Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Judge soft on global child rape trade

Judge with a history of weak sentences soft on global child rape trade

A group that has spent years campaigning for tougher penalties for those who fuel the global child rape trade has condemned what it describes as “another shocking” decision.

In the Auckland District Court, Judge Philippa Cunningham today declined to imprison a 50-year-old Auckland “professional”, despite him being caught with 6063 videos and still images of child sex abuse material.

One report stated that “so appalling was the nature of the abuse” that Judge Cunningham chose not to view it. Stop Demand founder Denise Ritchie says “It beggars belief that Judge Cunningham refused to review the material because it was of such an ‘appalling’ nature, then proceeded to treat the offender so leniently.”

Facing a sentence of up to 10 years in prison, the offender was given seven months home detention and 100 hours community work, despite the Department of Internal Affairs’ submission for a jail sentence to “reflect the seriousness of the offence and its aggravating features”. The judge also imposed permanent name suppression including details of the offender’s professional job to protect him and his own children.

It was further reported that the judge, noting rehabilitative steps taken by the offender, farewelled him with the words “every new day is going to be a better day”. Ritchie says, “It beggars belief. Does this judge not understand that every download fuels demand for further material? Does she not appreciate that for two years this offender proactively fuelled the global child rape trade? Tragically, for this man’s countless victims ‘every new day will not be a better day’ as offenders - undeterred by weak sentences – continue to fuel demand and victims continue to be re-victimised.”

Stop Demand said it was a weakness of such cases that judges did not have to hear, firsthand, the psychological torment victims can endure throughout their life, instead often being swayed by pitiful excuses trotted out by offenders and their counsel. “In this case,” says Ritchie, “it was the offender’s fear of prison and his gutless threats of suicide that she took into account before sending him home to enjoy his home comforts.”

Stop Demand is concerned about the excuses now being accepted by the Courts to provide Court protection to those participating in the global child rape trade. These have included a wife’s heart condition, impact on future work prospects and suicide threats.

Ritchie says, “These trivialising sentences are totally out-of-step with Parliament’s strong direction to the judiciary in April, when it doubled custodial penalties for possession. They set a worrying precedent. They also run counter to global efforts to crack down heavily on all who seek out such material. Demand fuels supply.”

This is not the first time Judge Philippa Cunningham has come under fire for her sentencing. In 2011 she allowed a comedian to walk free from sex charges against his 4-year-old daughter, saying he was a talented New Zealand and he “makes people laugh”. In a rare judicial review, the High Court ordered the District Court to resentence the man. In 2013, the Court of Appeal set aside another decision of Judge Cunningham’s, replacing home detention with a term of imprisonment to an offender who committed, while on bail, a violent attack on a vulnerable 81-year-old woman. In 2014, Judge Cunningham triggered further outcry when she discharged without conviction a son of the Maori king, despite his pleading guilty to charges of burglary, theft and driving while seven times over the legal alcohol limit for his age – a decision that was subsequently overturned by the High Court.

Stop Demand Foundation calls for action to stop sexual violence, sexual exploitation
and sexual denigration of women and children www.stopdemand.org


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Compensating Afghan Civilian Casualties

Reportedly, there have been nine incidents resulting in 17 civilian deaths and injuries (seven of the dead were children) caused by ordnance left behind on what used to be the firing range of our Provincial Reconstruction Team (PRT) in Bamiyan province.

Given that the NZ Defence Force has needed to be hauled kicking and screaming into belatedly arranging an adequate clean-up of its old firing range… what would it take before New Zealand offers to pay compensation to the families of those who suffered death and injury from what was left behind on our watch? More>>


Fossil Fuel Investment: ACC Must Lead On Climate Change

As the largest publicly owned investor in New Zealand, the ACC board should divest from fossil fuels, demonstrating our leadership role on climate change, Green Party MP Chlöe Swarbrick said today. More>>


Total Officers, Up Less: Coalition's 1800 New Police Officers

The Coalition commitment to add 1800 new Police officers to frontline policing has been achieved with the graduation of 59 constables from the Royal New Zealand Police College today. More>>


Predator Free: $3.5m For New Pest Controls

New Zealand First is proud to announce the Provincial Growth Fund (PGF) has allocated $3.5 million to develop innovative predator control approaches which will reduce the need for repeated 1080 use. More>>


Children's Day: Commissioner Calls For Govt Commitment

“Three decades on, we are able to celebrate some significant changes for children like the recent launch of a Child and Youth Wellbeing Strategy. But we still have a long way to go to prioritise children’s rights.” More>>


Elections: Proposed Electorate Boundaries Released

The Representation Commission is proposing changes to half of New Zealand’s electorates and establishing a new electorate in south Auckland… More>>


"Effectively A Permanent Amnesty": Final Month For Gun Ban Compensation

The firearms buy-back comes to an end a month from today, but the police say the amnesty for returning banned guns will continue into next year and beyond. More>>







InfoPages News Channels