Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Court Decision Shows RMA Flawed

Court Decision Shows RMA Flawed

An Appeal Court decision in favour of an environmentalist group has highlighted the urgent need for reform of the Resource Management Act, said Bruce McNab of Federated Farmers of New Zealand.

“The bottom line is that the court decision will have a potentially adverse effect on farmers’ ‘right to farm’ their own land. It also has potential to increase the ability of councils to provide for the protection of amenity values such as views and landscapes,” Mr McNab said.

“There are already sufficient protections for these amenity values and farmers are increasingly being stopped from farming. This has to change and amending the RMA is the best way to achieve it.

“Farmers support the RMA’s ethos of sustainable development, but the pendulum has swung too far toward environmental sustainability. Protecting the livelihoods of people who have farmed for generations is not being taken into account,” Mr McNab said.

The logic used by the court to reach its conclusion is flawed and extremely worrying, Mr McNab said.

“Perhaps the most worrying aspect is the reading by the Court of what it calls a ’precautionary approach’ to the evaluation of plan provisions that is required under section 32 of the RMA.

“Unfortunately, the Court does not elaborate on what it means by a ‘precautionary approach’. But it is clear that ‘precautionary approach’ is to apply when a council has ‘insufficient information about an activity to determine what provision should be made for that activity’ in a plan.

“The question that arises from this is: When will a council have sufficient information?

“Such an approach is incompatible with a basic presumption that a land use activity can be undertaken ‘as of right’ unless the plan provides otherwise.

“The onus should be on councils to ensure they have sufficient information to justify regulating, and to justify the level of regulation – not the other way round.

“Thus, as it stands, the Court of Appeal decision appears to give greater powers to councils to involve themselves in land-use activities, which isn’t good for farmers.

“The Federation has a ‘six pack’ of solutions to problems with the RMA, which relates to the decision’s potentially adverse impact on farmers’ freedom to farm and its potential to increase the ability of councils to provide for the protection of amenity values. On November 20 the Federation will release a booklet summarising its suggestions for fixing the Act,” Mr McNab said.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Frog Recruitment: Kiwi Workers Reluctant To Make Business Trips Across The Ditch Despite Trans-Tasman Bubble Opening

When the trans-Tasman travel bubble opens today, many Kiwi companies won't be rushing to buy an air ticket, reluctant to cross the ditch to do business. The latest survey conducted by leading recruitment agency, Frog Recruitment of nearly 1,000 New Zealand ... More>>

Tourism: Employers Welcome Back Working Holidaymakers

Tourism businesses gearing up for the return of Australian visitors from next week will be relieved to learn that they will also have access to an offshore pool of much-needed job candidates, Tourism Industry Aotearoa says. Tourism employers around ... More>>

Commerce Commission: Latest Broadband Report Confirms Improved Performance Of Premium Fibre Plans

The latest report from the Commerce Commission’s Measuring Broadband New Zealand programme shows that the performance of Fibre Max plans has improved substantially. This follows a collaboration between the Commission, its independent testing partner, ... More>>

Air New Zealand: Capital Raise Deferred

Air New Zealand has decided to defer its planned capital raise to later in 2021 allowing more time to assess the impacts of recent developments on the airline’s path to recovery. 'We’ve seen some clearing of COVID-19 clouds recently, with ... More>>

Stats NZ: Prices For Transport And Housing Rise In March 2021 Quarter

Higher prices for transport and housing led to a 0.8 percent lift in the consumers price index in the March 2021 quarter, Stats NZ said today. Prices for getting around rose in the March quarter. Transport prices rose 3.9 percent, the biggest quarterly ... More>>

Stats NZ: New Report Shows Impact Of Demands On Land In New Zealand

A new environmental report released today by the Ministry for the Environment and Stats NZ, presents new data on New Zealand’s land cover, soil quality, and land fragmentation. The land cover data in the report, Our land 2021 , provides the most ... More>>


Stats NZ: March Card Spending Rebounds Despite COVID

There was a lift in retail card spending in March following a fall in the lockdown-disrupted February month, Stats NZ said today. Seasonally adjusted retail card spending rose by $53 million (0.9 percent), compared with February 2021. Visit our website to read ... More>>