Market Turbulence And Lack Of Advice To Cost 50,000 KiwiSaver Members $3.5billion
According to NationalCapital.co.nz, an online platform helping Kiwis understand which KiwiSaver fund and provider is best suited for their requirements, in the quarter ending March 2020 approximately 3.74% of members from KiwiSaver Growth funds and 3.01% of KiwiSaver members in Balanced funds switched, mostly into more conservative funds. This choice has the potential to collectively reduce their investment gains by up to $3.5billion if they remain where they are.
“When Covid-19 hit, fuelled by declining KiwiSaver balances, misinformation and a lack of advice, an estimated 50,000 Kiwis panicked and moved, with most moving into a more conservative fund under the guise that they would be minimising further losses. The longer these members stay out of Growth/Balanced funds, the bigger the potential loss,” explains Clive Fernandes, Director of NationalCapital.co.nz and an Authorised Financial Advisor.
“For this group alone, we estimate the collective loss of funds to be $925,664,182 in 10 years from now or $3,578,215,119 in 20 years.”
The real danger is not what has already been lost due to recent market upheaval, but rather what this group is now set to miss out on in terms of future returns if they stay where they are.
“The reason I started National Capital is so anyone could access free KiwiSaver advice to maximise their investments, become financially secure and ideally, retire with more. Not only do we help people identify the best fund but also the provider best suited to their needs,” said Clive.
KiwiSaver plays a critical role for many people’s retirement and this loss equates to an estimated $20,580 in 10 years or $80,726 in 20 years, per person, “A significant chunk of change that would have served them well, come retirement,” he adds.
The hardest hit funds were two of the biggest; Westpac Growth and ASB Growth funds which lost 6.87% and 6.4% of their investor base in the March 2020 quarter.
The value of the right advice
The Growth funds which took the smallest hit (of investor base) were Mercer Growth, which gained 2.3% and Milford Active Growth which only lost 0.4% of their investor base. Both Mercer and Milford work with advisers outside of their organisation to provide KiwiSaver advice to their clients.
“These figures show those KiwiSaver members who had greater access to advice, were less inclined to switch, suggesting the value of advice - quite literally - particularly in a time of uncertainty,” said Clive.
“If those switchers had access to the right advice in the first place, the number of people switching funds would’ve most likely been significantly less. The question now begs, will they seek advice to avoid missing out in the long term.”
Clive explains that access to advice has been a known problem in the industry for a long time. However, the biggest barrier has been availability and affordability. Legislative changes to allow for digital advice have broken down these barriers, allowing companies such as National Capital to serve kiwis.
Clive believes KiwiSaver providers need to add ‘access to advice’ as part of their service offering and fee structure.
“Ultimately we need to ensure that Kiwis end up better off in the long run. Just aiming to have the lowest fees to attract new clients is not in the long term interest of KiwiSaver members. The Industry, FMA and the Government need to take the ‘value of advice’ into consideration; and not just have a myopic focus on fees.”
To ensure you are in the right KiwiSaver fund, and with a provider that best suits your needs, visit NationalCapital.co.nz to complete a KiwiSaver Health Check now for one less money worry.
Methodology for data collection and sample size:
The figures estimated have been calculated by National Capital by:
Using the December 2019 quarterly fund reports from the individual KiwiSaver providers - we calculated how many members were in the different KiwiSaver fund types (Conservative, Balanced, Growth)
Using the March 2020 quarterly fund reports from the individual KiwiSaver providers - we calculated the same.
The difference provided the number of members who had moved fund categories.
Our sample size equates to 90% of all KiwiSaver members (3million) and looks at the data from 11 major KiwiSaver providers (out of ~25).
Of this, an estimated total of 46,852 members transferred out of Growth and Balanced funds. Extrapolating that to the total number of KiwiSaver members (3,038,246) we estimated that approximately 50,000 Kiwis potentially moved out of Growth/Balanced Funds during the quarter ending March 2020.