Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 

Boardroom Double Standards Exposed by Air NZ Spat

Boadroom Double Standards Exposed by Air New Zealand Spat

Wed, 28 Aug 2002

About the most fruitful thing to come out so far of the argument over whether Qantas should have a stake of Air NZ, is that the major protagonists are totally conflicted but aren't letting this prevent them parade their self-interest on their sleeve.

This morning we have Wellington airport (aka Lloyd Morrison) and Infratil commissioning a report that argues the government is conflicted - its interests as a shareholder of Air NZ encouraging it toward a deal with Qantas to stop the financial bleeding, while its role as regulator and protector of competition should lead it to avoid giving Qantas a stake.

Well it takes a monopolist to have the cheek to preach competition to others. Already ticked off by the Commerce Commission for monopoly practices Wellington Airport and Infratil were noticeably absent in any opposition to the government decisions to re-nationalise Air NZ and hence reduce private sector competition. Indeed Morrison is on public record as supporting that competition-reducing move as being in the 'national interest' whatever that meant that day. And yet he has the gall to lead a PR campaign by vested interests to prevent Qantas taking a stake in Air NZ, purportedly on the grounds that it "reduces competition". Excuse me, isn't this the pot calling the kettle black?

Next we have the double standard being applied by Michael Cullen. Apparently it was fine for the government to pre-empt a competitive process for the purchase of Air NZ by taking the dominant stake itself, again 'in the national interest'. While such an action was apparently exempt from Commerce Commission scrutiny of its competition-reducing nature, this time around Dr Cullen has said he's happy for the Commerce Commission to scrutinise the part-sale to Qantas. In other words the government applies one rule for itself and another for others - classic hypocrisy.

Finally we have Air NZ CEO Ralph Norris bleating that the airports are usurious monopolies that are bleeding his airline and screwing travellers. The Commerce Commission agrees. That Air NZ has been monopoly pricing on some regional routes has not embarrassed Mr Norris to point the finger.

What is clear from all of this is that the consumer's interest has been left last in the queue behind the vested interest of Air NZ, the airports and the government's political sensitivity. Consumer benefit is best served by total privatisation and an open skies policy allowing all comers to establish the best air transport configuration for NZ. None of the protagonists have called for this.

All we have so far is a low ethical base of corporate vested interest trying through PR spin to manipulate public opinion to their own ends. No wonder corporate and political credibility are treated with such scepticism.

Dr Gareth Morgan
Economist
Infometrics Ltd,
ph (04) 4730 630


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Financial Markets Authority: Online Investing Platforms Transform Attitudes To Investing

Eight out of 10 New Zealand investors have a more favourable view of investing and financial markets after using online investing platforms, according to research released today by the Financial Markets Authority - Te Mana Tātai Hokohoko... More>>



Barfoot and Thompson: Auckland Housing Prices Shrug Off Winter Concerns

Auckland house prices shrugged off the normal winter downturn, concerns about increasing prices and warnings of possible future interest rate rises in July.
“Mounting concerns about the prices being paid and possible future interest rate increases did nothing to dampen July trading... More>>



Stats NZ: Sharp Falls In Unemployment And Underutilisation

The seasonally adjusted unemployment and underutilisation rates fell to 4.0 and 10.5 percent, respectively, in the June 2021 quarter, Stats NZ said today. The unemployment rate continued to fall from its recent peak of 5.3 percent in the September 2020 quarter... More>>


ASB: Labour Shortage Sting Set To Cause Issues For Years According To Latest Quarterly Economic Forecast

There are positives and negatives in the latest ASB Quarterly Economic Forecast as New Zealand continues to bounce back strongly from COVID-19. The closed border is putting additional strain on the country’s labour market... More>>

Transport: July 2021 New Vehicle Registrations Boosted By EV Rebate Scheme
Motor Industry Association Chief Executive David Crawford says that July 2021 sales of new vehicles were boosted by the recently introduced rebate scheme. July 2021 registrations were 15,053 units compared to 12,263 units for July 2020... More>>



ASB: New Support Finder Tool Helps Connect Customers With Thousands In Government Support

ASB research alongside benefit numbers from the Ministry of Social Development shows an increased number of Kiwis are struggling financially, and many may not be aware they’re eligible for government support... More>>