Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Costs, benefits, rugby and refugees

Costs, benefits, rugby and refugees

Murdoch Stephens – Doing Our Bit (www.doingourbit.co.nz)

Amongst all of the last day’s reports – ChangeMakers releasing their criticism of the lack of support for asylum seekers[1]; Peter Dunne suggesting an increase in the quota to 1000 places[2]; my analysis of New Zealand and asylum seekers for Glasgow’s GRAMnet[3] – some numbers on the costs of refugees have been haphazardly flying around in the mainstream media.

How do we measure the cost or benefit of something?

Today the Manawatu Standard, part of Fairfax’s network, reported that refugees cost New Zealand $50m per year[4]. It is a curious number, likely plucked from an analysis of the costs of refugees over a three-year period. However, it ignores one basic element of an economic cost-benefit analysis: the benefit.

The figure can be sub-divided into five departments: $5.7 m on Immigration, $5.3m on Social Development, $8.2m on Health, $18.5m on Education, $12m on Housing[5].

So the cost is $50m over three years.

Lets compare that to the cost of hosting the Rugby World Cup. Fairfax reports a cost of $66m for the event.[6] But the idea that we spend money on sport is not the point. The point is what comes next.

Murray McCully, Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade, states that the tournament was “absolutely” worth it financially, with a kickback for the economy that would be felt for years to come.

He reaches this conclusion by referencing a study by Coventry University's centre for the international business of sport, commissioned by MasterCard, to show a long-term net benefit to the country of $1.44b.

This is the crux of the matter. Costs or benefits are determined by comparing long term costs and long term benefits.

Consider a 2009 Department of Labour analysis of the cost of immigration to New Zealand[7]. There they show that 18% of our GDP is spent on immigrants to New Zealand. They go on to show that 24.7% of our GDP is accrued from immigrants. In short, immigrants add more to the economy than they cost.

Refugees have greater needs than immigrants and overall they are likely to be a short-term cost. But the problem with the government’s analysis is that they refuse to calculate the monetary benefits of refugees. Refugee’s tax payments (income tax, GST, and the rest) are unlikely to be more than $50 over three years, but the tax intake will be in the tens of millions.

If Murray McCully displayed the same loyalty to refugees as he did to rugby, he might come up with some similar sentiments.

For example, do we usually consider education to be such a dead cost? Roughly forty percent of refugees coming into New Zealand on our quota are under 18. These are the people costing the taxpayer $18.5m over three years in education.
And what does the taxpayer get back? They get the one thing they need to survive: more taxpayers, more skilled workers, more New Zealanders.

The government does not begrudge young New Zealanders their education and they don’t harangue the NZRU about the World Cup. Instead they take a long term look at education and indulge in the most highly inflated statistics about flow on effects for a sports tournament.

There is no reason that New Zealand’s young refugees should not be accorded the same dignity as our young people. There is no reason why New Zealand’s refugees should not be accorded the same optimism to their economic benefits as our elite sportsmen.

This is, of course, only the economic argument. There are other hard to quantify benefits, such as an increase in our international standing, that will come to mean a lot when the Universal Periodic Review is undertaken in February and New Zealand is assessed for our readiness for a place on the UN Security Council.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


Environment Aotearoa 2019: Report Warns Environment In Serious Trouble

The report is jointly produced by the Ministry for the Environment and Statistics New Zealand, and is a follow on from the last report in 2015.

The report says the way New Zealanders live and make a living is having a serious impact on the environment, and the benefits New Zealanders get from being in nature, though not measured or quantified, could be lost. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Scrapping The Capital Gains Tax

As PM Jacinda Arden said yesterday, there was no point in Labour bringing a proposal into the House that it didn’t have the votes to get passed. Looking back, maybe she always felt this outcome to be inevitable... More>>


Welfare: Access To Hardship Grants Hits Record High

Figures from the Ministry of Social Development for the March 2019 Quarter showed that hardship assistance grants increased by $48 million in the past year... They also showed the emergency housing grants went from $6.6m to $23m, and there were 70,000 extra requests for assistance for food. More>>


City Rail Link: Billion Dollar Cost Rise (And Preferred Bidder)

The revised cost envelope for completing the entire Auckland City Rail Link project now totals $4.419 billion. The revised cost has yet to be endorsed by the project’s sponsors (the Crown and Auckland Council). More>>


Meth Scare: Debt Write-Off For HNZ Meth Testing Evictions

People living in Housing New Zealand (HNZ) properties who were wrongly evicted because of flawed methamphetamine contamination policies will have their related debts with the Ministry of Social Development (MSD) written off. More>>


RNZ Report: Fears Grow For NZ Nurse Kidnapped In Syria

A New Zealand nurse working for the Red Cross was captured by Islamic State (IS) in Syria more than five years ago, and there are now public pleas for any information that could help bring her home. More>>


Streets Blocked In London: Climate 'Extinction Rebellion' Reaches Aotearoa

Across the world, thousands of people are taking part in a rebellion to avert climate, ecological and human catastrophe. This begins in Aotearoa New Zealand today. More>>





InfoPages News Channels