Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Unique copyright laws tested in furniture dispute

Unique copyright laws tested in furniture dispute

A court case involving alleged knock-off furniture highlights a unique aspect of New Zealand copyright law, according to intellectual property specialists James & Wells.

James & Wells client Plantation Grown Timbers (PGT) designs and produces collections of furniture made from reclaimed timber and exports furniture into many markets including New Zealand. It is owned by Australian citizen Ian Burden.

PGT (which manufactures its furniture in Vietnam) has claimed breach of copyright over furniture that was imported to New Zealand by a rival company last year. It has also made claims for misleading and/or deceptive conduct in breach of the Fair Trading Act.

PGT claims the imported furniture items infringe the copyright in its original design drawings. It has intellectual property rights notices in place with New Zealand Customs Service, which stopped the shipments in light of PGT’s copyright notice.

James & Wells Partner Gus Hazel says the case involves an aspect of New Zealand intellectual property law that makes us stand out from other countries.

“New Zealand has unique copyright laws which allow an author of an original work to enforce copyright rights in the drawings underlying 3D objects, even after they have been ‘industrially applied,” he says.

In most countries such rights cannot be enforced after industrial application (which typically means the manufacture of 50 or more objects from the drawings).

Earlier this year the High Court declined an application by one of the defendants (ESR Group, which runs the ‘Early Settler’ chain of furniture stores) to have the detained items of furniture released by Customs.

The trial to determine the copyright and Fair Trading Act claims took more than three weeks but has now come to a close in the High Court. The plaintiffs are of course hoping for a positive outcome, and are pleased to have had an opportunity to tell their story. Given the complexity of the case and the large volume of evidence it may take some time for a decision from the Court.

Mr Hazel says New Zealand’s copyright laws offer important protections for companies such as PGT and their designs.

“A lot of time, skill and effort goes into designing furniture items, and winning market success, and so our clients wish to prevent others making unauthorised use of their original works and free-riding on their hard work.”

“The more knock-offs there are in the market, the more the customer base and reputation is diluted,” he says.

He added that he was particularly pleased to have worked closely with PGT’s primary Australian lawyer (Richard Stone of Stone Lawyers), who has a detailed knowledge of the industry and the key players. Mr Stone was co-counsel over the course of the trial at Auckland.

“It’s another example of a great trans-Tasman working relationship to provide the best service to the client.”

Gus Hazel is a Partner at James & Wells and leads the Auckland office’s legal team. He has plenty of experience when it comes to litigation, including alternative resolution procedures, commercialisation, regulatory issues and administrative law.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Foodstuffs: New World & Four Square Trial NZ’s First Grocery Delivery Offer With Uber Eats

New World & Four Square have partnered with Uber Eats to unlock the first grocery offering available on the platform in Aotearoa. For New World and Four Square it’s yet another way to put New Zealanders first, particularly with those inevitable last-minute grocery needs... More>>

Digitl: Download 2.0 – Vodafone Wi-Fi Calling hits early milestone
Vodafone says it has 10,000 customers using its Wi-Fi Calling service. It took less than three months to reach that milestone; the service began operating in September... More>>

Energy Resources Aotearoa: New Law On Decommissioning Could Be Costly Overkill
A new law on decommissioning oil and gas fields passed by Parliament today has good intentions but is overkill, according to Energy Resources Aotearoa. "We strongly support operators taking responsibility and paying the costs for decommissioning, which is what all good operators do," says chief executive John Carnegie... More>>

ABC Business Sales: Demand High For Covid-proof Businesses
Despite the continuing challenges facing businesses in this Covid environment, right now there are more buyers looking for a small-medium sized business than there are sellers in the market... More>>

PriceSpy: Producer Prices Increase
New Black Friday and Covid-19 Report* released by PriceSpy says people’s fear of stepping inside physical shops during big sales events like Black Friday has risen since last year; Kiwis are still planning to shop, but more than ever will do it online this year... More>>

NZ Skeptics Society: Announce Their 2021 Awards, And Dr Simon Thornley Wins The Bent Spoon

Every year the New Zealand Skeptics presents its awards to people and organisations who have impressed us or dismayed us, and this year it’s been hard to pick our winners because there have been so many choices!.. More>>

REINZ: Sales Volumes Leveling Out

Data released today by the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand (REINZ) shows there were 44 fewer lifestyle property sales (-2.6%) for the three months ended October 2021 than for the three months ended September 2021... More>>