhelming empirical science in the area” says New Zealand Association of Psychotherapists Public Issues spokesperson, Kyle MacDonald. “It’s not a question of whether parents who use physical discipline are good parents, but whether smacking kids is good parenting: in other words does it work and does it have any harmful consequences?”

On this, the research is clear, and getting clearer. Studies have looked at the effect of physical discipline on short term compliance, long term compliance and its effects on aggression. There is evidence that smacking has a small effect on short term compliance, however non-smacking alternatives like “time outs” work at least as well, if not better. However this comes at quite a cost, in short, smacking makes kids worse behaved over time and more likely to see physical violence and aggression as a way to solve their own interpersonal problems.

The research is also clear that even ‘light’ smacking has been associated with increases in child aggression, delinquent and antisocial behavior, and increased aggression as an adult. It is also linked with a decreased quality of relationship between parent and child, decreased child mental health and worse mental health outcomes as an adult. It can even negatively impact school performance.

“The research shows that even so called light smacking can, and does, have lasting consequences,” says Kyle MacDonald. “To ‘decriminalise’ the use of physical discipline creates a legal and cultural sanction for a parenting strategy that we know creates harm. That’s not only bad parenting, but bad policy.”


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Finding A Model To Replace The Monarchy

One feels reluctant to pre-empt the verdict of history, but maybe we need to have a Plan B in mind just in case the reign of King Charles III turns out badly. With that possibility in mind, are there any other countries that do a reasonably good job of electing their ceremonial head of state? There is no perfect model for New Zealand to follow but - arguably - Ireland has made a pretty good fist of it over the past 70 years or so. Ireland has roughly the same population as New Zealand, so the pool of talent is similar in size...

Alastair Thompson: Are There TPLF Ethiopia Insurgency Training & Support Operations in Uganda?

Mystery Document Alleges:
Covert Operation has US/Egypt Support
Operations Coordinated between South Sudan, TPLF and Uganda
Planning began December 2021...



Government: Welcomes Climate Change Commission Advice On Agricultural Pricing System
The Government has welcomed advice from the Climate Change Commission assessing readiness in the agricultural sector for an emissions pricing system... More>>


Government: Action To Tackle Delays In Family Court
New legislation aimed at tackling delays in the family justice system, will help improve the wellbeing of thousands of children caught up in Family Court disputes every year, Justice Minister Kiri Allan says... More>>

Prime Minister: Chatham House Speech
What an honour it is to be back in London, and to be here at Chatham house. This visit represents much for me. The reopening of borders and resumption of travel after a difficult few years... More>>

Economy: Financial Statements Of The Government Of New Zealand
Please note the next Financial Statements of the Government of New Zealand to be released will be for the full year ended 30 June 2022. It is anticipated that these will be released in early October 2022... More>>

Government: New Era For Better Health In Aotearoa New Zealand

The Government has today delivered a nationwide health system that will ensure better outcomes for all New Zealanders with the establishment of Te Whatu Ora - Health New Zealand... More>>

Greens: Alcohol Harm Minimisation Bill Pulled From Biscuit Tin

After years of research and advocacy, Parliament will finally consider legislation to take meaningful action on alcohol harm, says the Greens... More>>




InfoPages News Channels