Video | Business Headlines | Internet | Science | Scientific Ethics | Technology | Search

 

Time for New Zealand to revisit the genetic modification deb

MCGUINNESS INSTITUTE MEDIA RELEASE 29 AUGUST 2013

Time for New Zealand to revisit the genetic modification debate

McGuinness Institute’s latest report assesses 40 years of GM public policy in New Zealand and concludes there is more work to do

Today the McGuinness Institute is pleased to announce the publication of An Overview of Genetic Modification in New Zealand 1973–2013: The first forty years.

The Institute’s chief executive, Wendy McGuinness, says, ‘the report found that strategically, New Zealand is no further ahead on public policy regarding outdoor use of GMOs than it was when the Royal Commission on Genetic Modification reported its findings in 2001. Indeed, we consider New Zealand is less equipped to make a strategic decision to release GMOs in the outdoors in 2013 than it was a decade ago.

The report forms part of the Institute’s flagship project, Project 2058. Forty years since the development of genetic modification (GM), the Institute believes it is timely to reassess New Zealand’s approach to managing the benefits, costs and risks. The report provides a comprehensive overview of policy development through four key eras: (1) the journey towards the 2001 Royal Commission on Genetic Modification; (2) the Royal Commission and its findings, (3) the response to the Royal Commission, and (4) the era of institutional change from 2008 – 2013. See attached: The First Forty years of GM: By the Numbers.

McGuinness says, ‘we found that many of the initiatives put in place after the Royal Commission, have since been disestablished or not progressed. Since 2001, New Zealand has significantly reduced its ability to collect strategic information that would enable informed decisions on GM to be taken. For example, New Zealand has disestablished the Bioethics Council (2009); discontinued Futurewatch, a work programme of MoRST (2011); discontinued the Bioscience Survey, formerly undertaken by Statistics NZ (2013), and has not reviewed or updated the Biotechnology Strategy, published in 2003 and due to expire this year.’

McGuinness notes that the Institute also found ‘considerable evidence of a system that is showing symptoms of fatigue. Largely due to the significant institutional change that has occurred in the last five years, information is not well collected or reported, and institutional knowledge and therefore analytical capability and institutional linkages are likely to be significantly reduced.’

In addition, she says, recent moves by a number of local authorities to use the RMA to restrict outdoor GM research and releases demonstrates on-going concern in local communities about this issue, concerns that are yet to be addressed by central government.

‘The 2001 Royal Commission on Genetic Modification proposed a strategic pathway, making 49 recommendations on the way forward. Twelve years later, with little evidence that outdoor research has generated any significant benefit for New Zealand, and continued consumer resistance to GM food globally, it seems timely to ask whether New Zealand is now better placed to make a decision to remain a GM-free food and fibre producer in the outdoors.’

The Institute’s report makes 12 recommendations on how the current system could be strengthened, stressing the need for transparency, accountability, and consideration of the interests of all New Zealanders.

The report concludes by reflecting on the proposal that ‘the most risk-adverse solution is to close down New Zealand’s only two GM outdoor experiments on the basis that they create unnecessary public risk, with little or no public benefit, and to use those funds elsewhere. Currently the only two outdoor field tests are being operated by two Crown Research Institutes, AgResearch and Scion, and could therefore be closed down by government.

Our approach to GM crops in the outdoors is threefold: (1) Buy time, (2) Undertake a systemic review and (3) Think strategically. See attached: The Three Stage Process.

‘The recent situation where Fonterra and New Zealand’s reputation were damaged by a contamination scare of Clostridium botulinum in whey protein, highlights the vulnerability of our agricultural based economy and demonstrates the importance of timely and effective testing.’ Fonterra chief executive Theo Spierings said ‘Food safety and quality must always remain our top priority.’ Fonterra commissioned independent testing from AgResearch, as it was only one of two research facilities in New Zealand capable of carrying out testing for the bacteria. As Spierings notes ‘On the basis of the results we received from the AgResearch tests, we had no choice but to alert regulators, and announce a global precautionary recall with our customers’. Independent test results released yesterday, have definitively established that there was no presence of these bacteria in the whey protein.

McGuinness says one of the main aims of the report is to stimulate discussion and contribute to a meaningful conversation that will ensure future public policy is durable and fit for purpose. ‘It is time for New Zealand to revisit the GM debate before the EPA receives an application to release a GMO into the outdoors. The time to build institutional capacity and think strategically is now.’

The report is available for download on the Institute’s website (www.mcguinnessinstitute.org) and hard copies can be purchased from its online store.

[ENDS]

Attachments: The First Forty years of GM: By the Numbers The Three Stage Process
McGuinness_Instititute_By_the_Numbers__29_August_2013.pdf
McGuinness_Instititute_GM_Three_Stage_Process__29_August_2013.pdf

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Government: New Year Border Exception For Seasonal Workers In The Horticulture And Wine Industries

2000 additional RSE workers to enter New Zealand early next year employers must pay these workers at least $22.10 an hour employers will cover costs of managed isolation for the RSE workers RSE workers will be paid the equivalent of 30 hours work a week ... More>>

ALSO:

Grey Power: Is Disappointed To Learn Of More Bank Closures

Many older people are being left without essential services because of cost cutting and the march of modern technology. It is now expected that most banking transactions can occur via the internet or telephone. Jan Pentecost, President of the Grey Power ... More>>

ALSO:

Economy: Supply Chain On Brink Of Overload Says National Road Carriers

The New Zealand supply chain is on the brink of overload and it looks like the upcoming peak imports season may push it over the edge says National Road Carriers Association (NRC) CEO David Aitken. “Worldwide supply chains are in disarray,” says Mr Aitken. ... More>>

Stats NZ: Annual Goods Trade Surplus At 28-Year High

New Zealand’s annual goods trade surplus reached a 28-year high of $2.2 billion as imports tumbled in the year ended October 2020, Stats NZ said today. “This is the largest annual surplus since the July 1992 year, driven mainly by much lower ... More>>

ComCom: How Real Is That Bargain?

The Commerce Commission urges retailers and consumers to think hard about the bargains being offered as ‘Black Friday’ and Christmas draw near. Black Friday has now overtaken Boxing Day in terms of retail spending, according to data from electronic ... More>>

Stats NZ: Births And Deaths: Year Ended September 2020

Births and deaths releases provide statistics on the number of births and deaths registered in New Zealand, and selected fertility and mortality rates. Key facts For the year ended September 2020: 57,753 live births and 32,670 deaths ... More>>

ALSO:


Forest & Bird: Kākāpō Wins Bird Of The Year 2020

The nation has voted and Aotearoa New Zealand has a new Bird of the Year. New Zealand’s moss-colored flightless parrot has climbed to the top-spot for the second time in Forest & Bird’s annual Te Manu Rongonui o Te Tau/Bird of the Year competition. ... More>>