Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


In praise of proportional representation

In praise of proportional representation

By Sridhar Ekambaram

Now that we are in the midst of trying to decide if we need MMP or not, it is time we put the issues in front of us in perspective and look at alternatives. For the uninitiated, MMP or Mixed Member Proportional system allows voters to make two choices – one for the local candidate as a representative and the other on the party. This was done to provide a more meaningful representation of voters’ choice to include smaller parties as well.

Few issues have come up with this system. For a country with only 70 parliamentary constituencies, there are at least 120 representatives in our parliament, a 70% over representation with multiple representatives for several constituencies.

The alternatives considered in the recent referendum were the traditional First Past the Post, Preferential voting, Single Transferable vote and Supplementary Member system. However, one system, proportional representation has been in existence as a theory but mostly unused

Proportional representation, by definition, gives successful parties number of seats in the parliament in direct proportion to the number of votes they accrue at an election . It works similar to our current MMP system except that there are no electorate representatives, only list members. This system achieves the same results as MMP, i.e. gives smaller parties due representation in parliament. There are several benefits of this system of election.

In the current system, as mentioned earlier, there is over-representation of New Zealanders in the parliament. Elected representatives’ personal policies anyway don’t make any difference in the parliament because voting on legislation is seldom based on individual members and it is always party votes that matter. This leads to the elected representative failing to represent his/her electors who voted on the member’s individual views and policies. Secondly, in the current scenario, members who get elected from a particular constituency seldom reside in the constituency they represent. Third, elected representatives are often voted based on their individual personality, even if they do not have enough influence in the party.

With proportional representation, voting is based on a party’s policies whereas Individual members’ views are irrelevant. Voters need to consider only one aspect, which party best represents his/her needs and is most likely to deliver accordingly, doesn’t matter if the party members are totally worthless, because at the end of the day it is a party’s decisions that prevail in the parliament. If the party feels a particular member is not being good enough, the member can easily be replaced with the next on the list without having to go through costly by-election. There is no issue of overrepresentation since there are no multiple representatives. Normal residence of the member is irrelevant because the member does not represent any constituency anymore, but in essence only the party and the country. They can continue to be in touch with the voters. Since they are not tied to any constituency they can instead represent the entire nation. The total number of seats in the parliament can be scaled back to a manageable level of say 50 or 70 and still giving representation of all eligible parties. Finally, it will prevent individual members from hijacking the party threatening to walk away with their loyal voters.

Some people may still prefer to have some kind of representatives. Elected local city/district councillors good are representing the people and can easily fill that gap, since their job description is similar to members of parliament, with reduced powers. The local councillors can take care of local issues as they are currently doing and the parliament can still take care of issues at a national level.

As a small country New Zealand is a perfect place to try out this system. The members who represent the party will still be able to keep in touch with people to get their views on issues, that gets difficult in a big country with a larger population, since the time required to meet everyone is insufficient.

We can continue to maintain the current 5% threshold levels of voting as minimum necessary to secure seats in the parliament.

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Labour’s Fudging On Child Poverty, And America’s Diplomatic Dance With Iran

If you want a good insight into what the limits of tiny, barely discernible steps to reduce poverty actually look like, delve into the latest Statistics Department figures on poverty in New Zealand Most of the nine measures utilised reveal little or no progress in combatting poverty over the 21 months to March 2020... More>>


Government: Reserve Bank To Take Account Of Housing In Decision Making

The Reserve Bank is now required to consider the impact on housing when making monetary and financial policy decisions, Grant Robertson announced today. Changes have been made to the Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee’s remit requiring it to take into ... More>>


RNZ: Alert Levels Remain

There are no new community cases of Covid-19 today, the Ministry of Health has confirmed.
Covid-19 Response Minister Chris Hipkins says at least half of the Papatoetoe High School community have been tested and the results that have come through so far have all been negative... More>>


Stats NZ: Latest Release Of Child Poverty Statistics

All measures of child poverty were trending downwards, prior to the COVID-19 lockdown, across the two years since year ended June 2018, Stats NZ said today. The COVID-19 lockdown in late March 2020 affected Stats NZ’s ability to collect data from households ... More>>


NZ Initiative: New Report Highlights How Our Housing Crisis Could Worsen If We Don’t Act Now

If New Zealand politicians thought the housing crisis in 2020 was bad, the worst is yet to come, warns a new report by The New Zealand Initiative. In The Need to Build: The demographic drivers of housing demand , Research Assistant Leonard Hong ... More>>

Parliament: Kiwi MPs Among The “Most Educated In The World”

New analysis of MP qualifications reveals New Zealand’s Parliament is one of the most educated and highest qualified in the world, and significantly more educated than Australia’s. The research, by Mark Blackham of BlacklandPR and Geoffrey Miller ... More>>

The Dig: An Illogical Ideological Struggle

Dig beneath all the trade wars and the arguments to the effect that the USA should not permit China to achieve economic and technological superiority, or even parity, and you find the real reason behind the conflict... More>>

Travel: Government Eases Visa Restrictions For Visitors In New Zealand

Visitor visa holders will be able to stay in New Zealand a little longer as the Government eases restrictions for those still here, the Minister of Immigration has announced. More>>




InfoPages News Channels