Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Phil Goff - DNA Reports Released

Media Release
Hon Phil Goff

9 March 2000


The Minister of Justice, Hon Phil Goff, released two reports on DNA today.

The first report from Rt Hon Sir Thomas Eichelbaum and Professor Sir John Scott resulted from an incident in which the DNA profile of a victim was found in forensic samples from two unrelated homicides.

Sir Thomas and Sir John concluded that the most likely explanation for the result was accidental contamination during the early stages of processing at the ESR biology laboratory in Mt Albert.

The report made a number of recommendations aimed at minimising the prospect of contamination of DNA samples.

Sir Thomas and Sir John stressed that the events ought not to be regarded as throwing doubt on the usefulness of DNA analysis as an investigative tool.

The second report results from concerns about a case involving marginal DNA results. The results were originally reported as excluding the accused as the source of the DNA in question. Later testing using newer more sensitive technology, indicated that the accused was the likely source of the DNA.

The report considers the need for mandatory reporting protocols to establish a scientific threshold governing the interpretation of analysis results within the laboratory.

It concludes that it is not possible or appropriate to establish mandatory reporting guidelines but instead makes recommendations relating to disclosure of information in ESR forensic reports and the training of trial counsel in DNA methods and technology.

Mr Goff said, "DNA profiling is an extremely valuable forensic tool. Over the last decade, it has become increasingly important in criminal trials".

"DNA testing has the ability to eliminate a suspect from an inquiry, or to assist in establishing the suspect's involvement in a crime. DNA technology has been used successfully in many criminal investigations. Among the more notable examples, it led to the apprehension of the Auckland serial rapist."

"However, as these two incidents demonstrate, DNA analysis is not infallible. It is only one piece of evidence that any jury must consider, albeit an increasingly persuasive one.

"DNA technology is improving all the time so there is less scope for these kinds of incidents to occur. Nevertheless, I am concerned, as I am sure the public is as well, that these incidents are not repeated.

"I have discussed the content of these reports with the Minister in charge of the ESR,
Hon Pete Hodgson and with ESR itself. The ESR has responded positively to the two reports released today.

"Among ESR's responses have been to implement procedural improvements to packaging and sealing practices in dealing with samples to minimise the risk of contamination. It is also assessing changes needed to upgrade to a 'state of the art' DNA facility including changes to ventilation requirements.

"The ESR this year will further upgrade its DNA profiling techniques to a system which provides greater discrimination when comparing DNA profiles and improved sensitivity (called SGM+).

"I have also instructed the Justice Ministry to work with the Judicial Studies Institute, the Law Society and the ESR to improve training of judges and lawyers in the use and interpretation of DNA evidence.

"These measures will reduce further the likelihood of the problems addressed by the two reports re-occurring", Mr Goff concluded.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On NZ’s Complicity In Western Sahara

If David Parker really wants to hone his crisis-managing chops on an international trade dispute that New Zealand has been making worse for years, he maybe should be turning his attention to the Western Sahara.

Some background: two NZ companies called Ravensdown and Ballance Agri-Nutrients appear to be the only independent firms in the world still willing to import phosphate from the disputed territory of the Western Sahara... More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Malaysia Exposing Our Dodgy Policies On China

Last week, we all owed a vote of thanks to Malaysian PM Mahathir Mohamad for breaking with protocol during his bilateral with Jacinda Ardern. Reportedly, Mahathir used the photo opportunity phase of the meeting to launch into matters of genuine substance. More>>


Withdrawls After Police Uniform Ban: Auckland Pride Remains Committed

The Auckland Pride Board remains committed to creating a space for our rainbow communities to feel safe celebrating their gender and sexual identity, despite some institutions pulling out from the Parade in recent days. More>>


South Korea: State Visit By Korean President Moon Jae-In

The President of the Republic of Korea Moon Jae-in will visit New Zealand from 2 to 4 December... “I am very much looking forward to welcoming President Moon to New Zealand,” said Jacinda Ardern. More>>

Health: Changes To Drinking Water Standards

David Clark said many of the changes he is making, which will take effect on 1 March 2019, are clarifications or corrections, “but there are two changes which will significantly improve the ability to test and respond to the presence of harmful bacteria such as E.coli”. More>>


IPCA: Police Detention "Unlawful But Reasonable"

The Independent Police Conduct Authority has found that while Police acted unlawfully in October 2017 when they detained a Queenstown man for a mental health assessment, their actions were reasonable in the circumstances. More>>


Joint Statement: Chile President's NZ Visit

At the invitation of the Right Honourable Jacinda Ardern, Prime Minister of New Zealand, His Excellency the President of the Republic of Chile, Sebastián Piñera, undertook a State Visit to New Zealand on 19 November 2018... More>>


Climate Change: Top Academics Call On Government To Take Action

One hundred and fifty academics and researchers from around Aotearoa, including Dame Anne Salmond, Emeriti Professors and several Fellows of the Royal Society, have signed a strongly-worded open letter to the Government demanding bold and urgent action to tackle climate change. More>>





InfoPages News Channels