World Video | Defence | Foreign Affairs | Natural Events | Trade | NZ in World News | NZ National News Video | NZ Regional News | Search


Panel On Algiers Bombing Cites UN Security Lapse

Panel On Algiers Terrorist Bombing Cites Dysfunctional UN Security System

New York, Oct 8 2008 4:10PM

A dysfunctional United Nations security management system, a lack of adequate supervision and training, and significant lapses in judgement and performance all played a major role in the 2007 terrorist bombings of UN offices in Algiers, which killed 17 staff members, an independent panel reported today.

It also found that the UN ‘phase system’ for grading security risks in Algeria had been “seriously compromised” through politicization due to the country’s aversion to any indication that it was not secure. And it cited a pre-occupation by UN security officials with countries like Afghanistan and Iraq for leaving Algeria off the security radar screen.

“The dysfunction of the present system is not attributable to a lack of resources alone,” the panel said, recommending administrative measures against six individuals and disciplinary proceedings against four others. “It is also attributable to a failure on the part of those who designed it and those who implemented it.”

The Independent Panel on Accountability, headed by former UN Assistant Secretary-General for Legal Affairs Ralph Zacklin, was set up by Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon in June to examine whether any staff should be held individually accountable over the 2007 attack.

Mr. Zacklin told a news conference that an administrative measure could be something as simple as a letter of reprimand while a disciplinary action could be something as serious as dismissal. The panel also recommended an administrative measure against “an organ of collective responsibility,” in this case the UN Security Management Team in Algiers.

A four-page summary of the 88-page report – and the thousands of pages of annexes – already presented to Mr. Ban cited a “marked reluctance” of some of those interviewed to accept the panel’s procedures and methods of work.

While this may be attributable to a misunderstanding of the panel’s function, the five-member body “took the view that this reflected an attitude of institutional and individual denial of the principle of accountability which is regrettably prevalent in the case in question,” the summary said.

The lack of executive authority of the Under-Secretary-General of the Department of Safety and Security (DSS) and the role of the so-called Designated Official responsible for on-site security were at the root of the design fault of the system, the panel found.

The former official was given responsibility without authority and the latter was expected to function as head of security in the field office and as programme manager, responsibilities which are often inherently contradictory, it added. Under-Secretary-General David Veness resigned in June, saying he would shoulder full responsibility for any security lapse that may have occurred.

The panel cited a variety of problems in integrating the previously existing UN Security Coordinator into the new DSS. “Four years on, the cultures of the two organizations did not appear to have been successfully integrated resulting in internal mistrust and even dissension,” it declared.

“There has been a lack of adequate supervision and training and the recruitment process has resulted in an imbalance at the senior and middle management level which is heavily weighted towards certain types of experience which is not necessarily best suited to an organization such as the UN and the threats that it faces.”

Stressing the primary responsibility of the host country for security of UN staff, the report noted that where relations with that country are strained or non-existent, “a critical fault-line may develop with tragic consequences.”

Governments must assume their responsibilities fully if they are to meet expectations inherent in the notion of primary responsibility, with proper and effective channels of communication maintained between the country’s security services and the UN Security Advisers in the field, it noted.

“The UN needs to urgently review the one-UN house doctrine and the security phase system. The one-UN house doctrine if followed ‘liturgically’ seriously undermines UN security in countries where there are terrorist threats,” the summary said.

“The security phase system was found by the panel to have been seriously compromised in Algeria through a process of politicization. The system as such was rejected or questioned by many of those interviewed since it tends to provide a false sense of security or the appearance of careful elaboration when in fact it is frequently inconsistent in its application from country to country."

Mr. Zacklin told reporters the UN graded phase system used worldwide is intended to govern UN operations in a country, not to be a reflection of the security situation there as a whole. “In Algeria, but it may be true in many other countries… many host countries do not look with pleasure on a security phase in a country being placed at a high level because for them this indicates that the country is not secure," he said.

“At the heart of the Algiers tragedy, more fundamental than all the frameworks and structures and models and assessments, lies the human factor,” the report declared. “There was a lack of adequate supervision and guidance on the part of senior managers which… can only be partially excused by the lack of resources.

“Senior managers were pre-occupied with Afghanistan, Iraq, Lebanon, Somalia and Sudan. Algeria was not on the radar screen. During the early and middle part of 2007 when the situation in Algeria clearly required sustained attention, key parts of DSS were undergoing personnel changes.”

The panel cited a failure to fulfil core responsibilities both upward in the hierarchy and downward to the field due to a lack of understanding of the tools available and, in some cases, a pre-disposition to dismiss the value of the product of such tools.

“In the field, the panel found that a dysfunctional relationship among key actors combined with passive and ineffective teamwork resulted in a false sense of security and a lack of urgency which was belied by the evidence,” it said.


© Scoop Media

World Headlines


Tale Of Two Pandemics: Follow The Science And Do Not Forget One At The Cost Of The Other

Covid-19 has posed innumerable health, economic, and social challenges for all, including people living with HIV. It has exposed the fragility of health systems around the globe and has diverted political attention and funding from other infectious diseases like TB and HIV... More>>

UN: Rights Chief Calls For Prompt Release Of Protestors Held In Cuba
The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights on Friday called for the prompt release of protestors and journalists detained during anti-government demonstrations in Cuba, some of whom are being held incommunicado... More>>

Scarce Goods: Isolating Daraa Al-Balad Threatens 40,000 With Starvation

The siege imposed by the Syrian government forces on Daraa al-Balad since June 24 would lead to serious humanitarian repercussions if it continues, Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor said in a statement on July 15, calling for lifting the siege urgently and allowing the entry of basic humanitarian supplies... More>>

Focus On: UN SDGs

Shaping The Future Of Food Systems: Thousands Commit To Dialogues Amidst The COVID-19 Pandemic

More than 130 governments are making food systems a top priority amid the pandemic and committing to an unprecedented programme of Dialogues in the run up to the UN Food Systems Summit in September... More>>

UN: Play:Fair For People And Planet – A Major United Nations Music Activation
organized by the UN SDG Action Campaign in partnership with Music Innovation Hub, Keychange, the city of Milan, the Milan Triennale, and partners from the SDG Music Network, will be held at an unexpected location in the center of Milan, Italy, taking into account safety measures with a limited on-site audience consisting of activists and fans... More>>

UN: Next 18 Months Seen As Pivotal In Global Efforts To Achieve Key Goals

Next 18 months seen as pivotal in global efforts to reverse punishing pandemic impacts and boost actions to achieve key goals - Even as pandemic erases decades of gains in development, response efforts show signs of renewed global commitment to accelerate SDG progress... More>>