Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Law Commission Response To Gordon Copeland

31 October 2007

Gordon Copeland MP
Parliament Buildings

Dear Mr Copeland

Your press release dated 30 October – “Provocation a justifiable defence”

Your press release earlier this week, in defence of provocation law, contained a number of inaccuracies. I am writing to correct those errors, and to briefly explain why the Law Commission is, as you put it, “pushing the issue”. A considerably fuller explanation can, of course, be located in our published report: The Partial Defence of Provocation (NZLC R98) www.lawcom.govt.nz .

Some of the errors to which I have referred are trivial; others are fundamental. To begin with the minor matters: according to your statement, “the Law Society says provocation has only been successful in four out of 81 cases over four years”; the statement subsequently refers to “a tiny number of successful defence cases using provocation – two battered woman [sic], and two men after unwelcome homosexual advances”. The statistics to which you refer are in fact drawn from our own case study, of all Auckland and Wellington murder files between 2001 and 2005: see further Appendix A of our report. This was thus a five-year period; it did not involve the Law Society; and there were four successful cases out of 81 in our sample (which, according to Ministry of Justice figures, comprised approximately 45 percent of the equivalent national total). As regards the nature of the successful cases, there was in fact only one battered woman, and two “homosexual advance” cases; the remaining defendant, Mr Simpson, killed his elderly terminally ill mother.

Your thinly disguised aspersions, to the effect that the Law Commission has been unnecessarily proactive and impetuous on this issue, are also incorrect. As President, it would not normally behove me to call attention to such matters, but on this occasion, I am pleased to be able to report that two differently constituted Law Commissions have considered this partial defence twice (in 2001 and 2007), and recommended its repeal on both occasions; furthermore, the publication of our latest report completes a reference that has been on our books for nearly four years. Furthermore, in the three decades that have elapsed since the Criminal Law Reform Committee first reported on this matter in 1976, four other NZ law reform bodies have independently arrived at the same conclusion. We are thus not alone in our views; nor are we acting suddenly.

Notwithstanding your views expressed to the contrary, provocation patently has not “worked in the past”. Our reasons for recommending the repeal of this archaic defence have very little to do with the small numbers relying on the defence, and the nature of the successful cases. They have a great deal to do with the trouble that it has caused trial and appellate courts, in every jurisdiction, and its redundancy in a legal environment that includes discretionary sentencing for murder. Furthermore, history demonstrates the impossibility of attempting to reform it.

Finally, I note that you may find yourself in a minority with your assertion that there is “no need for change”. Clearly, not everyone supports repeal. The criminal defence bar, in particular, is strongly opposed to this remedy. However, virtually everyone, including the defence bar, agrees that reform of some sort is required.

Yours sincerely

Geoffrey Palmer


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On National Being Shafted By Its Own Creation

As it licks its wounds, let’s hope the National Party can still find time to look back with some pride at what it has achieved in Epsom. The Act Party’s nationwide success on Saturday night has been a tribute to National’s foresight, and to its ability to pick winners. Others would have looked at the dying remnants of the old Act Party and written it off. Yet National needed an MMP partner and it saw the potential where no-one else did. And so it re-grew the Act Party in a petri dish in Epsom, and carefully nurtured it back to life... More>>


Green Party: 'Fruitful Discussions ... Further Discussions To Have'

The Green Party says there is a negotiation going on with the Labour Party, but there are more discussions to be had. More>>


Border: No Changes To Border Exemptions After Fishing Crew Test Covid-19 Positive

The cases were detected after routine day three testing but the immigration minister and air commodore agree there's no need to change border exemptions. More>>

PSA: Labour-Led Government Has Mandate For Transformation, Equality And Transparency

The Public Service Association welcomes the progressive electoral landslide New Zealand voters delivered on Saturday, and the union says its members look forward to implementing policies that reduce poverty and inequality, support affordable housing ... More>>


Poll: Labour On 46%, National 31%, While Greens And ACT Both On 8%

Tonight's political poll puts Labour on 46 percent and National on 31 percent with just one day remaining until election day. More>>


Stats NZ: New Report Shows Significant Changes To New Zealand’s Climate

Climate change is already happening in New Zealand and could have a profound impact on future generations of New Zealanders, a new report from the Ministry for the Environment and Stats NZ says. Our atmosphere and climate 2020 , released today, includes analysis ... More>>


Judith Collins: Obese People Must Take Responsibility For 'personal Choices'

National Party leader Judith Collins has described obesity as a weakness and says people should not 'blame systems for personal choices'. More>>

Māori Party: Poll Reveals Tamihere On Cusp Of Historic Māori Movement Election Victory

John Tamihere’s election campaign is on the rise and on track to return the Māori Party to parliament, a new Māori TV poll has revealed. The poll released on 11 October during the seventh and final Māori TV Maori Electoral campaign coverage has Tamihere ... More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Four-Year Terms Of Parliament, And On How The US Courts Are Dismantling Democracy

Last week, the issue of four-year parliamentary terms surfaced again. Infuriatingly, it is being discussed purely in terms of its convenience for political parties. They’d get so much more time to enact their policies, free of scrutiny or sanction by voters ... More>>





InfoPages News Channels