Local Govt | National News Video | Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Search


Lake Horowhenua Trust now without trustees

Lake Horowhenua Trust now without trustees

by Veronica Harrod

Lake Horowhenua Trust now has no trustees after an historic decision by the Maori Appellate Court quashed their appointment.

Late last week three judges decided in favour of Lake Horowhenua owner Philip Taueki who challenged Judge Doogan's decision of 19 May 2016 appointing 11 Lake Horowhenua trustees on the grounds Judge Doogan had a conflict of interest.

Mr Taueki made his application appealing the appointment of trustees by Judge Doogan after the Maori Appellate Court found on 8 March 2018 that Judge Doogan had a conflict of interest in an appeal by another Lake Horowhenua owner Charles Rudd in another case involving the Lake Horowhenua Trust.

Mr Rudd’s appeal was based on comments Judge Doogan made in his court case about his previous professional involvement with the Muaūpoko Tribal Authority and Lake Horowhenua Trust chair Matthew Sword.

The court judgement on Mr Rudd’s appeal stated, "That case raised the issue of apparent bias. We held that a fair-minded, impartial and properly informed observer could reasonably have thought that Judge Doogan might not bring an impartial mind to the matters before him.”

It was after the decision in Mr Rudd's appeal was released by the Maori Appellate Court that Mr Taueki filed his application seeking a previous decision Judge Doogan made to appoint 11 Lake Horowhenua trustees be quashed.

The court judgement further stated, "It is appropriate that we hear Mr Taueki’s appeal. It involves the same trust, the same judge, and arguments similar to those that Mr Rudd pursued before us."

"The fully-informed observer would also have known – although Mr Taueki did not – that Judge Doogan formerly acted for the Muaūpoko Tribal Authority, and that Matthew Sword, who had since become chair of the Lake Horowhenua Trust, was Judge Doogan’ instructing solicitor."

"Against this background, our answer to the question of whether a fair-minded fully informed observer would have a reasonable apprehension that the judge might not bring an impartial mind to the matters before him is ‘yes’.

"The judge formerly acted for the Muaūpoko Tribal Authority; the judge’s instructing solicitor at that time had become chair of the Lake Horowhenua Trust; and persons active in the Muaūpoko Tribal Authority were seeking appointment as trustees of the Lake Horowhenua Trust although subject to objection from Mr Taueki and others," stated the Maori Appellate Court judgement.

"Given the troubled history of this trust and the objections raised, the appointment as trustees of the 11 highest-polling candidates cannot be regarded as a fait accompli. Judge Doogan exercised judgement not to inquire into the objections, and proceeded to appoint strictly in accordance with the poll. This was not an inevitable, nor indeed necessarily a desirable, course. There was enquiry to be made, and Judge Doogan, given his former professional relationship with key players, was not the judge to undertake that enquiry.”

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Chilling The Warm Fuzzies About The US/China Trade Deal

Hold the champagne, folks. This week’s China/US deal is more about a change in tone between the world’s two biggest economies – thank goodness they’re not slapping more tariffs on each other! - than a landmark change in substance. The high walls of US and Chinese tariffs built in recent years will largely remain intact, and few economists are predicting the deal will significantly boost the growth prospects for a slowing US economy. As the New York Times noted this morning, the likes of New Zealand will still face the trade barriers imposed by the Trump administration during the recent rounds of fighting. More>>


PGF Kaikōura $10.88M: Boost In Tourism & Business

The Provincial Growth Fund (PGF) is investing $10.88 million to boost business and tourism opportunities in Kaikōura, Parliamentary Undersecretary for Regional Economic Development, Fletcher Tabuteau announced today. More>>


Whitebaiting: Govt Plans To Protect Announced

With several native whitebait species in decline the Minister of Conservation Eugenie Sage has today released proposals to standardise and improve management of whitebait across New Zealand. More>>


Education: Resource For Schools On Climate Change

New resource for schools to increase awareness and understanding of climate change... More>>


In Effect April: New Regulations For Local Medicinal Cannabis

Minister of Health Dr David Clark says new regulations will allow local cultivation and manufacture of medicinal cannabis products that will potentially help ease the pain of thousands of people. More>>


RNZ: New Year Honours: Sporting Greats Among Knights And Dames

Six new knights and dames, including Silver Ferns coach Dame Noeline Taurua and economist Professor Dame Marilyn Waring, have been created in today's New Year's Honours List. The list of 180 recipients - 91 women and 89 men - leans heavily on awards for community service, arts and the media, health and sport.


Gordon Campbell: On What An Inquiry Might Look Like

Presumably, if there is to be a ministerial inquiry (at the very least) into the Whakaari/White Island disaster, it will need to be a joint ministerial inquiry. That’s because the relevant areas of responsibility seem to be so deeply interwoven... More>>






InfoPages News Channels