Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
License needed for work use Register

Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Chief Justice Involved in ‘Recusal’ Argument

Chief Justice Involved in ‘Recusal’ Argument – Supreme Court Battles Intensify


The Siemer/Stiassny argument has reached right to the top of the judicial heap

The ‘recusal’ and bias arguments against Supreme Court judges has taken on new energy with a Queen’s Counsel making serious allegations in respect of Chief Justice Dame Sian Elias’ role in a case involving her husband, Hugh Fletcher.

The Chief Justice is now becoming embroiled herself in a ‘recusal’ issue, which threatens the future of her fellow jurist, Justice Bill Wilson.

The Stiassny-Siemer defamation battle, a turf war that has been fought viciously for some years and has resulted in one of the largest-ever defamation awards in New Zealand legal history, as well as seeing maverick publisher Vince Siemer jailed, has reared its head again and has Dame Sian Elias, the Chief Justice, at centre stage.

The National Business Review reported this week on a case involving Dame Sian’s husband, Hugh Fletcher who together with Auckland Receiver Michael Stiassny both sit on the board of energy company Vector Limited.

Vector is presently involved in a Supreme Court appeal which, according to documents filed by Vince Siemer’s lawyer, Robert Lithgow QC, directly affect herself and her husband through both financial and horse racing interests the parties jointly share.

Michael Stiassny is also chairman of the New Zealand Racing Board. Both Hugh Fletcher and Dame Sian are enthusiastic racing industry investors and participants. The major issues for Justice Bill Wilson also involves racing, centering upon his heavy financial involvement with Auckland QC Alan Galbraith in the Rich Hill Stud operation.

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading

Are you getting our free newsletter?

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.

Justice Wilson’s involvement has lead to a complaint to the Judicial Conduct Commissioner, David Gasgoigne, who in turn has recruited the assistance of former Australian Chief Justice Murray Gleeson to determine how the complaint issue against the judge should be handled.

The National Business Review reported on the issue involving Dame Sian, saying there was an “intersection of relationships” that gave rise to an appearance of bias that was sufficient to require the Chief Justice to ‘recuse’ herself from the appeal involving Vector, and therefore her husband.

The NBR reports that Robert Lithgow said Liquidator Stiassny was a powerful, well resourced man. ”As a company director and a professional receiver and liquidator of companies he sometimes reported directly to High Court judges or associate judges,” Lithgow said.

“In that role he no doubt holds many secrets and confidences of the Auckland business community and beyond. But now, what was essentially his private interest argument with another businessman, now has the support of the State through the junior law officer,” which evidently is a reference to Solicitor General David Collins QC, a staunch supporter of Justice Wilson.

Lithgow said that the restructuring of Vector Limited, a controversial move that was subject to heavy criticism and debate, saw Hugh Fletcher remain on the board.

“Does that make him aligned to Mr Stiassny, beholden to Mr Stiassny, wary or proud to be associated with him?” Lithgow says.

He said the question must be how that relationship factors into the relationship between Mr Fletcher and is wife – Chief Justice Elias.

“If the judge has to pause for one split second to consider whether if her decision, or her agreement attaches to a decision, harms Mr Stiassny’s interests…could that in turn do harm to her husband’s interests, then what is an entirely proper protective instinct of a spouse…becomes a liability to detached and dispassionate decision making.”

Meanwhile, Vince Siemer has a civil rights claim to the Court of Appeal naming Dame Sian as a defendant and which alleges a miscarriage of justice, as well as a Supreme Court appeal.


© Scoop Media

Advertisement - scroll to continue reading
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Government's Assault On Maori

This isn’t news, but the National-led coalition is mounting a sustained assault on Treaty rights and obligations. Even so, Christopher Luxon has described yesterday’s nationwide protests by Maori as “pretty unfair.” Poor thing. In the NZ Herald, Audrey Young has compiled a useful list of the many, many ways that Luxon plans to roll back the progress made here over the past 40 years in race relations... More

Public Housing Futures: Christmas Comes Early For Landlords

New CTU analysis of the National & ACT coalition agreement has shown the cost of returning interest deductibility to landlords is an extra $900M on top of National’s original proposal. This is because it is going to be implemented earlier and faster, including retrospective rebates from April 2023. More

Green Party: Petition To Save Oil & Gas Ban

“The new Government’s plan to expand oil and gas exploration is as dangerous as it is unscientific. Whatever you think about the new government, there is simply no mandate to trash the climate. We need to come together to stop them,” says James Shaw. More

PSA: MFAT Must Reverse Decision To Remove Te Reo

MFAT's decision to remove te reo from correspondence before new Ministers are sworn in risks undermining the important progress the public sector has made in honouring te Tiriti. "We are very disappointed in what is a backward decision - it simply seems to be a Ministry bowing to the racist rhetoric we heard on the election campaign trail," says Marcia Puru. More




InfoPages News Channels


Join Our Free Newsletter

Subscribe to Scoop’s 'The Catch Up' our free weekly newsletter sent to your inbox every Monday with stories from across our network.