Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Glenharrow Holdings Ltd v Inland Revenue

Supreme Court of New Zealand
19 December 2008
Glenharrow Holdings Ltd v Commissioner of Inland Revenue
(SC 59/2007 [2008] NZSC 116)
This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court’s judgment. It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment.

The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document. The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at

The Supreme Court has unanimously dismissed an appeal by Glenharrow Holdings Ltd in its claim against the Commissioner of Inland Revenue seeking a GST tax refund of the tax fraction (one-ninth) of an amount of $45m which was the purchase price in 1997 of a licence to mine serpentinite and bowenite in Westland. Under the arrangements between the vendor of the licence, Glenharrow and its controlling shareholder a deposit of $80,000 was paid and the balance of the price was discharged and an equivalent amount advanced back to Glenharrow by an exchange of cheques when the license was transferred to Glenharrow, which was a shell company with no other assets.

Only a relatively small amount of stone was extracted before the licence expired three years later and only $210,000 of the advance was ever repaid.

The High Court largely disallowed Glenharrow’s claim, ordering the Commissioner of Inland Revenue to credit Glenharrow with a GST refund of the tax fraction of the Court’s valuation of the licence ($9.75m). The Court of Appeal dismissed Glenharrow’s appeal and, allowing a cross-appeal by the Commissioner, reduced the tax refund to the tax fraction of the payments actually made by Glenharrow.

The Supreme Court has confirmed that ruling, agreeing that the Commissioner was entitled to invoke s 76 of the GST Act 1985 and to treat the arrangement as a tax avoidance. The Court has found that the arrangement entered into to defeat the intent and application of the Act: the price was not paid in economic terms, even though as between the parties a debt was discharged. The structure adopted by the parties achieved no economic effect and nothing significant in commercial terms.



© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Civil Contractors: Massive Rebound In Civil Construction Business Confidence

New Zealand’s civil construction industry is riding a massive rebound in post-pandemic business confidence – but this may be undermined by skills shortages, which continue to be the industry’s number one challenge... More>>

Energy: Feeling Our Way Towards Hydrogen - Tina Schirr

Right now hydrogen is getting a lot of attention. Many countries are focusing on producing hydrogen for fuel, or procuring it, or planning for its future use... More>>

Maritime Union: Calls For New Zealand Shipping To Resolve Supply Chain Crisis

The Maritime Union says there needs to be innovative responses to ongoing shipping congestion. Maritime Union of New Zealand National Secretary Craig Harrison says it is essential that New Zealand develops its own shipping capacity... More>>

Housing: New Home Consents Continue To Break Records

A record 44,299 new homes were consented in the year ended June 2021, Stats NZ said today. “The annual number of new homes consented rose again in the June 2021 year, the fourth consecutive month of rises,” construction statistics manager Michael Heslop said... More>>

Real Estate: June Home Transfers Remain High
There were 44,517 home transfers in the June 2021 quarter, the highest June quarter figure since 2016, Stats NZ said today. The number of home transfers was very similar to the March 2021 quarter and was up 18,252 from the June 2020 quarter... More>>

Statistics: Household Saving Falls In The March 2021 Quarter

Saving by New Zealanders in the March 2021 quarter fell to its lowest level in two years after rising sharply in 2020, Stats NZ said today. Increases in household spending outpaced income growth, leading to a decline in household saving from the elevated levels that prevailed throughout 2020... More>>