News Video | Policy | GPs | Hospitals | Medical | Mental Health | Welfare | Search


Compulsory Treatment Orders Benefit Some Mental Health Patients More Than Others – Study

A ground-breaking University of Otago study could well influence which mental health patients in New Zealand are prioritised for controversial Compulsory Treatment Orders (CTOs) to ensure they get the medications and support they need.

The ten-year study has found that the well-being of patients with one specific type of mental illness - psychotic disorders such as schizophrenia - benefit far more from a CTO than people with non-psychotic disorders such as depression, bi-polar disorder, personality disorders and dementia.

“Our study is the first to examine whether a specific mental health diagnosis makes a noticeable difference in treatment outcome for New Zealand patients placed on a CTO” says study co-author, psychiatrist and University of Otago Christchurch researcher, Dr Ben Beaglehole.

“We found that patients with psychotic disorders do much better when placed under a CTO, with both shorter and less frequent hospital admissions compared to those with a non-psychotic disorder on a CTO. This information could now help psychiatrists more confidently gauge whether the often-difficult decision to place a patient under a CTO is likely to truly benefit that patient or not.”

The study, just published in The Lancet Regional Health – Western Pacific, studied outcomes for nearly 15,000 New Zealand patients placed under a CTO between January 2009 and December 2018. The mean age of the study cohort was 35 years, nearly 60 percent were male, with 50 percent European and 34 percent Māori. Patients with psychotic disorders experienced 18 percent fewer hospital admissions on CTOs compared to an increase of 15 percent for patients with non-psychotic disorders. In addition, their average hospital admissions were reduced by 3 days in length compared to an increase of 2.5 days for non-psychotic patients. CTO status was also associated with a three-fold increase in positive community contacts for patients and a two-fold increase in the successful dispensing of their medication.

“These findings are significant for patients with psychosis and show a measurable improvement in their ability to stay safely in the community, for longer periods of time, with the right support, receiving the medications they require to keep themselves as well as possible. Notably in this study, patients on a CTO with a non-psychotic disorder also received high rates of injectable anti-psychotic medications, despite their hospital admission frequency being increased. These findings really question whether we should be using coercive treatments like CTOs for this non-psychotic group of patients if the main aim is to reduce their acute admissions to hospital,” Dr Beaglehole says.

Compulsory Treatment Orders have long been contentious due to the fact they impose severe restrictions on the freedoms of individuals living with mental health in the community. They are used by psychiatrists to enable legally-mandated, compulsory treatment for people with severe mental illness without their consent where there are concerns the patient may be a danger to themselves and/or others. CTOs require patients to take their medications or face being returned to hospital if they refuse. The primary aim is to support the ability of patients with severe mental illness to remain in the community without the need for repeated hospital admissions.

“One suggestion from the government’s 2018 enquiry into mental health and addiction, He Ara Oranga, is to repeal and re-write the Mental Health Act due to concerns some competent patients are currently having their rights over-ridden,” says Dr Beaglehole. “This study may inform this discussion, helping ensure only the most suitable patients – those with psychotic disorders – are considered for CTOs in future.”

Despite the controversy, Dr Beaglehole says most in the mental health treatment community believe CTO’s are highly successful for improving patient care, hence their use.

“As a psychiatrist, I can now more confidently advise a psychotic patient and their whānau that a CTO will increase the care they or their loved one will receive to enable them to remain safely in the community and also increase the likelihood they’ll receive their medication. We can also more confidently say that the need for that patient to be admitted to hospital to treat an acute episode may be less frequent and for a shorter duration when required.”

© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


Howard Davis: Emerald Fennell's Promising Young Woman'

The Guardian needed not one, but three reviews to do justice to Fennell's unsettling approach, which indicates exactly how ambiguous and controversial its message really is. More>>

Howard Davis: Jill Trevelyan's Rita Angus

Although Angus has become one of Aotearoa’s best-loved painters, the story of her life remained little known and poorly understood before Jill Trevelyan's acclaimed and revelatory biography, which won the Non Fiction Award at the Montana New Zealand Book Awards in 2009, and has now been republished by Te Papa press. More>>

Howard Davis: The Back of the Painting

Painting conservators are the forensic pathologists of the art world. While they cannot bring their subjects back to life, they do provide fascinating insights into the precise circumstances of a painting's creation, its material authenticity, and constructive methodology. More>>

Howard Davis: Black Panthers on the Prowl

A passionate and gripping political drama from Shaka King, this is an informative and instructive tale of human frailty that centers around the charismatic Chicago Black Panther leader Fred Hampton, who was murdered at the age of twenty-one during a police raid. More>>

Howard Davis: Controlling the High Ground

Stephen Johnson's raw and angry film not only poses important questions with scrupulous authenticity, but also provides a timely reminder of the genocidal consequences of casual bigotry and xenophobia. More>>

Howard Davis: Dryzabone - Robert Conolly's The Dry

After the terrible devastation caused by last year’s bushfires, which prompted hundreds of Australians to shelter in the ocean to escape incineration and destroyed uncountable amounts of wildlife, The Dry has been released during a totally different kind of dry spell. More>>

Howard Davis: Hit the Road, Jack - Chloé Zhao's Nomadland

Nomadland is perhaps the ultimately 'road' movie as it follows a group of dispossessed and disenfranchised vagabonds who find a form of communal refuge in camp sites and trailer parks after the economic contraction of 2008. More>>



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland