Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Why The Price Of Property In Auckland Is Irrelevant

Last week, I spoke with Kerry McIvor on Newstalk ZB to discuss the “housing crisis”. The “housing crisis” term is used as an excuse for some form of price control or to illustrate the need for more property. In this article, I talk on both.

There is a large media focus on Reserve Bank Governor, Adrian Orr and Finance Minister, Grant Robertson to apply the fiscal and monetary brakes. With the implication that fiscal and monetary policy will somehow bring prices to some ‘correct’ level.

There are a number of models and formulas that are frequently used to show that a house or wider market is overpriced. Median property to median income ratios nearing 10x are often quoted to illustrate Auckland’s un-affordability on a global stage. However, assuming capital is global, property in Auckland is actually undervalued, if we compare median rental yield on the same global stage. Arbitrary models are often used to justify political means and typically, are one sided in their presentation. The price of property reflects market conditions and doesn’t care for our opinion on what a property is ‘worth’.

What we see in Auckland currently, is a lack of supply, with a slowly increasing level of demand, this mismatch results in higher prices. We can see this in the average number of people per household, Auckland has 3.2, while the average for NZ is 2.8.

So, easing price can only be solved by increasing supply.

Now we have isolated supply as the side of the equation we need to fix, the conversation needs to focus on the most efficient way in which this can be adjusted.

When assessing any housing policy, I assess it with one key lens; is this the most efficient allocation of resources?

There is a lot of discussion on capital gains tax, changes to bright lines tax and other various fiscal and monetary measures to stem the increasing price side of the equation.

To focus on price rather than supply, is to focus on the symptom, not the source of the issue.

Will property taxes increase supply?

They might, if the Government can allocate resources more efficiently and build houses more efficiently than the private sector. However, as we have seen, this is not the case.

There are two key areas the Government of the day can focus on that will immediately affect the price of property. a) increase supply; and b) promote the flow of property in the market.

The most efficient way to build more units is at present, through the private sector. It appears that more support for the private sector will result in the greatest addition of new housing stock to the market.

Making it as easy as possible for people to sell properties will also increase supply to market. Extending the bright line test will likely mean people will avoid selling, instead recycling their equity to avoid tax, buy more property, and there will be an even greater divide between those with assets and those without.

Less circulation means less supply, which we figured out earlier, will only increase price.

One easy strategy the Government can use, is to simply repurpose the billion odd dollars earmarked for Kiwibuild and guarantee further purchase of housing stock off private developers. The infrastructure is already there, there is a massive flow on effect throughout the economy and there will be many millions saved in administration and bureaucracy costs.

To quote Winston Churchill; "For a nation to tax itself into prosperity is like a man standing in a bucket and trying to lift himself up by the handle.”

© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


TradeMe: Property Prices In Every Region Hit New High For The Very First Time

Property prices experienced their hottest month on record in December, with record highs in every region, according to the latest Trade Me Property Price Index.\ Trade Me Property spokesperson Logan Mudge said the property market ended the year with ... More>>

Motor Industry Association: 2020 New Vehicle Registrations Suffer From Covid-19

Chief Executive David Crawford says that like some other sectors of the New Zealand economy, the new vehicle sector suffered from a case of Covid-19. Confirmed figures for December 2020 show registrations of 8,383 were 25% ... More>>

CTU 2021 Work Life Survey: COVID And Bullying Hit Workplaces Hard, Huge Support For Increased Sick Leave

New data from the CTU’s annual work life survey shows a snapshot of working people’s experiences and outlook heading out of 2020 and into the new year. Concerningly 42% of respondents cite workplace bullying as an issue in their workplace - a number ... More>>

Smelter: Tiwai Deal Gives Time For Managed Transition

Today’s deal between Meridian and Rio Tinto for the Tiwai smelter to remain open another four years provides time for a managed transition for Southland. “The deal provides welcome certainty to the Southland community by protecting jobs and incomes as the region plans for the future. The Government is committed to working on a managed transition with the local community,” Grant Robertson said. More>>


OECD: Area Employment Rate Rose By 1.9 Percentage Points In The Third Quarter Of 2020

OECD area employment rate rose by 1.9 percentage points in the third quarter of 2020, but remained 2.5 percentage points below its pre-pandemic level The OECD area [1] employment rate – the share of the working-age population with jobs – rose ... More>>

Economy: Strong Job Ad Performance In Quarter Four

SEEK Quarterly Employment Report data shows a positive q/q performance with a 19% national growth in jobs advertised during Q4 2020, which includes October, November and December. Comparing quarter 4, 2020, with the same quarter in 2019 shows that job ad volumes are 7% lower...More>>

NIWA: 2020 - NZ’s 7th-warmest Year On Record

The nationwide average temperature for 2020, calculated using stations in NIWA’s seven-station temperature series which began in 1909, was 13.24°C (0.63°C above the 1981–2010 annual average). New Zealand’s hottest year on record remains 2016, when... More>>

Quotable Value New Zealand: Property Market Set To Cool From Sizzling To Warm In 2021

Nostradamus himself could not have predicted the strange series of events that befell our world in 2020 – nor the wild trajectory of New Zealand’s property market, which has gone from “doom and gloom” to “boom and Zoom” in record time. Even ... More>>