Māori Privilege
Māori Privilege
Contrary to what some may believe,
Māori aren't privileged citizens of Aotearoa New Zealand.
Dr (yes this guy is learned) Jamie Whyte and Winston Peters
would obviously beg to differ, as their recent remarks
clearly propagate a narrative that belongs in the 19th
century. Analysing the situation, it's evident that two
major discourses influenced the social actions taken by
Peters and Whyte - election year politicking and the ugly
social norm of the 'One Law for all' minority (a large
minority).
In regards to the first discourse,
Whyte and Peters see a political opportunity provided to
them on a plate. Let's face it, John Key was never going to
give Colin Craig the nod. The Conservative leader is just
too much maintenance to handle, quite simply the cons
outweigh the pros. Monday's no deal announcement pretty much
closed the door for Craig but opened up another door for
more 'reliable' (an oxymoron in this case) coalition
partners. Queue Whyte, looking to bank on the right-wing
voters that were giving the Conservatives a healthy average
of 2.5%. After Key gave the thumbs up to David Seymour in
Epsom, it would be humiliating if ACT (currently on 0%)
failed to get the additional votes needed to get Whyte into
parliament, thus the motivation to go fishing on Craig's
constituency.
Winston is a political survivor, and is
probably looking to maximize on the Conservatives' voters
too. In his political career Winston has done what's best
for Winston. Ironically the Minister for Māori Affairs in
1990, Peters has since found his 'niche market' in the
anti-immigrant and anti-Māori constituency. Wavering just
below the MMP threshold, Winston is playing his cards for
survival and banking on the old "Māori separatism"
narrative to solidify his political future. Winston has
distanced himself from Key's National government over the
past year, but who could forget his pivotal 7 week charade
post-elections in 1996. As Craig becomes more and more
irrelevant by the day, Winston is again looking like the
'kingmaker' - he knows if he can secure the
conservative-right-wing-One-Law-for-All votes, then NZ First
will bump over the 5% threshold.
In regards to the
second discourse, Whyte and Winston utilize an ugly 'social
fact' - that Māori are privileged - an ideal believed by
some even in light of socio-economic disparities. In his
speech to a Waikato conference, Jamie Whyte described Māori
as "legally privileged in New Zealand today, just as the
Aristocracy were legally privileged in pre-revolutionary
France."[1] I'm wondering, by privileged does he
mean being at the bottom of all social indicators? By
Aristocracy does Whyte mean 39% of children living in high
deprivation standards; 13.3% unemployment rate; 50% of the
prison populace; and "living 7.9 (female) and 8.6 (male)
years less than other New Zealanders?"[2] For some reason, I don't think the
above paints a picture of a privileged people. Yet some
believe otherwise, and this constituency is the group that
Whyte and Peters can depend on.
So what does Māori
privilege look like? Well on TV One's Breakfast show this
morning, Whyte described the Māori electorates and Iwi
'Advisory' Boards (key word advisory) as an upper hand. This
type of rhetoric harkens back to the days of Don Brash, who
said that "we are one country with many peoples, not simply
a society of Pakeha and Maori where the minority has a birth
right to the upper hand."[3] It's ironic that a lot of people
that propagate or listen to this narrative are well
educated. It appears that knowledge doesn't always equate
with wisdom (let alone insight), as both Brash and Whyte
(who both have a PhD) have trumpeted an illogical logic of
neo-colonial racism. Even Winston Peters is calling for the
abolition of the Māori seats because they're
"extraordinarily damaging for this country."[4] This is pretty hypocritical of
Peters, as his party NZ First won all the Māori seats in
1996. The simple fact is that the three aspects - Māori
electorates, advisory boards and university scholarships -
that are circulated as the characteristics of Māori
privilege are far from anything
aristocratic.
Indigenous rights are different from
aristocratic privilege, and should be honoured. Yes Māori
have rights as do all New Zealanders; the only point of
difference is 'Indigeneity'. Article 15 of the 2007 UN
Declaration of Indigenous Rights, states that indigenous
peoples: have a right to the "dignity and diversity of their
culture". As an indigenous peoples groups, Māori have a
unique relationship with Aotearoa. This may seem
undemocratic but sometimes democracy isn't just in and of
itself - minority groups always come off second best in a
'majority rules' political environment. You know what's
undemocratic? Colonization, but I guess I'm just being
ungrateful for my so called 'privilege'. Jamie Whyte and
Winston Peters want to get rid of the Māori electorates and
other forms of affirmative action. But would New Zealand
politics ever come to the point where the Māori electorates
are scrapped? Well ironically, in 2008 Key said that
National wanted to do away with the Māori seats in
Parliament once all historical Treaty settlements are
finalized.[5] As National's constituency continues
to boom, relying on coalition partners who are similar in
race-relation ideology seems more than likely.
This
is my Māori privilege: The only 'privilege' I've ever
received was being pinned up between a police car and a
fence just because I met the suspect's description (I was
walking home after Uni). The only 'goods' I've received is
the 'Police 10/7' look I get when I go into a restaurant or
shop. I didn't get into Uni because I'm Māori and I've got
a student loan the size of a mortgage. The only
'aristocracy' I know is being part of a peoples group that's
told to get over colonisation. This is my sociological bias,
my narrative that is far from the 'privileged' ideal held
onto by some in New Zealand society.
There is no
Māori privilege, just a socially constructed norm used to
get right-wing politicians into parliament and further
entrench a negative perception about the indigenous peoples
of Aotearoa New
Zealand.
________________________________________
[1] Jamie Whyte Speech: Race has no place in the law http://www.act.org.nz/?q=posts/speech-race-has-no-place-in-the-law
[2] T.K Lewis. Māori = Privileged citizens? http://community.scoop.co.nz/2013/04/maori-privileged-citizens/
[3] T.K Lewis. Māori = Privileged citizens? http://community.scoop.co.nz/2013/04/maori-privileged-citizens/
[4] Winston Peters. No Deal http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/10324092/Peters-No-deal-with-Maori-Mana
[5] John Key http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10534713
ends