Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search


Manufacturing firm warned over anti-competitive agreement

October 2015
Release No. 33

Manufacturing firm warned over anti-competitive roofing products agreement

The Commerce Commission has issued a formal warning to manufacturing firm Consolidated Alloys (N.Z.) Limited (CA) over the inclusion of an anti-competitive clause in a negotiated settlement with roofing products competitor Edging Systems (NZ) Limited (ESL).

The settlement agreement was entered into to resolve a commercial dispute about whether ESL’s EZ-Edge product breached CA’s registered patent over soft-edge flashing products for use on residential metal roofs. CA’s patent was registered in 1995 and expired on 10 August 2015.

The Commission became aware of the agreement in September 2014 when ESL applied for and was granted conditional immunity under the Commission’s leniency programme.

Under the negotiated settlement, ESL agreed to pay CA a lump sum and royalties on annual sales of EZ-Edge. It also agreed not to sell any other soft-edge flashing products covered by the patent other than EZ-Edge until June 2023. The Commission considers this clause had the purpose and likely effect of substantially lessening competition after the patent expiry date in breach of section 27 of the Commerce Act.

ESL developed and began selling a new soft-edge product innovation called Vent Edge in late 2013 after the settlement agreement was signed. There was also a dispute between the parties about whether Vent Edge was covered by the patent. Competition brought about by EZ-Edge and Vent Edge has led to some price decreases. The Commission believes that had CA used the clause to prevent the sale of Vent Edge there would have been a substantial lessening of competition after the patent expired.

While the clause may have been inserted to protect the royalty payments, only one of multiple purposes needs to be anti-competitive to breach the Commerce Act. An intended consequence of the clause was to exclude the only likely competitor from entering the market with another competing product. As well as restricting the sale of competing products for a considerable period of time, it exceeded the duration of the associated royalty.

However, Commission Chair Dr Mark Berry said following the Commission’s investigation, CA formally advised that it would not enforce the restrictive clause in the settlement agreement. CA has also not prevented ESL from selling Vent Edge.

“Without a court ruling we can’t determine whether the patent validly applied to any of ESL’s flashing products. However, we believe the clause would have restricted competition after the patent expired, ultimately impacting on customers’ choice. Clauses like this protect established products by limiting innovation and the development of more efficient or better value products that benefit consumers,” Dr Berry said.

“Given CA has advised ESL that it will not enforce the clause restricting the sale of other soft-edge flashing products and no harm has been caused, we consider a public warning is appropriate. No further action will be taken in this case.

“This investigation is a reminder to all businesses that it can be risky to enter into settlement agreements that contain clauses that affect the ability of other parties to compete in any market. Care is required, particularly where competitors are involved.”

A copy of the investigation report can be found here.

© Scoop Media

Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines


NZTA: Major New Zealand Upgrade Programme Projects Go To Tender

Two major New Zealand Upgrade Programme projects are beginning tenders for construction. The New Zealand Upgrade Programme is a $6.8 billion investment to get our cities moving, to save lives and boost productivity in growth areas. The first Auckland ... More>>

Reserve Bank: RBNZ Seeks To Preserve Benefits Of Cash

The Reserve Bank – Te Pūtea Matua is taking on a new role of steward of the cash system “to preserve the benefits of cash for all who need them”, Assistant Governor Christian Hawkesby told the Royal Numismatics Society of New Zealand annual conference ... More>>


Economy: Double-Dip Recession Next Year, But Housing Rolls On

New Zealand's economy is expected to slip back into recession early next year as delayed job losses, falling consumer spending, and the absence of international tourists bites into growth. More>>


Microsoft New Zealand: Microsoft Expands “Highway To A Hundred Unicorns” Initiative To Support Startups In Asia Pacific

New Zealand, 14 October 2020 – Today Microsoft for Startups launches the Highway to a Hundred Unicorns initiative in Asia Pacific to strengthen the region’s startup ecosystem. This follows the initiative’s success in India, where 56 startups were ... More>>

Fonterra: Farmers Taking Another Step Towards New Zealand’s Low Emissions Food Production

They’re hot off the press and intended to help take the heat out of climate change. Fonterra farmers are already among the world’s most sustainable producers of milk and now have an additional tool in their sustainability toolbox. Over the last few ... More>>


Electricity: New Zealand Remains In Top 10 For Energy Balance

The World Energy Council’s Energy Trilemma Index has become part of the energy dialogue both globally and in New Zealand. The Index illustrates the need for countries to balance energy security, energy equity and environmental sustainability. New Zealand ... More>>


Courts: Businessman Eric Watson Sentenced To A Four-Month Jail Term

New Zealand businessman Eric Watson has been sentenced to a four-month jail term in the UK for contempt of court, TVNZ reports. More>>

OECD: Area Employment Rate Falls By 4.0 Percentage Points, To 64.6% In Second Quarter Of 2020

The OECD area employment rate – the share of the working-age population with jobs – fell by 4.0 percentage points, to 64.6%, in the second quarter of 2020, its lowest level since the fourth quarter of 2010. Across the OECD area, 560 million persons ... More>>

Spark: Turns On 5G In Auckland And Offers A Glimpse Into The Future Of Smart Cities

Spark turned on 5G in downtown Auckland today and has partnered with Auckland Transport (AT) to showcase some of the latest in IoT (Internet of Things) technology and demonstrate what the future could look like for Auckland’s CBD with the power of 5G. 5G is ... More>>

Stats NZ: Monthly Migration Remains Low

Since the border closed in late-March 2020, net migration has averaged about 300 a month, Stats NZ said today. In the five months from April to August 2020, overall net migration was provisionally estimated at 1,700. This was made up of a net gain ... More>>

University of Canterbury: Proglacial Lakes Are Accelerating Glacier Ice Loss

Lake Tasman, New Zealand | 2016 | Photo: Dr Jenna Sutherland Meltwater lakes that form at glacier margins cause ice to recede much further and faster compared to glaciers that terminate on land, according to a new study. But the effects of these glacial ... More>>


Dairy: Fonterra Sells China Farms

Fonterra has agreed to sell its China farms for a total of $555 million (RMB 2.5 billion*1), after successfully developing the farms alongside local partners. Inner Mongolia Natural Dairy Co., Ltd, a subsidiary of China Youran Dairy Group Limited ... More>>