Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Bain Decision Vindicates Privy Council Appeals

Bain Decision Vindicates Opponents Of Abolition Of Appeals To The Privy Council

The recent decision of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council confirms that the abolition of future appeals to the Privy Council was a mistake.

It is difficult to overestimate the significance of the ruling. The Law Lords have determined that Bain has suffered a “substantial miscarriage of justice'', at the hands of the Court of Appeal. Confidence in New Zealand’s judiciary will inevitably have been damaged.

David Bain was fortunate that his appeal process was commenced early enough to permit him to appeal to the Privy Council. Future accused will not have that advantage.

The Law Lords have again overturned a deeply flawed decision of the Court of Appeal. Would the New Zealand Supreme Court have done so?

Opponents of the 2003 reforms of the New Zealand appeal process pointed out very many practical and legal reasons why appeals to the Law Lords should remain. One of the principal arguments was that, however good the New Zealand judiciary might be, there is nothing to equal an independent outside body to ensure quality control.

The Bain case joins a series of appeals, from Taito v R to Harley v McDonald, where New Zealand courts have failed to identify a procedural or logical error in a Crown case. That is the role of appellate courts, and our courts are failing to perform it adequately. There is little confidence that the new Supreme Court will make much difference. The fundamental problem remains that our judiciary is too small in numbers, and the courts are overworked.

Before the establishment of the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal was very short of judges. The Supreme Court took its best judges, leaving the Appeal Court decimated. It had to urgently recruit members from the High Court and elsewhere. It is common cause that, whilst many judges excel as trial judges, not all judges are suitable for appeal work. The number of suitable candidates for appeal court benches is very limited. So the High Court lost its best members to the Court of Appeal, and the Court of Appeal is largely made up of relatively inexperienced judges. Only the Supreme Court has a full complement of experienced judges. All courts are overworked and understaffed. Including the New Zealand Supreme Court.

The Privy Council by contrast has a full bench of the finest legal minds in the Commonwealth. It has the time, experience and knowledge to analysis the most difficult appeal arguments.

The majority of New Zealanders opposed the abolition of appeals to the Privy Council. Many because of the unilateral decision of the Government, in the face of considerable opposition and a majority call for a referendum; Many others because of the belief that we should retain access to the best appeal court in the world; Some because the abolition of appeals to the Privy Council was motivated in part by republicanism; Yet others because the cost of appeals was inevitably going to be higher under the new system.

When it comes to justice, we deserve the best in the work. The Privy Council provides that.

The Campaign for the Privy Council calls for New Zealand political parties to make the commitment to restore full access to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council.

John Cox


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Virtues (and Fluffed Opportunities) Of The Operation Burnham Report

One unspoken rule of thumb in any official public inquiry is : whatever you do, don’t conclude you were made to listen to “a litany of lies” even if the evidence of a deliberate cover-up is right there under your nose. In that respect, the report into the 2010 Operation Burnham military raid in Afghanistan has been a model of decorum. Bad stuff did happen and has been duly noted and lamented - but only as a lapse and departure from usual professional standards. Normal service can be trusted to resume shortly... More>>


Office Of The Speaker: Parliament Is Revamping Its Rules

Today, the Standing Orders Committee’s report on the review of Standing Orders was presented to the House. The Speaker of the House, the Rt Hon Trevor Mallard, chairs the committee. He said today that the 2020 review will make our rules more ... More>>

Environment: Govt Progress On Climate Change Essential, Risk Assessment Shows

The release of the National Climate Change Risk Assessment shows that the progress this Government has made to solve the climate crisis is essential to creating cleaner and safer communities across New Zealand. “Because of this report, we can see clearer ... More>>

Economy: Investing In The Tourism Sector’s Recovery

More than $300 million in funding has been approved to protect strategic tourism businesses, drive domestic tourism through regional events and lift digital capability in the tourism industry, Tourism Minister Kelvin Davis announced today. A $400 million ... More>>


National On MP Bill: Waka-Jumping Repeal Bill Passes First Reading

The Electoral (Integrity Repeal) Amendment Bill has passed its first reading, marking one step closer to Parliament getting rid of NZ First’s ‘waka-jumping’ legislation, National List MP David Carter says. “I’d like to thank the Greens for voting ... More>>


Covid-19:Legislation For Managed Isolation Payments Introduced

Hon Dr Megan Woods Minister of Housing Legislation to allow the Government to recover some of the costs for managed isolation and quarantine will be introduced to Parliament today, said Minister of Housing Megan Woods. “The Bill will allow the government ... More>>


Your Vote 2020: Bringing Election Coverage To Viewers Across TVNZ Channels And Platforms

As New Zealand gets ready to head to the ballot box this September, 1 NEWS is bringing voters comprehensive coverage and analysis of this year’s General Election. TVNZ’s coverage will draw on the depth of experience held across the 1 NEWS team, says Graeme ... More>>

Economy: 30% Believe Households Worse Off, 298,000 Expect To Lose Jobs

64% of New Zealanders feel the economic position of their households is the same or better than a year ago – and 30% think it is worse or much worse, while 298,000 think they will lose their jobs in the next 12 months. Households’ perceptions ... More>>

State Services Commission: Findings Of Investigation Into COVID-19 Active Cases Privacy Breach

Deputy State Services Commissioner Helene Quilter has today announced the findings of an investigation into a breach of privacy regarding sensitive personal information. The investigation looked into who or what caused the disclosure of the information, ... More>>

International Security: New Zealand Suspends Extradition Treaty With Hong Kong

The New Zealand Government has suspended its extradition treaty with Hong Kong and made a number of other changes in light of China’s decision to pass a national security law for Hong Kong, Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters says. More>>


Energy: 100% Renewable Electricity Grid Explored With Pumped Storage ‘battery’

The Government is taking a significant step toward its goal for 100% renewable electricity generation in a move that could be a game changer for consumers and the creation of a low-emissions economy, Energy & Resources Minister Megan Woods said. ... More>>






InfoPages News Channels