Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Judgment: Calver v Accident Compensation Corporation



8 July 2019



[2019] NZHC 1581

This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court’s judgment. It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment. The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document. The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at www.courtsofnz.govt.nz.


In 2016, aged 45, Deanna Trevarthen died of mesothelioma, a fatal cancer contracted by a small but significant number of New Zealanders each year. In almost all cases mesothelioma is caused by exposure to asbestos. There is no known minimum or “safe” threshold level of exposure below which there is no risk of developing it. The internal changes caused to a person who inhales asbestos stay latent for decades before mesothelioma is triggered. These factors make it impossible to identify which instance, or instances, of inhalation caused the disease.

Before she died, Ms Trevarthen sought cover under the Accident Compensation Act 2001 for a range of entitlements such as treatment costs, weekly compensation, a lump sum and funeral costs. The claim was continued by her estate after her death.

The Act provides cover to persons who have contracted mesothelioma from work-related exposure to asbestos. This did not apply to Ms Trevarthen. She was exposed to asbestos when she was a child in the 1970s through her father who worked as an electrician. She would hug her father in his work clothes after his return from work. She also sometimes played at his work sites. Therefore, she needed to show that her mesothelioma was “a personal injury caused by an accident” under the Act.

The Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) rejected Ms Trevarthen’s claim on the basis that she was seeking cover for personal injuries caused wholly or substantially by a disease (which is excluded by the Act) and because she could not identify a specific occasion of asbestos inhalation which caused the disease, as required by the Act. That decision was upheld by the District Court. 2


In allowing her appeal to the High Court, Mallon J has held:

(1) It is the condition suffered that constitutes the personal injury for the purposes of the Act. The condition suffered by Ms Trevarthen was mesothelioma. That condition is not caused wholly or substantially by a gradual process, disease or infection. It is caused by inhaling asbestos. If it can be shown that inhaling asbestos is an accident, as defined by the Act, then it will be covered.

(2) The Act provides that an accident is proven if Mrs Trevarthen inhaled asbestos “on a specific occasion”. It was not necessary to identify the specific occasion of asbestos inhalation which gave rise to her mesothelioma to show that the inhalation was an accident. This is because mesothelioma will only be triggered if a sufficient dose of asbestos has been inhaled. That dose may arise from a single occasion (in which case there has been a “specific occasion” at that time) or from several occasions (in which case the occasion on which the last bit of asbestos is inhaled that constitutes the necessary dosage is the “specific occasion” which gives rise to the accident).

Therefore Ms Trevarthen was entitled to cover under the Act for mesothelioma because this was a personal injury caused by an accident to her.

[Scoop copy of judgment: 2019NZHC1581_Calver_v_ACC.pdf]

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


Gordon Campbell: On Trump’s Open White Nationalism

At one level, this has been the week that the Republican Party of Abraham Lincoln – which once led a civil war that ended the slave economy of the South – has now defined itself openly as being the party of white nationalism.

By telling those four elected, American born and/or raised women of colour to “go home”, US President Donald Trump’s racist agenda has come out of the shadows. More>>


RNZ: Trades Hall Bombing Case Re-Opened, Evidence Released

The cold case has been reopened and the police have recently revealed more details about the bomb's components - including that it was wrapped in a 1977 edition of The Evening Post. More>>

Safety: Govt Targets Fewer Deaths On The Road

“Most roads deaths and serious injuries are preventable and too many New Zealanders have lost their lives or been seriously injured in crashes that could have been prevented by road safety upgrades,” said Associate Transport Minister Julie Anne Genter. More>>


Pay Rise Delay: Teachers Unions Plan Legal Action Against Novopay

Both of the teachers unions - NZEI and the PPTA - have confirmed they will be taking legal action against Novopay. More>>


Emission Statement: 'Consensus Reached' On Agriculture

Today the Government launched a consultation document, informed by the work of the Interim Climate Change Committee (ICCC), on how to bring agriculture into the emissions trading scheme, a key part of the Government’s plan to tackle climate change and reduce New Zealand’s emissions. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On What’s Wrong With Wellington

For many Wellingtonians, it hasn’t been the normal hardships – the workings of central government and the lousy weather – that have recently pushed their tolerance into the red zone. It has been the inability of local government to maintain even the basics. More>>


$1m Compensation Paid: First Gun Ban Event In Christchurch

The Police Minister says the first ever firearms collection event in Christchurch over the weekend was a huge success. But Stuart Nash had concerns about whether the participation reflected the number of weapons in the region. More>>


The Kids: Youth Parliament 2019 Event Kicks Off

120 Youth MPs and 20 Youth Press Gallery members have gathered in Wellington to attend the two-day Youth Parliament event ... More>>


Friends Like These: Foreign Minister To Visit USA

Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters will travel to Washington D.C. today for talks with senior members of the US Administration, and to attend the Ministerial to Advance Religious Freedom. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The Aussie Banks’ Latest Fee Hike Excuse

When the Reserve Bank sought feedback on its plans to require the country’s major banks to raise their capital reserves then you might have expected the banks to whine and complain. And so they have. More>>





InfoPages News Channels