Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

A High Growth-Low Welfare State

A High Growth-Low Welfare State

Hon Sir Roger Douglas, ACT New Zealand

February 15 2009


The reactions to my Orewa speech (Brian Fallow, New Zealand Herald 'wealthy get tax relief' or John Key, 'idea is fundamentally flawed'), are disappointing but not surprising - clearly, the politics of gesture or pigeon-holing still reigns supreme while New Zealand's problems escalate.

Will the policy I outlined at Orewa help the rich? It will - but not nearly as much as it will help the poor. Why? Because rich and poor taxpayers alike get precisely the same tax relief: $6,150.

That means someone on $30,000 per annum will pay no tax at all, while someone on $100,000 will pay no tax on the first $30,000. Thereafter, they will pay a flat rate on the balance of $70,000. It is the current system, apparently supported by Fallow and Key, that denies options and opportunities to the poor - while the poor are forced to queue for healthcare, (sometimes dying on the waiting list), the wealthy get the care they need through private provision.

How is it then, that the option I propose - which puts the poor in the same position as the rich and allows them to get treatment when they need it - hurts the poor?

The poor will also have $4,000 a year inflation-proofed to save for their retirement compared to being unable to save under the present system. For someone saving under this option from ages 18 to 65, that equates to $1.8m or $850,000 in dollar-of-the-day terms.

How does this adversely impact on the poor? Or is it simply that there are some who want the poor to rely on the good-will of the taxpayer or the whim of a politician?

The size of Government spending is set to balloon under National from 30 to 36 percent. The tax-cuts will be financed by mortgaging our future, with the interest on the increased debt having to be paid back by future generations.

Under Labour, we mortgaged our houses to buy consumer goods; under National, we are about to mortgage our children's future. Under Labour's rules, New Zealand became a high-tax low-growth welfare state.

My speech at Orewa shows how to obtain a high-growth low-tax welfare state. Labour moved the State from a growth-oriented model to an income re-distribution model. This saw New Zealand take a dive in productivity from three percent to around one percent.

In New Zealand we have come to believe that we are all getting a free lunch. There is no free lunch. For instance: pensioners may enjoy free trips to Waiheke but, unless you know what kind of trade-off has been made to obtain such free rides, it is hard to think of this as bad policy.But let us go back to the cut in productivity and, hence, the foregone rises in the average wage resultant from the policies of redistribution.

For pensioners the dive from three percent to one percent productivity-growth per year over the past nine years has meant they are missing out on around $100 per week per couple. Those who thank the past Labour Government for their free trips to Waiheke - and other redistribution policies, like more money for art and racing - need to think again.

For wage earners, was the loss of around $180 per week really worth it? Or for pensioners, around $100 per couple? Perhaps we should stop fiddling with the cents; and get on with the dollars.


ENDS


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Whakaari / White Island Eruption: Body recovery operation

Six bodies have been successfully recovered from Whakaari / White Island... More>>

Police Update: Plan To Recover Bodies
"I can now confirm that we are finalising a plan to recover the bodies from Whakaari / White Island tomorrow morning. Families will be briefed on the operation at 4.30pm and Deputy Commissioner Mike Clement will speak with media in Whakatane." More>>

 
 

Gordon Campbell: On Welfare Vs Infrastructure Spending

If New Zealand has a pressing need to stimulate its flagging economy, it seems very weird that the government is choosing a $12 billion package of infrastructure spending – mainly on road and rail – that by definition, will take a very long time to deliver their stimulatory benefits ... More>>

New Reports: "Immediate Commitment To Doing Justice Differently"

Justice Minister Andrew Little released two reports today, Turuki! Turuki! from Te Uepū Hāpai I te Ora, and Te Tangi o te Manawanui: Recommendations for Reform from the Chief Victims Advisor. Both recommend a fresh approach to the way criminal justice has been approached... More>>

ALSO:

"Heart-Breaking And Confronting": Surgical Mesh Restorative Justice Report

Minister Genter: “People have talked about losing the life they had enjoyed before surgical mesh harmed them – the loss of a steady job, the ability to exercise, a loving relationship in some cases. Others described the chronic pain they experienced..." More>>

ALSO:

Law Foundation: Government Decryption Powers Must Respect Privacy

The power of government to order users and companies to decrypt encrypted data and devices needs stronger privacy protections and additional safeguards, according to a study published by researchers at the University of Waikato. More>>

Latest 'Discussion Doc': National On Healthcare

National has today released our eighth Discussion Document which focusses on health and outlines a range of policies which will enable more Kiwis to access high-quality healthcare, Leader of the Opposition Simon Bridges says. More>>

ALSO:

Select Committee Report: Combatting Foreign Election Interference

MPs have finally delivered their recommendations to combat foreign interference in elections in a long awaited and much delayed report. More>>

Mosque Attacks: Names Of Arresting Officers Released

Police are now in the position to name the two officers involved in the arrest of the alleged gunman responsible for the attacks on the Al Noor and Linwood Mosques on March 15. More>>

Big, Bold, Permanent Change Needed: Children's Commissioner On 2019 Child Poverty Monitor

“I want to see family incomes dramatically raised by increasing benefits and making the minimum wage a living wage. And the Government needs to move much faster at increasing the supply of social housing..." More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 


 

InfoPages News Channels