Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Unpaid meetings and Smiths City

Commentary on the recent decision of the Employment Court (NZEmpC 43 EMPC 313/2016 [2018]) involving Smiths City Group Limited and employees attending unpaid meetings has flooded the media and provided Unions with fertile soil on which to grow their memberships.

Several organisations have declared that the sector they are involved in will be facing large claims for payment of arrears of wages as a result of this decision. Sectors such as aged care, early childhood education, hospitality and others have been referred to in commentary to date.

Before all succumb to this hysteria we should look at what this decision means. Firstly, to generalise, the Court reinforced the principle that if an employee is engaged in an activity that is integral to their job then the time spent should be paid. Secondly, the requirement to pay not less than the rate specified in the Minimum Wages Act for time worked was reinforced. Thirdly, that commissions and bonus payments cannot be taken into account when determining the actual amount paid to employees paid by the hour.

The decision focused primarily on hourly paid employees who were paid an hourly rate that was at or near the applicable minimum wage. The logic is that if pre-start meetings are included as work then the total hours paid would be at a rate less than the minimum wage, i.e. 8 hours worked at the minimum wage of $16.50 = $132.00 per day. If a 15-minute unpaid meeting is included the effective hourly rate paid for the day becomes $15.53 ($132.00 divided by 8.25) and so an underpayment occurs.

It should be noted that these sorts of issues are determined by the facts of the situation. The Smiths City decision is not something that would automatically apply to every situation. If you do hold unpaid meetings, then it is something to think about and you should seek advice as needed.

The case could be considered more interesting when looking at the situations that are not encompassed by the decision. What is the situation where employees attend unpaid meetings but the employees are paid above minimum wage? The Labour Inspector in the Smiths City case could only take action for a breach of the Minimum Wages Act. A similar situation where the employee receives say $18.00 or $20.00 per hour, specified in their employment agreement, could raise some interesting issues.

The circumstances of employees who travel between assignments and who are not paid for this travel time raises questions based on the logic of the Smiths City decision and the travel time agreement reached between the government, employers and unions in the aged care sector. Should such time be included in calculations to ensure that the average hourly rate paid doesn’t drop below the minimum hourly rate?

Employment Law continually evolves through Government action and Court decisions. To ensure you have the best advice please contact us.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Forest & Bird: Report Find Council Failures On Effluent

The report exposes significant inconsistencies and gaps in how regional councils are enforcing the rules around dairy effluent management. More>>


Mana In Mahi: Helping Young New Zealanders Into Work

Thousands of young people will be given the chance to gain valuable qualifications and meaningful work under the Mana in Mahi – Strength in Work scheme launched by Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern today. More>>


Reserve Bank: Official Cash Rate Unchanged At 1.75 Percent

The Official Cash Rate (OCR) remains at 1.75 percent. We expect to keep the OCR at this level through 2019 and into 2020, longer than we projected in our May Statement. The direction of our next OCR move could be up or down. ... More>>

Post-Cabinet Press Conference: Trade Stuff

Jacinda Ardern and David Parker's press conference that focused on the government's 'trade for all agenda' plans for widespread consultation on the shape of future trade agreements... More>>


Debt Capital Markets Summit: Grant Robertson On The Economy

"In short, the heart of our Government’s economic plan is to help New Zealand become a more productive, more sustainable, and more inclusive economy in which all New Zealanders can thrive." More>>


Best Environment Practice For Landcorp Farms: New Forest & Bird And Pāmu Collaboration

New Zealand’s largest conservation organisation and largest farming group have agreed to work together to promote best environmental practice in New Zealand’s farming sector. More>>