Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


The problem with Ardern’s Corbyn endorsement

The problem with Ardern’s Corbyn endorsement

For many Jewish New Zealanders, their decision on which political candidate to support will at least partly be based on that candidate’s position on Israel and “the conflict”, as well as their sensitivity around anti-Semitism as it exists in 2017.

Jacinda Ardern, who may well be New Zealand’s PM in two weeks, has given little away in terms of her position on both of these matters, although in general she comes across as moderate on international matters, and strong against racism.

A few days ago, however, Ardern proudly shared an endorsement she’d received that may have caused a few Jewish Kiwis some discomfort. This was from UK Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn – a man seen by many progressives as a hero of the left. But for the vast majority of UK Jews – and many Kiwi Jews too – he is seen as tolerant of anti-Semitism, if not actively anti-Semitic.

Corbyn’s problems with Jews go back a while. The list of worrying alliances, statements, and failures to act is long and growing. His supporters, citing his lifetime commitment to fighting “all forms of racism”, have dismissed these concerns as ‘smears’ and the weaponisation of anti-Semitism for political gain.

It is difficult to imagine an ethnic group whose legitimate concerns over racism have been more blatantly dismissed by a mainstream western political party in recent years. Among all ethnic groups, it seems that only Jews are considered ill-qualified to determine for themselves what constitutes racism against them.

In the recent UK election, polls indicated that only 13% of Jews supported Corbyn’s Labour party. This is a dramatic reversal of UK Jews’ traditional support for Labour. In fact, it has been suggested that, in the narrow race, Jewish alienation may have helped the Conservatives retain power.

So why is Jeremy Corbyn such a toxic name in Jewish circles? The following is just a representative sample of some of the incidents, statements and allegiances that have given rise to this distrust of the UK Labour leader:

• Corbyn has called terror groups Hamas and Hezbollah “friends” and attempted to invite them as his “honoured guests” to the UK Parliament. He also referred to Hamas as “an organisation that is dedicated to the good of the Palestinian people and bringing about long term peace and social justice”.

• He participated in a wreath-laying ceremony at the grave of one of the terrorists behind the massacre of 11 Israeli Olympic athletes in Munich in 1972.

He accepted 20,000 as payment for appearances on Iranian government-controlled Press TV. He claimed that he did this to raise “human rights issues”, but there is no evidence that he did that. He did, however, listen to callers share anti-Semitic slurs, without interjection or opposition.

• He appointed the former chair of virulently anti-Israel group Stop The War to head his election campaign.

• During the election campaign, Corbyn supporters erected a banner depicting Theresa May with Star of David earrings, “to highlight her relationship with Israel”.

• A report into anti-Semitism in the Labour Party published in 2016 was widely seen as a whitewash. Following its publication, the report’s author, Shami Chakrabarti, was almost immediately made a Labour peer.

• At the public launch of the report a Jewish Labour MP, Ruth Smeeth, suffered anti-Semitic verbal abuse, while Jeremy Corbyn stood by and did nothing to intervene.

• In his speech at the same launch, Corbyn appeared to compare Israel to Isis, which former Chief Rabbi Lord Sacks called, “demonisation of the highest order, an outrage and unacceptable”.

• Corbyn invited extremist Imam Sheik Raed Salah to “tea on the terrace” at Parliament, “because he deserves it”. He also called him an “honoured citizen”. Salah was charged with inciting anti-Jewish racism and violence in January 2008 and was sentenced to eight months in prison.

• Despite finding remarks (repeatedly made) by Ken Livingstone connecting Zionists with Nazis anti-Semitic and bringing the Labour party into disrepute, the Labour party decided not to expel Livingstone from the party and instead suspended him for one year – a decision widely seen as shameful.

• Jewish Labour MPs who have spoken out against Corbyn have received appalling anti-Semitic abuse and threats. In July this year Jewish MP Luciana Berger was threatened with deselection by Corbyn supporters. Corbyn has done little (if anything) to support the MPs suffering such abuse.

• Corbyn has declined several invitations to visit Israel’s Holocaust museum, Yad Vashem. He has also consistently turned down requests for interviews with Jewish newspapers.

The compounding effect of the above is a discernible disquiet about Corbyn and his party’s attitude toward Jews and their apparently obsessive hatred of Israel. As David Mercer, former director of Labour Friends of Israel, told the Guardian in 2015:

“Thousands of years of persecution have given Jewish people a sixth sense, and with Corbyn the alarm bells are ringing extremely loudly. There is a way in which he frames his views that makes me feel very uncomfortable. When I listen to Corbyn speak on almost any issue, I get the feeling this is a man who doesn’t like my community.”

Similarly, the Chairman of the Jewish Labour movement, Jeremy Newmark, told the BBC:

“Jeremy Corbyn appears to have failed to understand the nature of contemporary anti-Semitism in the same way that it’s understood by most of its target group.”

A recent survey commissioned by the Campaign Against Anti-Semitism found that a third of UK Jews are now thinking about emigrating. It also revealed that more than three-quarters of UK Jews believe that the Labour Party’s stance on Israel has intensified levels of bigotry.

Corbyn’s ties and allegiances with extremists, including those who advocate for the death of all Jews, whether in or outside Israel, are of great concern to Jews everywhere. It is daunting to see Corbyn escape scrutiny for these ties from his own party, which professes to stand against racism. It would be particularly galling for Kiwi Jews to see unquestioning support for such a morally defective individual from someone who may soon lead the country.

Shalom.Kiwi calls on Ms Ardern to distance herself from such a malignant stain on the left’s traditional and proud commitment against racism.

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Election Day Results

2017 General Election - Preliminary Count

National won 46% of the vote with Labour on 35.8%.

NZ First won 7.5%, with the Greens on 5.8%.

ACT held on to Epsom, but failed to get more MPs.

The Maori Party were wiped out of Parliament.

There are still special votes to be counted, but clearly National is in the box seat to form the next Government.

The Greens can not contemplate a deal with National.

So, Winston Peters will have to make a choice and could back National or a combined Labour/Green coalition.

The most likely result is National and NZ First will reach some sort of deal to form the next government.

Election Night Results

Advance Voting Statistics

General Election Information: Voters - Who, When And Where


From The Hood: The Campaign Strategist’s Lament

"This election is a chance to really work the record of what nine years of National-led government has done to improve the country for everyone. Or will do. Another three years, maybe six. Thirty-three years, tops. You don’t want to risk that, do you? More>>

PSA Report: National Gets An ‘F’ For Health Funding

"Seeing National’s record on health collected in one place is quite sobering - it’s clear that underfunding is having dire consequences on both patients and staff, who are having to do more than ever with less," says Glenn Barclay, PSA national secretary. More>>


Children With Disabilities: Education Crisis Unaddressed

In 2008 IHC lodged its complaint against the on-going failure of New Zealand Governments and the Ministry of Education to ensure that disabled children access a quality education on an equal basis to others in New Zealand schools. More>>

Gordon Campbell: Ten Reasons For Not Voting National

if anyone you know is thinking of voting National in Saturday’s election, there’s still time for an intervention. You owe it to your friends and relations to intercede. Because there’s plenty of evidence on National’s mediocre-to-awful track record over its nine years in power. We can’t afford another three years of drift. More>>


Suffrage Day: PSA National Secretaries Vote For Equal Pay

PSA national secretaries Erin Polaczuk and Glenn Barclay are advance voting for the 2017 election alongside their daughters, with equal pay and fairness in mind on the 124th anniversary of women’s suffrage in New Zealand. More>>


Charge Protests: Dairy Farms Use Same Amount Of Water As 60 Million People

Using Dairy NZ numbers, economist Peter Fraser and agricultural consultant Dr Alison Dewes calculate the water consumption of New Zealand dairy farms is equivalent to the residential use of 60 million people. More>>


Greenpeace: Labour, Greens Commit To Canterbury Democracy

Labour MP Megan Woods is promising to return Canterbury’s regional council, ECan, to a democratically elected council. It follows a mass day-long occupation of the ECan building by local water activists calling for the restoration of democracy and urgent action to save rivers. More>>




Featured InfoPages

Opening the Election
  • PublicAddress
  • Pundit
  • Kiwiblog