Cablegate: Election Process Update and Next Steps

DE RUEHBUL #2789/01 2571100
R 141100Z SEP 09




E.O. 12958: N/A

1. (SBU) Summary. With 92.8 percent of polling stations counted,
Hamid Karzai has 54.3 percent of the votes, Dr. Abdullah has 28.1
percent, Mr. Bashardost has 9.2 percent, and Ashraf Ghani has 2.7
percent. Another 2.15 percent of polling stations are under
quarantine for fraud at the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC),
and the remaining 5 percent - most of which come from southern
Pashtun provinces - will be announced in some form along with female
turnout numbers at the next IEC press conference -- which had been
scheduled for Sept. 14 but is now postponed. The ECC continues to
investigate its 700+ "Category A" complaints. Meanwhile, the IEC
will embark on the ECC-ordered audit and recount of stations with
more than 600 ballots or where one candidate got over 95 percent of
votes. We expect this process may require review of up to 4000
polling stations, but we are cautiously optimistic that if the IEC
and ECC pursue a joint implementation plan, both processes can be
concluded by September 30, which would allow for a run-off to take
place before the end of October (if one is required). It is now
essential that adjudications take place in an efficient and
transparent manner in order to salvage the credibility of these
elections. Authorities will face pressure to balance fraud
adjudication with Pashtun sensitivities about disenfranchisement.
End Summary.

The Numbers, What's in, And What's Out

2. (SBU) At a press conference on Sept. 12, the IEC Chief Electoral
Officer Dr. Najafi announced results of 22,861 polling stations,
representing 92.8 percent of polling stations nationwide, which
produced 5,545,149 valid votes. At this time, Hamid Karzai has
3,009,559 votes (54.3 percent), Dr. Abdullah Abdullah earned
1,558,591 votes (28.1 percent), Ramazan Bashardost has 511,441 votes
(9.2 percent), and Ashraf Ghani has 149,720 votes (2.7 percent).
Another 600 polling stations (2.15 percent of all polling stations)
are under quarantine for fraud at the Independent Electoral
Commission (IEC). (See para 5 for more detail on these.)

3. (SBU) Najafi said the next IEC press conference would take place
on Sept. 14 and at that time the IEC would reveal the status of the
remaining 5 percent of polling stations. (On the morning of Sept.
14, the IEC announced the press conference would not take place.)
Remaining polling stations -- which we believe to be about 1134 --
come predominantly from four southern Pashtun-majority provinces:
Kandahar, Paktika, Khost, and Ghazni.
4. (SBU) The IEC says the number of polling stations open on
election day was 24,621. However, we note this is still a
preliminary number which may change, making all calculations subject
to correction. Post is requesting the final list of polling station
locations in a formal letter to the IEC. Dr. Najafi said he would
also make available information related to turnout of male, female,
and Kuchi (nomadic) voters at the next press conference.
Quarantines, Audits, Recounts, Nullifications, and Investigations
--------------------------------------------- ------

5. (SBU) The IEC has held for some time 600 polling stations under
quarantine (2.15 percent of all polling stations). The IEC
explained on Sept. 12 that it had used the following triggers to
quarantine these tally sheets: stations with more than 1,000 votes,
stations not opened from which results arrived, and stations where
votes recorded are greater than number of ballot papers delivered.
(Note: The explanation caused much confusion among donors,
observers, and journalists, who suspected the IEC was trying to
apply a soft standard to all audits and recounts.) The IEC said it
has "sent" these quarantined tally sheets to the ECC, presumably to
be nullified. This indicates the IEC interprets the electoral law
to mean only the ECC may nullify ballots. The law says the IEC may
"permanently withdraw from counting" ballots it has quarantined, but
nothing about the IEC nullifying ballots.

6. (SBU) The ECC continues to investigate the "Category A"
complaints, which were at 726 at one time. On Sept. 10 they
announced their early investigations produced a small tranche of
nullifications that included 29,014 presidential ballots from 83
polling stations in Ghazni, Paktika, and Kandahar. We assess that
three of these stations (all in Ghazni) had been already included in
the IEC's count. The ECC will continue to adjudicate the rest of
the "Category A" complaints over the coming weeks. The week of
Sept. 14, ECC investigators will travel to Paktika, Herat, Baghlan,
Nangahar, Kapisa, and Parwan to conduct relevant investigations.
Post has been assisting the ECC's trips through logistics, transport
and funding.
7. (SBU) Under the Sept. 7 directive from the ECC, the IEC will
conduct an audit and recount of polling stations with 600 or more
ballots and those where one candidate received 95 percent of the
vote and 100 or move votes. Dr. Najafi confirmed that IEC
Commissioners had tasked the tally center to begin this process. On
Sept. 13 the IEC and ECC worked out a plan that would begin audits
in 13 provinces using three teams. If the audits show discrepancies

KABUL 00002789 002 OF 002

then recounts will begin using the international standard sampling
process. The IEC/ECC are also drafting a joint statement that they
planned to announce Sept. 14, although that date seems to have
slipped. The IEC-led process may require review of up to 4000
polling stations, according to our latest calculations, although the
IEC's Barakzai said it will be only 2516 stations.
8. (SBU) These two parallel processes -- the IEC-led audit/recount
and the ECC-led investigations -- will require some time to
complete, therefore the final results will be delayed. However, if
the IEC/ECC joint plan is realized and implemented with
determination, it could produce a conclusion by September 30.
Results could be certified within a few days, and if no run-off is
required, inauguration could take place 30 days later.

Run-Off Feasibility

9. (SBU) While it is still possible, it appears that odds are
against a run-off or second round. We still don't know exactly how
many polling stations will fall under the audit/recount, but the
IEC/ECC would have to nullify about 475,000 of Karzai's votes (with
other candidates losing none) from the current preliminary vote
tally in order for him to drop below 50 percent, according to
Election Team calculations. As for the uncounted ballots, the
trend forecasts those to be either nullified or for Karzai to pick
up votes at a higher rate than Abdullah, as he has done as the
counting moved ahead. But nothing is certain at this stage.

10. (SBU) If a run-off is needed, the IEC, UNDP-ELECT, and ISAF
have all expressed confidence in their ability to carry it out.
However, there is no doubt logistics and security will require
another monumental effort. It may not be exactly within 15 days of
final certification, as the law requires, but it could happen in
late October. A tally could take as little as one week because only
two candidates are at issue. A challenge period is open for 72
hours after the announcement of results. More fraud is likely, but
lessons have been learned and the IEC/ECC should be better able to
deal with such fraud. If there is the will to do so, certification
could take place within three weeks after the provisional
announcement of run-off results. This would put us at the latest
into mid-November with an inauguration by mid-December.
Next Steps

11. (SBU) The Sept. 12 IEC press conference shed light on the
status of quarantined ballots and affirmed the IEC's intent to
cooperate with the ECC in the audit/recount, and thus it can be seen
as a small victory for the process. These developments are a marked
contrast to one week ago, when the IEC appeared to be caving to
political pressure to roll out votes, whether suspect or not.

12. (SBU) This election brought more polling stations, more
observers, more women candidates, more media coverage and debates,
and a high degree of cooperation among ANSF and ISAF than ever
before. At the same time, the themes of these elections, as played
out in the press, have been violence, intimidation, and fraud.
Prior to elections, a majority of Afghans had perceived the
elections would be fair. In order to now help rescue the election's
credibility, at a minimum the institutions must: a) be demonstrably
effective in their fraud investigations and adjudications, b)
cooperate at an unprecedented level; and c) break new ground in
explaining their work to the Afghan public. Firing IEC workers who
participated in or committed fraud would help credibility as well.
Still, authorities will have to contend with Pashtun sensitivities
about perceived disenfranchisement, which will likely increase as
more polling stations are nullified in the South, as well as the
reality the process fell short in providing fair access for women

© Scoop Media

World Headlines


Human Rights: China Journalist Jailed For COVID Reporting Seriously Ill, Must Be Released

UN human rights experts* today urged China to immediately release imprisoned citizen journalist and woman human rights defender Zhang Zhan on humanitarian grounds, saying her health is deteriorating rapidly and her life is in danger... More>>

CID: PNG Deadly Covid Crisis Getting Worse
People in Papua New Guinea are not getting enough Covid vaccines due to misinformation. This is causing immense stress and suffering throughout the country, says Quenelda Clegg Chair of CID’s Humanitarian Network...More>>

Sudan: Bachelet Condemns Killings Of Peaceful Protesters

At least 39 people have been killed by security forces in Sudan since the 25 October military coup, 15 of whom were reportedly shot dead on Wednesday, according to the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights...

Focus On: UN SDGs

Food: Three Billion People Cannot Afford A Healthy Diet

Approximately three billion people, almost 40 per cent of the world’s population, cannot afford a healthy diet and another one billion people would join their ranks should further unpredictable events reduce incomes by one-third, the UN food agency said, launching a new report on Tuesday... More>>

COP26: Enough Of ‘Treating Nature Like A Toilet’ – Guterres Brings Stark Call For Climate Action To Glasgow
As the World Leaders Summit opened on day two of COP26, UN chief António Guterres sent a stark message to the international community. “We are digging our own graves”, he said, referring to the addiction to fossil fuels which threatens to push humanity and the planet, to the brink, through unsustainable global heating... More>>

Climate: ‘Vague’ Net Zero Promises Not Enough: Planet Still On Track For Catastrophic Heating, UN Report Warns

New and updated commitments made ahead of the pivotal climate conference COP26 in the past months are a positive step forward, but the world remains on track for a dangerous global temperature rise of at least 2.7°C this century even if fully met, a new report by the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) has warned... More>>