Cablegate: Hatoyama Cabinet Approves Fy2010 Budget

VZCZCXRO2217
RR RUEHFK RUEHKSO RUEHNAG RUEHNH
DE RUEHKO #0039/01 0070758
ZNR UUUUU ZZH
R 070758Z JAN 10
FM AMEMBASSY TOKYO
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC 8577
INFO RUEHFK/AMCONSUL FUKUOKA 8202
RUEHNAG/AMCONSUL NAGOYA 5309
RUEHNH/AMCONSUL NAHA 0546
RUEHOK/AMCONSUL OSAKA KOBE 2015
RUEHKSO/AMCONSUL SAPPORO 8701
RUEATRS/TREASURY DEPT WASHDC
RHEHAAA/NSC WASHDC
RUCPDOC/USDOC WASHDC

UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 04 TOKYO 000039

SENSITIVE
SIPDIS

TREASURY FOR DOHNER, WINSHIP, AND FOSTER
STATE FOR E, EEB AND EAP/J
NSC FOR DANNY RUSSELL AND JIM LOI
STATE PASS TO USTR FOR AUSTR CUTLER, BEEMAN, LEE AND
HOLLOWAY

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ECON EFIN JA
SUBJECT: HATOYAMA CABINET APPROVES FY2010 BUDGET

REF: A. TOKYO 00018
B. TOKYO 00025
C. 2009 TOKYO 02819
D. 2009 TOKYO 02464

1. (SBU) Summary: The Hatoyama Cabinet approved the central
government's initial budget for FY2010 (April 2010 - March
2011) on December 25, clearing the way for its submission to
the Diet. This is the first full budget formulated by the
Hatoyama Administration since it came to power in September
2009. The initial FY2010 general account budget of JPY92.3
trillion (US$1.0 trillion) represents a 4 percent increase
over the initial FY2009 budget, but is still 10 percent
smaller (about JPY10 trillion (US$109 billion) or 2.2 percent
of GDP) than the revised FY2009 budget, inclusive of the two
FY2009 supplemental budgets.

2. (SBU) FY2010 tax revenues are projected to remain weak,
rising only 1.5 percent from FY2009. Consequently, the
budget assumes that Japanese government bond (JGB) issuances
will exceed tax revenues for the second straight year. The
budget contains JPY3.1 trillion (US$34 billion) in policy
measures promised in the DPJ's "manifesto" (policy platform)
issued in the run up to the August 2009 Lower House election.
The budget bills will be submitted to the Diet in January.
Final Diet approval is likely in late March. End Summary.

Competing Budgetary Priorities
------------------------------

3. (SBU) In compiling the FY2010 budget, the Hatoyama Cabinet
sought to navigate between two competing policy priorities:
demonstrating the DPJ's fiscal discipline while avoiding
premature withdrawal of fiscal stimulus. The combined FY2010
general account and FILP (Fiscal Investment and Loan Program)
outlays are equivalent to 23 percent of GDP in FY2010. While
this represents a contraction of 3.4 percentage points (pp)
from FY2009, total outlays are still a full 2.1 pp higher
than the average of the previous ten years (FY2000-2009).
The government also appears to be counting on the assumption
that most of the JPY7.2 trillion (US$ 78 billion) in new
spending included in the second FY2009 supplemental budget
will only actually impact the economy in FY2010.

General Account Expenditures
----------------------------

4. (SBU) FY2010 general account expenditures for FY2010 total
JPY92.3 trillion (US$1 trillion), a 4 percent increase over
the initial FY2009 budget. This partly reflects a 6 percent
increase in revenue sharing with local governments due to
their worsening fiscal condition. Debt service costs are
also projected to increase 2 percent, under the assumption
that the ten-year JGB yield averages 2.0 percent in FY2010.
Social security spending is set to increase 10 percent and
accounts for over half (51 percent) of total discretionary
ministerial budget spending. This increase is largely due to
the introduction of a child allowance program paying
JPY13,000 (US$141) per month for each child until graduation
from middle school, a key DPJ electoral pledge. In contrast,
public works spending is set to decline a record 18 percent
to JPY5.8 trillion (US$63 billion), consistent with the
Hatoyama Cabinet's intent to shift fiscal resources "from
(construction) concrete to households." Spending on official
development assistance (ODA) has been cut 8 percent from the
initial FY2009 budget to JPY619 billion (US$6.7 billion), the
eleventh consecutive annual decrease on an
initial-over-initial budget basis. Like last year, the
FY2010 general account budget contains JPY1.35 trillion
(US$14.6 billion) in reserves, including JPY1.0 trillion
(US$10.9 billion) to cope with economic shocks. In addition,
the FY2010 budget will repay JPY0.7 trillion (US$7.6 billion)
borrowed in FY2008 from the debt consolidation special
account (a sinking fund) to cover smaller-than-estimated tax
revenues.

5. (SBU) (Note: The general account budget consists of two
mandatory spending items -- debt service costs and revenue

TOKYO 00000039 002 OF 004

sharing with local governments -- as well as discretionary
ministerial budget spending such as social security and
public works. End note.)

6. (U)

FY2010 General Account Budget Expenditures
------------------------------------------

JPY percent change
trillion from initial
FY2009
------------------------
TOTAL 92.3 4.2
Debt Service Costs 20.6 2.0
Revenue Sharing with
Local governments 17.5 5.5
Ministerial Budget Spending 53.5 3.3
Social Security 27.3 9.8
Education and Science 5.6 5.2
Military Pensions 0.7 -9.3
National Defense 4.8 0.3
Public Works 5.8 -18.3
Economic Cooperation 0.6 -7.5
Small Businesses 0.2 1.1
Reserves 1.4 0.0
Other 7.2 6.1
Repayment to FY2008 0.7 n/a
Settlement Fund

(Note: ODA includes spending budgeted under Economic
Cooperation, as well as under other budget categories. End
note.)

7. (U)

FY2010 General Account Budget
-----------------------------

Change from
Initial Initial Revised
FY2010 FY2009 FY2009
-------------------------
(trillion) (percent)
TOTAL EXPENDITURES 92.3 4.2 -10.0
Ministerial Budgets 53.5 3.3 -19.9
Social Security 27.3 9.8 -5.3
Public Works 5.8 -18.3 n/a
Other Discretionary 20.4 3.0 n/a
Debt Service 20.6 2.0 7.3
Revenue Sharing with
Local Governments 17.5 5.5 5.5
Repayment to FY2008
Settlement Fund 0.7 n/a n/a
TOTAL RECEIPTS 92.3 4.2 -10.0
Tax Revenues 37.4 -18.9 1.5
Other receipts 10.6 15.8 -13.4
Government Bond Issuance 44.3 33.1 -17.1

8. (U)

FY2009 General Account Budget
-----------------------------

Initial FY2009 with
FY2009 Supplementals
------------------------
(trillion)
TOTAL EXPENDITURES 88.5 102.6
Ministerial Budgets 51.7 66.7
Social Security 24.8 28.8
Public Works 7.1 n/a
Other Discretionary 19.8 n/a
Debt Service 20.2 19.3
Revenue Sharing with
Local Governments 16.6 16.6
Repayment to FY2008
Settlement Fund 0.0 0.0

TOKYO 00000039 003 OF 004

TOTAL RECEIPTS 88.5 102.6
Tax Revenues 46.1 36.9
Other receipts 9.2 12.2
Government Bond Issuance 33.3 53.5

Measures Contained in the DPJ Manifesto
---------------------------------------

9. (SBU) The FY2010 general account budget contains a total
of JPY3.1 trillion (US$33.7 billion) in policy measures
promised by the DPJ ahead of last August's Lower House
election. This is roughly JPY3.8 trillion (US$41.3 billion)
smaller than the budget requests made in October by
individual ministries to conform to the DPJ's manifesto. The
decrease is largely a result of the Hatoyama Cabinet's
decision not to eliminate the surcharge rates on four
road-related taxes from April 2010 (Ref A). Instead, the
surcharge rates on three road-related taxes (gasoline tax,
diesel oil delivery tax, and automobile acquisition tax) will
be replaced by new "special" rates that result in no change
in the tax burden. The remaining fourth surcharge rate on
the automobile tonnage tax will be halved from JPY3,800 to
JPY1,900 (US$41 to US$21) per half ton from April 2010.

10. (U) The FY2010 budget does include:

-- A new monthly child-rearing allowance of JPY13,000
(US$141) in FY2010 to each child until graduation from middle
school, with no household income ceiling.

-- The elimination of designated highway tolls.

-- A JPY0.6 trillion (US$6.5 billion) income support subsidy
program for rice farmers designed to make up the difference
between the cost of production and sales price.

-- Making public high school effectively free, as well as
providing JPY120,000 to JPY240,000 (US$1,304 to US$2,609) per
year for each private high school student, depending on
household income levels.

11. (U)

Measures Promised in DPJ's Manifesto
------------------------------------

Actually
Requested Budgeted
---------------------
(trillion)
TOTAL 6.9 3.1
Spending Measures 4.4 2.9
New Monthly Child Allowance 2.3 1.7
Highway Tolls Elimination 0.6 0.1
Rice Farmers Income Support 0.6 0.6
Free High School 0.5 0.4
Employment Measures 0.3 0.02
Pension Records Problems 0.1 0.1
Tax Measures 2.5 0.2
Road-related Tax Surcharges
Elimination 2.5 0.2

(Note: Local governments will shoulder some costs for the
child allowance program. End note.)

General Account Receipts
------------------------

12. (SBU) MOF projects FY2010 tax revenues at JPY37.4
trillion (US$407 billion), a 1.5 percent increase from
FY2009. Given this weak tax revenue growth, MOF plans to
issue JPY44.3 trillion (US$482 billion) of new JGBs in
FY2010, barely meeting the Hatoyama Cabinet's policy target
of limiting JGB issuance in the initial budget to "about
JPY44 trillion (US$478 billion)" (equivalent to the FY2009
initial budget plus the first FY2009 supplemental budget).
As a result, the total amount of JGBs issued in FY2010 is
projected to exceed tax revenues for the second year in a

TOKYO 00000039 004 OF 004

row. As for non-tax receipts, MOF will transfer to the
general account budget JPY4.8 trillion (US$52 billion) in
retained earnings from the Fiscal Loan Fund Special Account
and, consistent with past years, JPY2.9 trillion (US$32
billion) in retained earnings from the Foreign Exchange
Special Account.

Overview of FILP
----------------

13. (U) The FY2010 FILP (the so-called "second budget") calls
for total outlays of JPY18.4 trillion (US$200 billion), up 16
percent from the initial FY2009 level, but down 22 percent
from the final FY2009 level inclusive of the two FY2009
supplemental budgets. FILP lending to government-affiliated
financial institutions and public works related agencies will
decline 33 percent and 42 percent from their final FY2009
levels, respectively. Allocations to local governments will
increase 10 percent. FILP financing is mainly provided
through FILP bonds (JPY13.5 trillion or US$147 billion) and
government-guaranteed bonds (JPY4.8 trillion or US$52
billion).

14. (U)

FY2010 Fiscal Investment and Loan Program
-----------------------------------------

Change from
Initial Initial Revised
FY2010 FY2009 FY2009
-------------------------
(trillion) (percent)
TOTAL OUTLAYS 18.4 15.7 -22.2
Government affiliated
financial institutions 10.5 26.3 -33.2
Public works agencies 0.6 -30.8 -42.5
Local governments 4.3 10.3 10.3
Other 3.0 5.7 -0.4
TOTAL FUNDING 18.4 15.7 -22.2
FILP bonds 13.5 12.6 -25.4
Government-guaranteed bonds 4.8 26.5 -6.6
Other 0.1 -14.4 -74.5

15. (U)

FY2009 Fiscal Investment and Loan Program
-----------------------------------------

Initial FY2009 with
FY2009 Supplementals
------------------------
(trillion)
TOTAL OUTLAYS 15.9 23.6
Government affiliated
financial institutions 8.3 15.7
Public works agencies 0.8 1.0
Local governments 3.9 3.9
Other 2.8 3.0
TOTAL FUNDING 15.9 23.6
FILP bonds 12.0 18.1
Government-guaranteed bonds 3.8 5.1
Other 0.1 0.4

ROOS

© Scoop Media