Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

UPDATE: Knauf, Fletcher return to court over Batts dispute

UPDATE: Knauf, Fletcher return to court over long-running Batts dispute

(Adds detail from Knauf submission in 8, 9 10th paragraphs)

By Suze Metherell

Sept. 29 (BusinessDesk) - Knauf, the German building materials firm, and Fletcher Building, New Zealand's dominant building supplies company, have returned to court for a cross appeal, the latest instalment of their long-running dispute over the use of the word "batts" to describe insulation.

Appearing in the Court of Appeal before Justices Tony Randerson, Christine French and Mark Cooper, the legal counsel for Fletcher's Tasman Insulation subsidiary, Julian Miles QC returned to the argument that Knauf's use of "batt" or "batts" on the packaging of insulation infringed the "Batts" trademark it has held since 1973.

The two building supplies companies are both appealing aspects of Justice Brendan Brown's May 2014 judgment, which refused a request from Knauf to revoke the trademark. In the same judgment, Justice Brown also limited Fletcher’s claim of infringement of the trademark to the use of “batt” in the HTML code on the www.earthwool.co.nz website, which sold Knauf insulation, and said the use of the word in the installation instructions on the packaging didn’t infringe trademark.

Dwarfed by 11-plus boxes of files and three large rolls of Knauf insulation, Tasman's Miles said the rival company first started importing its insulation into New Zealand in December 2010, originally in clear packaging labelled "loft roll". However, during 2011 Knauf began to bring in "what we understand was the same product with different packaging" which included instructions which referred to the product as "batts". Miles pointed out the difference using the three insulation rolls in the court room.

Miles argued that Knauf's use of "batts" on its packaging was a "deliberate" attempt to use Fletcher's trademarked term. He said the change from the original non-offending packaging to the inclusion of the term came after market research showed the widespread use of the term over the past four decades.

Knauf "knew (Batts) had a trademark, the only inference that you can draw from that is that they intended to undermine a trademark," he said. It was irrelevant how the term was used in other countries, as this dispute concerned only the New Zealand market.

Knauf, represented by Clive Elliott QC, is appealing Justice Brown’s ruling that the "Batts" trademarked term for insulation is not generic.

In its submission Knauf argues Tasman was flawed in asserting "Batts" was a highly distinctive and iconic trademark, and it has always been a descriptive word to describe portions of insulation. There is no evidence Knauf set out to destroy the distinctiveness of "Batts" and Tasman's efforts to protect the mark were "too little, too late".

"Knauf submits that if traders have chosen not to use 'batts' it is reasonable to infer that this is because of a fear of being sued by Tasman rather than in express of implied acknowledgement of Tasman's proprietary assertions," Knauf said it its submission. The company points to CSR which had also applied to revoke the trademark use of the term as further proof it is considered a generic term.

The global insulation business said the use of "batt" and "batts" on its insulation bales imported into New Zealand was because of the genuine belief the word was descriptive. The original bales had been shipped from Russia and the USA, where the words are considered generic terms and it wasn't economical to manufacture product with New Zealand-specific packaging.

The hearing is set down for three days in the Court of Appeal, and is continuing.

(BusinessDesk)

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 


R&NTU: KiwiRail strike notices withdrawn following new offer

Strike notices on KiwiRail have been withdrawn. Rail and Maritime Transport Union General Secretary Wayne Butson says following negotiations between the RMTU and KiwiRail, a new offer from KiwiRail will be taken back to union members for ratification... More>>



Banking: Stress Tests Show Strengthening Bank Resilience

The latest stress tests carried out by the Reserve Bank of New Zealand – Te Pūtea Matua show strengthening resilience in the banking sector and the benefits of continuing to build capital buffers... More>>


Statistics: Building Activity Down In September Quarter
The volume of building activity in New Zealand fell 8.6 percent in the September 2021 quarter, compared with the June 2021 quarter, Stats NZ said today. Residential building activity fell by 6.4 percent in the September 2021 quarter, while non-residential building activity fell 12 percent... More>>



Reserve Bank: Deputy Governor Reflects On Time At RBNZ
Central bankers must continue to look forward to guard against the unpredictable, Deputy Governor Geoff Bascand says in a speech published today. Mr Bascand joined the Reserve Bank of New Zealand – Te Pūtea Matua in 2013 during the aftermath of the Global Financial Crisis... More>>


Xero: Data Reveals ICT Expenditure Key To Small Business Sales Growth
Xero, the global small business platform, today released a new report which shows New Zealand small business ICT expenditure has increased 25 percent compared to pre-pandemic levels - more than the UK (20%) and Australia... More>>


Fonterra: Lifts Forecast Farmgate Milk Price Range And Revises Earnings Guidance At First Quarter Update

Fonterra Co-operative Group today lifted its 2021/22 forecast Farmgate Milk Price range, reported a solid start to the 2022 financial year and revised its earnings guidance... More>>


Canterbury Museum: New Research - Bald Haast's Eagle Feasted On Moa Guts

New Zealand’s extinct Haast’s Eagle (Hieraaetus moorei), the largest known eagle, gulped down viscera like a vulture and may even have been bald, new research suggests... More>>