Education Policy | Post Primary | Preschool | Primary | Tertiary | Search


Educators Dismayed At Legislation Proposals



Speaking on behalf of the Education Forum, John Morris, Headmaster of Auckland Grammar School, said he was appalled at some of the legislative proposals recently announced by Trevor Mallard, Minister of Education.

"The abolition of bulk funding of teacher salaries is overturning by legislation arrangements entered into voluntarily by many schools in both low and high income areas. Bulk-funding serves schools and their students well by providing flexibility and demonstrating trust in the judgement of schools and their communities to do what's best for their own students. If abolition is not to be seen as a petty, vindictive manoeuvre designed to do by legislation what the teacher unions couldn't achieve by bullying, the government will have to explain what is to replace bulk-funding and how the same or greater benefits are to be achieved. By what other means is the government to express confidence in the ability of boards, principals and teachers to find local solutions to local problems, lift parental involvement, and raise educational achievement?

"Tightening enrolment schemes will tend to lock in restrictions on parental choice. It will ensure, for example, that students who would benefit from attending a successful out-of-zone school will only be able to do so if they secure places in a ballot. It may exacerbate over-crowding in popular schools and help to protect failing ones. Again it assumes boards, principals and teachers can't be trusted to make good decisions for their students.

"By contrast, the proposals for more flexible governance arrangements are aimed at allowing local solutions to local conditions and seem sensible. Why is the same approach not used when it comes to staffing and enrolments?

"The basic problem with both the bulk-funding and enrolment proposals is that they don't address the key issue of how to raise the performance of all schools. This must include giving parents more not less choice of school and allowing boards and principals more not less discretion over staffing and not just over staffing profiles but also over terms and conditions of employment and over procedures for easing out persistently poor performing teachers. It's disturbing that these proposals seem to be directed at appeasing political constituencies rather than improving education. This is a disappointing start for a government which purports to be concerned to improve education and to 'close the gaps' ", he said.


© Scoop Media

Culture Headlines | Health Headlines | Education Headlines


NAISA: World's Indigenous People Gather In New Zealand

More than a thousand people from the Pacific and across the globe are in Hamilton for the Native American Indigenous Study Association conference at the University of Waikato. More>>

Stats NZ: Slight Fall In Overall Life Satisfaction

The average rating for overall life satisfaction is now 7.7, a slight fall from 7.8 in 2016 and 2014. However, the majority of Kiwis (81.1 percent) still rated their life satisfaction highly, as 7 or above on a 0 to 10 scale. More>>

Howard Davis Review: Ans Westra & The New Photography At Te Papa

Te Papa's latest exhibition and publication focuses its corrective lenses on eight outstanding photographic pioneers who forged a bold new style during the 1960s and 70s. More>>

Scoop Review Of Books: Making History

Jock Phillips is a pioneering public historian who has sought new ways to communicate history to a wide audience. His autobiographical memoir is a fascinating account of how perceptions of history have changed through his career. More>>



  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
  • Auckland