Art & Entertainment | Book Reviews | Education | Entertainment Video | Health | Lifestyle | Sport | Sport Video | Search

 

Momentous Mahler

Momentous Mahler

Lindsay Perigo

It is said of Gustav Mahler that as a conductor he was a despot and a perfectionist. "To him there was no such thing as a minor detail," Harold C. Schonberg writes, "... Mahler would not tolerate inattentive or careless playing. Never in his life did he encounter an orchestra that satisfied him in his search for perfection." After conducting the premiere of his 5th Symphony in 1904, Mahler himself said, "Nobody understood it. I wish I could conduct the first performance fifty years after my death."

Well, I'm no expert on performances of the Mahler 5th—I'm not even a fan of it or him—but I know a venerable aficionado who is. For him, the New Zealand Symphony Orchestra's rendering of it on Friday night was his 20th live hearing of the work, and right up there with the best of them. His verdict: "What fabulous playing from the orchestra and all that solo instrumental work. At least Edo didn't drag out the 4th movement, a la Bernstein."

The "4th movement," of course, is the Adagietto famously used in the movie Death in Venice, and one of Mahler's infrequent flirtations with tunefulness. It is customary to label him a "late Romantic," but I venture to suggest that anti-Romantic would be more accurate. Critic Ferdinand Pfohl went so far as to call the 5th, Adagietto aside, “second- and third-hand music, ugly and barren … a desecration of the sacred spirit of music.” (Invited to a dinner for the composer, he declined, refusing “to be in the same room with Mahler, breathing the same pestilential atmosphere”!)

The Cincinnati Symphony gave the work its American premiere in May, 1905, where it was panned for “almost unbearable dissonances and cacophony"—though The Commercial Tribune pronounced it “the most impressive and meritorious novelty” the orchestra had yet presented. The latter view became prevalent, of course, as dissonance and cacophony became the norm.

The true Romantics knew the truth later to be identified by Henry Pleasants in The Agony of Modern Music: "... in the opera house, as in the concert hall, vocal melody or an instrumental substitute for it is the alpha and omega of music." Mahler's sublime Adagietto shows that he knew it, too, but perversely set out instead to be a purveyor of preposterously long and discordant bloviation masquerading as intricacy.

None of this is to gainsay the spellbinding energy and precision with which the supersized orchestra, and conductor Edo De Waart, executed this work. Trumpeter Michael Kirgan and hornist Samuel Jacobs were standouts, ablaze and thrilling. The capacity crowd, including a higher-than-usual number of youngsters, roared its approval. And roared and roared and roared. One suspects even Mahler would have been satisfied.

This concert replays tomorrow night, Tuesday April 10 in Dunedin and the following night, Wednesday April 11 in Christchurch.

(PS—There was some Mozart, awash in "the alpha and omega of music," in the first half, played by two attractive young ladies, Christina and Michelle Naughton—who, disconcertingly, appeared to think they were auditioning to be Fox News anchors. Since they are clearly excellent in their present vocation, one would encourage them to remain in it.)

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines

 

Preview: Your Heart Looks Like A Vagina By Dominic Hoey

Dominic Hoey’s one-man show Your Heart Looks Like a Vagina, is a dark comedy about the joys of living with autoimmune disease. This one man show will bring together Dominic Hoey’s long career as a performance poet and writer and the experimental theatre experience of Director Nisha Madhan.. More>>

Let The Games Begin: PM Sends Best Wishes To Athletes

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has sent her warm wishes to the New Zealand athletes preparing for the opening of the Commonwealth Games on Australia’s Gold Coast... More>>

ALSO:

Scoop Review of Books: Martin Edmonds' The Expatriates

This book is an extension of, and tribute to, the life’s work of James McNeish. Without sacrificing any degree of authorial independence, the result is gracefully written, handsomely produced, and likely to propagate many further works of its kind. More>>

Max Rashbrooke Review: The King's Singers and Voices New Zealand

To be good at one thing is impressive; to be so versatile across a range of genres is truly exceptional. More>>

Joe Cederwall Review: WOMAD 2018 - Harmony of Difference (part 1)

A friend described WOMAD as his “favourite white middle class celebration of diversity.” There is certainly an echo of truth to this as the crowd is still largely white and middle class, but this WOMAD for me represented that a better world is possible ... More>>

Harmony of Difference (part 2)

Top international world music artists seldom make it down to this neck of the woods, so for those of us into this sort of thing WOMAD is certainly a welcome addition to the cultural calendar. Now it is a case of waiting and looking forward to seeing what they manage to conjure up for next year. More>>

Howard Davis Review: A Bigger Splash - Te Papa Celebrates Twenty Years

Considering the available resources, this is a decidedly hit-and-miss affair, mainly due to some highly questionable curatorial decisions. In their overweening wish to "push boundaries," Charlotte Davy and Megan Tamati-Quennell have made a number of serious miscalculations by ignoring a basic rule - keep it simple. More>>

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • CULTURE
  • HEALTH
  • EDUCATION
 
 
  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland