Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Canadians Contradict Government Assurances on GM

Canadians Contradict Government Assurances on GM

Government assurances that export markets will not be affected by GM plantings in New Zealand are contradicted by a previously secret paper from a country that Government cites as proof of its claims.

A document on GM release intended to reassure Labour MPs paints a picture of no significant damage resulting to New Zealand’s clean green brand and no impact on non-GM exports. It states “Canada and the US, despite having extensive GM plantings, continue to secure access for their non-GM products to GM sensitive markets such as the EU countries and Japan”.

Yet the Canadian government is privately very concerned about the impact of GM production on export markets and damage to “Brand Canada”.

"Consumers are becoming more worried that they can't distinguish between GE and non-GE products," says a paper prepared in March by the Department of Agriculture and Agri-Food. "These concerns could precipitate a loss of confidence in the integrity of the Canadian food system, which could be very disruptive to the domestic system as well as Canada's ability to export to demanding markets."

The Canadian paper is marked secret but was recently declassified. It details in particular the problems Canada faces exporting non-GM canola. “The production of GE canola is currently adversely affecting the value of non-GE canola in some markets. The EU is effectively closed to all Canadian commodity canola” it states. Since 1998, Canada's annual sales of canola to Europe have dwindled to about $1.9 million a year from $230 million, the Canadian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade calculates.

The canola experience has prompted other Canadian commodity/production sectors to block the introduction and cultivation of GM varieties. In 2000, GM flax was poised for commercial production. However, it was withdrawn from the market, after concerted pressure from the Canadian Flax Council. The council cited consumer resistance to GM foods in Europe, which accounts for 60% of all Canadian flax sales.

GM wheat, the newest GM variety proposed for market release, has been roundly rejected by Canadian growers. Their single desk seller, the Canadian Wheat Board, considers that GM wheat production would jeopardise the viability of non-GM wheat markets.

This experience is not unique to Canada. Non-GM growers in the US, the largest GM Food producing nation, have similarly suffered significant losses of export sales due to GM production. (See box below.)

These examples show that the growing of GM crops clearly damages the export of similar non-GM crops, contrary to Government’s advice. As no systems for preventing GM crops from contaminating ordinary crops have yet been demonstrated, the lesson for New Zealand is to remain a GM Free Food Producer for at least the next five years.

US Corn Market

The US lost almost its entire European Union corn export market in 1997, at a time when GM corn accounted for 10% of all corn production. US corngrowers estimate this has cost them more than $1 billion USD over a three-year period. (US Department of Agriculture (2001) “Fight for Corn Market Share in Europe Intensifies”, International Agricultural Trade Report; National Corn Growers Association Letter to President Bush, January 2003) Export markets in Asia have also suffered. The South Korean market, which was the second largest export market for U.S. corn in the late 90s, has been largely lost to China, which provides a non-GM corn source. (USDA Economic Research Service, Feed Yearbook 2003, p. 30). The reputation of the US corn market was further harmed by the StarLink contamination incident of 2000, in which GM corn that had not been approved for human consumption entered the human food chain. The USDA notes that the zero tolerance for StarLink in Asian markets has disrupted corn shipments destined for these export markets. (USDA Feed Yearbook 2001, p. 46).

© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Maritime Union: Deepening Supply Chain Crisis Requires Action

Maritime Union of New Zealand National Secretary Craig Harrison says the global COVID-19 pandemic exposed pre-existing weaknesses in our logistics sector, and created enormous problems... More>>

Air New Zealand: Employees Recognised With $1,000 Share Award

The efforts Air New Zealand employees made during one of the airline’s toughest years will be recognised via an award of $1,000 worth of company shares to all permanent employees... More>>

Consumer NZ: Bank Complaints On The Rise, Survey Shows

Nearly one in five Kiwis had a problem with their bank in the past year, Consumer NZ’s latest satisfaction survey finds. Consumer NZ chief executive Jon Duffy said the number of bank customers reporting problems had jumped to 18%, up from 11% in 2020... More>>

Mercury: Enters Into Binding Agreements To Acquire Trustpower’s Retail Business

Mercury NZ Limited (Mercury) has announced that it has entered into binding agreements with Trustpower Limited (Trustpower, NZX:TPW) to acquire Trustpower’s retail business for NZ$441 million... More>>


ASB: New Zealanders Missing Out On Hundreds Of Millions In KiwiSaver Government Contributions

New Zealanders have just over a week to ensure they’re eligible for the maximum annual government KiwiSaver contribution... More>>

Stats NZ: GDP Climbs 1.6 Percent In March 2021 Quarter Following December Dip

Gross domestic product (GDP) rose by 1.6 percent in the March 2021 quarter, following a 1.0 percent fall in the December 2020 quarter, Stats NZ said today. "After an easing of economic activity in the December quarter, we’ve seen broad-based growth in the first quarter of 2021... More>>