Art & Entertainment | Book Reviews | Education | Entertainment Video | Health | Lifestyle | Sport | Sport Video | Search


Momentous Mahler

Momentous Mahler

Lindsay Perigo

It is said of Gustav Mahler that as a conductor he was a despot and a perfectionist. "To him there was no such thing as a minor detail," Harold C. Schonberg writes, "... Mahler would not tolerate inattentive or careless playing. Never in his life did he encounter an orchestra that satisfied him in his search for perfection." After conducting the premiere of his 5th Symphony in 1904, Mahler himself said, "Nobody understood it. I wish I could conduct the first performance fifty years after my death."

Well, I'm no expert on performances of the Mahler 5th—I'm not even a fan of it or him—but I know a venerable aficionado who is. For him, the New Zealand Symphony Orchestra's rendering of it on Friday night was his 20th live hearing of the work, and right up there with the best of them. His verdict: "What fabulous playing from the orchestra and all that solo instrumental work. At least Edo didn't drag out the 4th movement, a la Bernstein."

The "4th movement," of course, is the Adagietto famously used in the movie Death in Venice, and one of Mahler's infrequent flirtations with tunefulness. It is customary to label him a "late Romantic," but I venture to suggest that anti-Romantic would be more accurate. Critic Ferdinand Pfohl went so far as to call the 5th, Adagietto aside, “second- and third-hand music, ugly and barren … a desecration of the sacred spirit of music.” (Invited to a dinner for the composer, he declined, refusing “to be in the same room with Mahler, breathing the same pestilential atmosphere”!)

The Cincinnati Symphony gave the work its American premiere in May, 1905, where it was panned for “almost unbearable dissonances and cacophony"—though The Commercial Tribune pronounced it “the most impressive and meritorious novelty” the orchestra had yet presented. The latter view became prevalent, of course, as dissonance and cacophony became the norm.

The true Romantics knew the truth later to be identified by Henry Pleasants in The Agony of Modern Music: "... in the opera house, as in the concert hall, vocal melody or an instrumental substitute for it is the alpha and omega of music." Mahler's sublime Adagietto shows that he knew it, too, but perversely set out instead to be a purveyor of preposterously long and discordant bloviation masquerading as intricacy.

None of this is to gainsay the spellbinding energy and precision with which the supersized orchestra, and conductor Edo De Waart, executed this work. Trumpeter Michael Kirgan and hornist Samuel Jacobs were standouts, ablaze and thrilling. The capacity crowd, including a higher-than-usual number of youngsters, roared its approval. And roared and roared and roared. One suspects even Mahler would have been satisfied.

This concert replays tomorrow night, Tuesday April 10 in Dunedin and the following night, Wednesday April 11 in Christchurch.

(PS—There was some Mozart, awash in "the alpha and omega of music," in the first half, played by two attractive young ladies, Christina and Michelle Naughton—who, disconcertingly, appeared to think they were auditioning to be Fox News anchors. Since they are clearly excellent in their present vocation, one would encourage them to remain in it.)

© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


Book cover: New Zealand's Backyard BeastsScoop Review Of Books: Bug Report

You might be forgiven for being a little uncertain about what this non-fiction work is all about based just on its title, but the cover illustration steers you straight, and the content inside leaves you in no doubt about the purpose of this lovely book More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Best Music Tracks Of 2018

Oliver Godji, who records as Octavian, is a French/British/Angolan rapper based in London. As someone born in Lille, France, he didn’t qualify for welfare in Britain... More>>

Programme Launch: Pussy Riot Leads The Auckland Fringe

The full programme for Auckland Fringe arts festival 2019 has landed with a giant international announcement for the blockbuster programme which features Russian protest art collective Pussy Riot. They are set to make their New Zealand debut, coming to Auckland for one night only. More>>

Howard Davis: Three Reasons for Film Fans to Get Netflix

The past two months have finally seen Netflix come into its own, providing the financing for three films that will warm the hearts of cinephiles everywhere - Orson Welles' The Other Side of The Wind, The Coen Brothers' The Ballad of Buster Scruggs, and Alfonso Cuarón's Roma. More>>

Scoop Review Of Books: The Rift by Rachael Craw

Rachael Craw's first series, Spark has been extremely well received by the YA community in both Australia and New Zealand (it has a hashtag, #SparkArmy), and The Rift looks like it’s going to be just as popular. More>>



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland