Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Employment proposals out of step with practice

Media release
22 June 2008

Employment proposals out of step with commercial practice

Tinkering with employment law relating to casuals and temps could blow out costs for the Rugby World Cup and other events, Business NZ warned today.

The Government is seeking to change the Employment Relations Act to give some casual workers the same pay and conditions as permanent staff.

“That would blow the labour hire industry out of the water,” said Business NZ Chief Executive Phil O’Reilly.

“It would make temp agencies uneconomic and there would be huge ramifications for events like the Rugby World Cup that rely on large numbers of temporary workers.

“Large infrastructure projects like roading also rely heavily on the labour hire industry and we could see delays in building new infrastructure.”

Mr O’Reilly said the proposal was no doubt motivated by good intentions, but was out of step with how the commercial world operated.

“Temporary and permanent staff are needed and used in different ways. They have the same employment rights, but these are delivered differently – for example temps get payment in lieu of holidays. It doesn’t make sense to try and make them the same.”

The Government’s proposed code of practice also includes labour inspectors having the power to say whether a worker was a casual or permanent worker. Mr O’Reilly said this was misguided.

“This is a very complex area of employment law that has resulted in many appealed decisions to higher courts – for example the Bryson case that went all the way to the Supreme Court. It is not realistic to expect labour inspectors to make rulings in this area.”

Despite these concerns about the proposed code of practice, Mr O’Reilly said business was totally supportive of moves to make all employees – permanent, causal or temporary – more aware of their rights.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Statistics: Retail Card Spending Down 0.2 Percent In July
Retail card spending fell $11 million (0.2 percent) between June 2022 and July 2022, when adjusted for seasonal effects, Stats NZ said today... More>>

Barfoot & Thompson: Auckland Rental Prices Inch Up Again, But Upward Trend Could Ease In Coming Months

Data from nearly 16,000 rental properties managed by real estate agency Barfoot & Thompson shows Auckland’s average weekly rent rose by $6.12 (or 1 percent) during the second quarter... More>>

ComCom: Draft Report Says Regulatory System Favours Established Building Products
The Commerce Commission’s draft report into competition in the residential building supplies industry has identified two main factors negatively impacting competition... More>>

Commerce Commission: Draft Determination On News Publishers’ Association’s Collective Bargaining Application
The Commerce Commission (Commission) has reached a preliminary view that it should allow the News Publishers’ Association of New Zealand (NPA) to collectively negotiate with Meta and Google... More>>

Heartland: Retirees Facing Pressure From Higher Cost Of Living And Increasing Debt In Retirement

Heartland has seen a significant increase in Reverse Mortgages being used to repay debt. Among the most affected by the increasing living costs are retirees, many of whom are trying to get by on NZ Super alone... More>>

APEC: Region’s Growth To Slow Amid Uncertainties And Crises
Economic growth in the APEC region is expected to slow this year amid soaring inflation, a protracted war in Ukraine and heightened uncertainties, on top of the continuing impact of the pandemic and virus mutations that are draining resources, according to a new report by the APEC Policy Support Unit... More>>