Video | Agriculture | Confidence | Economy | Energy | Employment | Finance | Media | Property | RBNZ | Science | SOEs | Tax | Technology | Telecoms | Tourism | Transport | Search

 


Korea investor safeguards will not work

“Safeguards” for investor rights to sue governments in Korea FTA text will not work

“The Abbott Government has agreed to include Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) in the Korea Australia FTA text which was released today. ISDS enables foreign investors to sue national, state or local governments for hundreds of millions of dollars of damages if they can allege a domestic law or policy “harms” their investment. The disputes are heard in international tribunals without the legal protections of national legal systems: arbitrators can be practising advocates and there are no precedents or appeals,” Dr Patricia Ranald, Convenor of the Australian Fair Trade and Investment Network, said today.

“The Trade Minister claims that there are “safeguards” which will prevent foreign investors from suing governments over laws which deal with public welfare, health and the environment. But these same “safeguards” have been included in other recent trade agreements, including the Central American Free Trade Agreement and the Peru-US Free Trade Agreement. The key substantial safeguard clauses in the Korea FTA are the same as in these two agreements, and they have not worked to prevent governments being sued,” said Dr Ranald.

“These agreements seek to limit the definition of “indirect expropriation”, which enables foreign investors to sue governments over domestic laws. But the sentence to exempt public health, safety and the environment begins with the words "except in rare circumstances.” This leaves a huge loophole which recent cases have used to advantage. Another “safeguard” is a more limited definition of "fair and equitable treatment" for foreign investors. But tribunals have ignored these limitations and applied the previous higher standard,” explained Dr Ranald.

“These “safeguards” have not prevented cases against environmental regulation. The Government of El Salvador has been sued by Pacific Rim Mining Corporation under the Central American Free Trade agreement, over a ban on mining to protect the nation’s limited groundwater resources. The US Renco mining company is using ISDS in the Peru-US Agreement to contest a local court decision that it was responsible for pollution from its lead mine. Both cases are ongoing and may take several years,” said Dr Ranald.

“Even if governments win these cases, they will have taken years and cost millions of dollars in legal fees. There will be no guarantee that the “safeguards” will work in future cases, because the arbitrators do not have to base their decisions on previous precedents meaning that the outcomes of future cases are unpredictable,” said Dr Ranald.

“The inclusion of ISDS in any trade agreement, even with “safeguards” exposes Australia to being sued for hundreds of millions of dollars over health and environment legislation,” said Dr Ranald.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Half Full: Dairy Payouts Steady, Cash Will Be Tight

Industry body DairyNZ is advising farmers to focus on strong cashflow management as they look ahead to the 2015-16 season following Fonterra's half-year results announcement today. More>>

ALSO:

First Union: Cotton On Plans To Use “Tea Break” Law

“The Prime Minister reassured New Zealanders that ‘post the passing of this law, will you all of a sudden find thousands of workers who are denied having a tea break? The answer is absolutely not’... Cotton On is proposing to remove tea and meal breaks for workers in its safety sensitive distribution centre. How long before other major chains try and follow suit?” More>>

ALSO:

Scoop Business: NZ-Korea FTA Signed Amid Spying, Lost Sovereignty Claims

A long-awaited free trade agreement between New Zealand and South Korea has been signed in Seoul by Prime Minister John Key and the Korean president, Park Geun-hye. More>>

ALSO:

PM Visit: NZ And Viet Nam Agree Ambitious Trade Target

New Zealand and Viet Nam have agreed an ambitious target of doubling two-way goods and service trade to around $2.2 billion by 2020, Prime Minister John Key has announced. More>>

ALSO:

Scoop Business: NZ Economy Grows 0.8% In Fourth Quarter

The New Zealand economy expanded in the fourth quarter as tourists drove growth in retailing and accommodation, and property sales increased demand for real estate services. More>>

ALSO:

Scoop Business: RBNZ’s Wheeler Keeps OCR On Hold, No Rate Hikes Ahead

The Reserve Bank has removed the prospect of future interest rate hikes from its forecast horizon as a strong kiwi dollar and cheap oil hold down inflation, and the central bank ponders whether to lower its assessment of where “neutral” interest rates should be. The kiwi dollar gained. More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Business
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news