Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Used vehicle imports: Court backs call for change

Organisations representing used vehicle importers and dealers say a High Court ruling backs their call for change in the way Land Transport New Zealand administers vehicle compliance rules.

LTNZ has lost a landmark case based on its insistence that used vehicle importers obtain compliance statements from manufacturers' agents to show each imported vehicle meets approved standards.

Both the Independent Motor Vehicle Dealers Association (IMVDA) and the Motor Trade Association (MTA) are calling for LTNZ officials to meet with them to develop a sensible approach that reflects the High Court judgment.

IMVDA chief executive David Vinsen said the court decision highlighted the fact the government agency's requirements "allow vehicle manufacturers to use compliance rules to selectively shut out used-import competition".

Although the case involved an expensive Ferrari, it was typical of situations applying to more mainstream vehicles and urgently needed changing.

"Consumers are paying thousands of dollars more than they should for near-new vehicles as a result of manufacturers' manipulation of the rules," he said.

"Land Transport NZ must ensure used imports are safe. However, it is inequitable and anti-competitive for new vehicle distributors to control the situation by refusing to supply statements of compliance.

"As a result of this court decision, LTNZ should take a new approach and accept whole vehicle model ranges meet compliance standards instead of applying vehicle-by-vehicle scrutiny to used imports."

MTA communications manager Andy Cuming said LTNZ must address the issue in the process it used.

"It is our belief that removal of this impediment to open competition will benefit the consumer," he said.

LTNZ sought a High Court review of a District Court ruling which reversed its refusal to register a 1999 Ferrari 360 Modena imported by Jerry Clayton's Kiwi Auto Exports PTE Ltd.

In a reserved decision, Justice David Baragwanath confirmed the District Court was entitled to overturn LTNZ's refusal and awarded costs against LTNZ.

Earlier this year District Court Judge Ann Kiernan ruled Mr Clayton had shown the vehicle complied with safety rules based on a number of factors, including that the model was type-compliant and LTNZ had accepted a manufacturer's statement of compliance in the past for the same model.

Judge Ann Kiernan also awarded costs against LTNZ.

She said compliance laws allowed manufacturers to control the market in their own interests.

"Because of the structure of the legislation and regulations it is clear that vehicle manufacturers' representatives can pursue their own commercial interests in declining to provide other entities, private or commercial, with certificates of compliance which would be accepted by the respondent (LTNZ)."

"Until that procedure is altered by amendment to the statutory scheme, the only commercial interests being protected currently are those of vehicle manufacturers' representatives", she said.

Mr Clayton, a former new vehicle dealer now importing second-hand vehicles through Singapore, has spent more than $70,000 on the case in a bid to have the used-imports industry and its customers treated the same as new vehicles.

"New car dealers want to control the market by what amounts to a restrictive trade practice," he said.

"This case shows the courts don't support LTNZ's pedantic approach.

"The question now is how long will LTNZ continue to use taxpayers' money to force importers to fight it car-by-car while it grants blanket approvals to whole model ranges of new vehicles?"

Steve Ward, head of odometer certification firm Optimech, has fought and won similar cases against LTNZ and assisted Mr Clayton in the latest case.

"Used imports were supposed to make vehicles more affordable for the average New Zealand consumer, and also safer and more environment-friendly by reducing the age of our fleet."

"But instead, the government and the bureaucrats are allowing their own regulations to be mis-used to protect the commercial interests of manufacturers and new vehicle distributors."

Mr Ward said individuals and businesses throughout the motor industry had pledged more than $150,000 to a fighting fund aimed at "either having the bureaucrats see sense, or getting the law itself changed".


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Transport Industry Association: Feb 2021 New Vehicle Registrations Strongest On Record

Motor Industry Association Chief Executive David Crawford says that the February 2021 figures are the strongest for the month of February ever. Registrations of 12,358 were 8.0% up on February 2020. Year to date the market is up 7.1% (1,735 units) compared to the first two months of 2020... More>>

Paymark: Lockdown Equals Slowdown For Some

The three days of lockdown for Auckland earlier this month made a clear impression on our retail spending figures. While only Auckland moved into Level 3 lockdown, the impact was felt across the country, albeit at different levels. Looking at the ... More>>

Infrastructure Commission: Te Waihanga Releases Report On Water Infrastructure

The New Zealand Infrastructure Commission, Te Waihanga’s latest discussion document highlights the importance of current reforms in the water sector. Its State of Play discussion document about water infrastructure is one of a series looking at the ... More>>

Sci-Tech: Perseverance Rover Lands On Mars – Expert Reaction

NASA has landed a car-sized rover on the red planet to search for signs of past life. The vehicle has more instruments than the four rovers preceding it, and it’s also carrying gear that could help pave the way for human exploration of Mars. The ... More>>


Hemp Industries Association: Could The Next Team NZ Boat Be Made Entirely Of Hemp?

With The America’s Cup due to start in a few days’ time, innovators from a very different sphere have been wondering how long it could be before New Zealand could be competing in a boat entirely built from hemp, with the crew eating high-energy, nutritious hemp-infused foods and wearing high-performance hemp kit..? More>>

ACT: Matariki Almost A Half Billion Dollar Tax On Business

“Official advice to the Government says an extra public holiday at Matariki could cost almost $450 million,” ACT Leader David Seymour can reveal. “This is a perfect example of the Prime Minister doing what’s popular versus what’s responsible. ... More>>

Genesis: Assessing 6,000 GWh Of Renewable Generation Options For Development By 2025

Genesis is assessing 6,000 GWh of renewable generation options for development after starting a closed RFP process with 11 partners. Those invited to participate offer a range of technologies as Genesis continues to execute its Future-gen strategy to ... More>>

OECD: Unemployment Rate Stable At 6.9% In December 2020, 1.7 Percentage Points Higher Than In February 2020

The OECD area unemployment rate was stable at 6.9% in December 2020, remaining 1.7 percentage points above the level observed in February 2020, before the COVID-19 pandemic hit the labour market. [1] In December, the unemployment rate was also stable ... More>>