Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Herald agreement breaches law, says employment ct.

November 17, 2003
Media Release

Herald agreement breaches law, says employment court

The Employment Court has found that part of the New Zealand Herald journalists’ collective agreement is inconsistent with the law, and therefore unenforceable.

In a decision likely to have ramifications for other agreements, the court has found that workers covered by a collective agreement cannot leave that agreement and sign an individual agreement without resigning from the union.

The case arose after Herald managers told two senior journalists that if they wanted pay rises, they would have to leave the collective. The journalists’ union, the Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union, complained to the Employment Relations Authority that the move was in breach of the good faith requirements of the Employment Relations Act.

But authority member Yvonne Oldfield said that there were serious questions about whether some parts of the collective agreement were legal, and she asked the Employment Court to rule on those questions before she would consider the case further.

In a ruling released today, a full bench of the court found that:

1. A worker covered by a collective agreement may withdraw from that coverage by resigning from the union.
2. A clause in the NZ Herald journalists’ collective allowing people to leave the collective while remaining members of the union was inconsistent with the ERA.
3. The actions of workers who purported to withdraw from the collective by signing individual agreements or giving notice to the union and the employer were ineffective.

Union lawyer Tony Wilton said that the ruling meant that the only way a worker could leave a collective was by resigning from the union, and workers who had not were still covered by the collective.

The court also said that any move by the Herald to make a pay rise conditional upon a worker leaving the collective agreement would breach the ERA and International Labour Organisation conventions.

“Insistence upon salaried employees leaving the coverage of the collective agreement would fall down on a number of counts,” the court said.

“It would be inimical to promoting observance of the principles of ILO convention 87 on freedom of association. It would not promote collective bargaining. It would at least indirectly undermine the effect of s8 and 9 providing that membership of unions should be voluntary and prohibiting any arrangements that confer any preference on employees turning on whether the particular employee is or is not a member of a union.”

Mr Wilton said that the union welcomed the decision, which clarified an important aspect of the Employment Relations Act.

Meanwhile, the NZ Herald journalists’ collective agreement has expired, and bargaining is under way for a new agreement.


© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


Stats NZ: Consents For New Homes At All-Time High

A record 41,028 new homes have been consented in the year ended March 2021, Stats NZ said today. The previous record for the annual number of new homes consented was 40,025 in the year ended February 1974. “Within 10 years the number of new homes ... More>>

Stats NZ: Unemployment Declines As Underutilisation Rises

The seasonally adjusted unemployment rate decreased to 4.7 percent in the March 2021 quarter, continuing to fall from its recent peak of 5.2 percent in the September 2020 quarter but remaining high compared with recent years, Stats NZ said today. ... More>>


Digitl: The Story Behind Vodafone’s FibreX Court Ruling

Vodafone’s FibreX service was in the news this week. What is the story behind the Fair Trading Act court case? More>>

Reserve Bank: Concerned About New Zealand's Rising House Prices

New Zealand house prices have risen significantly in the past 12 months. This has raised concerns at the Reserve Bank of New Zealand – Te Putea Matua about the risk this poses to financial stability. Central banks responded swiftly to the global ... More>>

Westpac: Announces Strong Financial Result

Westpac New Zealand (Westpac NZ) [i] says a strong half-year financial result has been driven by better than expected economic conditions. Chief Executive David McLean said while the global COVID-19 pandemic was far from over, the financial effect on ... More>>

MYOB: SME Confidence In Economic Performance Still Cautious

New insights from the annual MYOB Business Monitor have shown the SME sector is still cautious about the potential for further economic recovery, with two-in-five (41%) expecting the New Zealand economy to decline this year. The latest research ... More>>