Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Decision Stuns Users Of Port Company Monopolies

24 December, 2002

Media Release

Decision Stuns Users Of Port Company Monopolies

The Captive Port Customers Group (CPC) says a Government decision that port companies are free to exercise their monopoly driven market power on captive users will reduce the competitiveness of New Zealand based shipping and captive export industries.

Paul Nicholas, secretary to the Captive Port Customers Group, says the case against the Ports was so strong that the Group is stunned by the Government decision to do nothing.

“After all the evidence we provided to the review, this decision was next to impossible. The Government has got it horribly wrong, and it is real business-people and consumers who will pay the price.

“We submitted case after case where ports took advantage of captive customers, and we submitted economic evidence which showed ports had earned at least $300m more than they were entitled to over the past decade.

“We also showed that the legal remedies available were impotent.

“The decision not to intervene frees port monopolies to act as they wish over their customers, and that guarantees that ports will be one of New Zealand’s most lucrative investment opportunities over the next few years. There are not many other businesses opportunities in New Zealand where the Government has given monopolies a right to charge their customers whatever they want,” Mr Nicholas said.

Mr Nicholas said the decision stymies one of the Governments own core economic aims of increasing New Zealand’s participation in shipping and maritime service provision.

He also labeled Transport Minister Paul Swain’s caution for Regional Council port owners to be sensitive to the impact of disputes between port companies and port users on regional development and employment as “feeble”.

“Port companies are regarded as cash cows by regional councils, so we have to ask what influence regional councils have exerted on government to let the current monopoly situation continue.

“It appears a new pricing regime for regional Councils to apply to port company monopolies will be to charge what you can until regional development and employment are threatened, then back your pricing off. No mention is made about fair and reasonable pricing,” Mr Nicholas said.

Mr Nicholas said the decision completely overlooked one of the main obstacles in dealing with a monopoly, which is monopolies do not have to negotiate or go to voluntary arbitration as the Commerce Minister suggests - monopolies just set prices.

“The Minister has received some bad advice on what actually happens in the industry. A recent case of a port company refusing to negotiate or accept arbitration required Pacifica Shipping to go to Court.

“The Government has taken no account of the national welfare cost of ports market power as the review undertaken by Charles River and Associates was purely qualitative no provision was made in the terms of reference to calculate the cost of the ports market power.”

Mr Nicholas challenged the Government to pass economic legislation covering the Port sector, with clauses reflecting the recent decision;

- Legislative obligation for ports to be successful businesses

- No economic regulation

- No consultation

- No information disclosure

- No dispute resolution

“The ridiculous contrast of such Ports legislation against legislation passed for other industries would expose the illogic of this recent decision.

“This issue will not go away and we can assure Ministers that they will be regularly reminded of the poor decision they have made and its costs to the sector and the country,” Mr Nicholas said.

ends


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 




Digitl: Bumper year ahead for NZ IT sector

Gartner says New Zealand spending on technology products and services will grow 7.4 percent this year. The company’s latest forecast says the market will total NZ$15.3 billion in 2022... More>>



Fonterra: Lifts Forecast Farmgate Milk Price Range

Fonterra Co-operative Group today lifted its 2021/22 forecast Farmgate Milk Price range to NZD $8.90 - $9.50 per kgMS, up from NZD $8.40 - $9.00 per kgMS. This increases the midpoint of the range, which farmers are paid off... More>>

Federated Farmers: NAIT Levy Increases Must Achieve Accurate, User-friendly System
Nobody welcomes extra costs but if OSPRI is to catch-up on under investment in the NAIT platform and deliver on its workability and farmer support, levy increases are probably necessary, Federated Farmers says... More>>



Skoltech: Study Probes Earth’s Turbulent Past To Explain Where Oceans Came From

The origin of water on our planet is a hot question: Water has immense implications for plate tectonics, climate, the origin of life on Earth, and potential habitability of other Earth-like planets. In a recent study in Physical Review Letters, a Skoltech professor and his Chinese colleagues suggest... More>>


Statistics: Household Net Worth Grows In The September 2021 Quarter But At A Slower Pace Compared To March 2021

Household net worth grew by $60.7 billion in the September 2021 quarter compared with the June 2021 quarter, Stats NZ said today. This represents an increase of 2.5 percent, a similar result to the June 2021 quarter, which was up $60.6 billion or 2.6 percent... More>>

TradeMe: Job Market Ends 2021 On A High With Record Number Of Vacancies
The New Zealand job market finished 2021 on a high note, with the ball still firmly in the job hunters’ court, according to the analysis of 69,600 vacancies listed on Trade Me Jobs for the quarter ending 31 December (Q4)... More>>