Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Proposed funding model could do more harm

Proposed funding model could do more harm

Child Poverty Action Group (CPAG) says that axing the current decile funding system on the basis that it is too crude, only to replace it with another that is already said to to be unreliable, may have the result of seriously disadvantaging schools on a national level.

A new Targeted at Risk Funding (TARF) component of the operational grant was introduced in the 2016 Budget. Instead of fully increasing operational grants to all schools, funding was instead targeted to support ‘at risk’ students. Students at risk were those whose parents had been on benefits for 75% of the first five years of the student’s life or 75% of the last five years. The 2016 Budget allocated $43.2 million over four years to 150,000 targeted ‘at risk’ children through TARF.

Outgoing Education Minister Hekia Parata has backed a proposal to replace the current decile system with a predictive risk modelling (PRM) system that individually targets ‘at risk’ students. This approach aligns with the Government’s new Social Investment model. PRM was originally developed for use by the Ministry of Social Development in relation to preventing child maltreatment. The latest reports suggest Ms Parata is hoping to have sign-off for the new system before she exits her role in Parliament.

A major flaw in the TARF approach is that the ‘at risk’ criteria aimed at identifying the most ‘vulnerable’ children exclude many children who are experiencing severe material hardship. These children are also known to be at increased risk of poor educational outcomes, but will not benefit from TARF because they do not meet the criteria. Another major flaw is that the TARF model is based on contextual or household risk indicators, not specific indicators of a child’s educational need. A third major flaw is that the decile system is used to additional "Vote Education" resources to the most disadvantaged school communities.

Professor John O’Neill, CPAG education spokesperson says that, "Abandoning decile based resource allocation without a sufficiently precise and educationally valid replacement is like throwing the baby out with the bathwater."

"It is important to provide a solution to funding more comprehensively across the board, and not simply rob one educational funding pot to pay another."

The overall picture shows New Zealand schools are being funded inadequately per student across the student’s 13 years at school, receiving around 40% less funding than other OECD countries such as Finland, Denmark and Ireland, whose schools rank among the highest for educational achievement. It stands to reason that better funding will significantly improve the opportunities for many children.

The New Zealand Treasury's analysis has also shown that basing Government educational funding solely on the risk of not having a successful life outcomes is too unreliable. In contrast the indicators used to allocate Targeted Funding for Educational Achievement (TFEA) are strongly correlated with actual educational underachievement: low-income households, low skill parental employment, household crowding, lack of parental qualifications, parents receiving income support.

"In this context, any funding targeted at children deemed to be at risk of educational underachievement must be additional to TFEA, not instead of it," says Professor O’Neill.

CPAG says that a successful funding model would retain the principles of the current decile funding system, with an increase in overall per-student spending for all schools, while incorporating the new targeted funding model as an additional support for learning. This would provide Government with some assurance that it was 'targeting' its limited additional funding support to both educational and contextual support needs of children.

Furthermore, addressing individual need must come at a familial level. Family income needs must be addressed urgently, and all schools must have the necessary provisions so that children living in material poverty have a greater chance of receiving the all the resources, support and expertise they need to help them achieve by the time they leave school.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell:
On The Kim Regime

During the Cuban Missile Crisis, the US had a very clear objective and eventually offered a quid pro quo of the removal of some of its own missiles from Turkey. This time, there’s no clarity about what the US is seeking, or offering.

It hasn’t helped that the US and the global media consistently agree on calling North Korea and its leadership “crazy” and “irrational” and urging it to “come to its senses”. When you treat your opponent as being beyond reason, it gets hard to comprehend what their strategy is, let alone work out the terms of a viable compromise. More>>


Recovery: Economic Impact Of Kaikōura Quake Revealed

The report details the impact on small businesses and tourism caused by disruptions to transport infrastructure and the economic impacts... The impact on New Zealand’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) over the first 18 months following the earthquake has been estimated at $450-$500 million. More>>


Human Rights Commission: Urgent Need For Action On Seclusion And Restraint

Chief Human Rights Commissioner David Rutherford says that while the report makes for sobering reading, the focus should now be on how the recommendations can be used to reduce the occurrence of seclusion and restraint in New Zealand and, in circumstances where it is necessary, to improve practices. More>>


CORRECTIONS (March 2017):


$11bn Capital Spend, New Debt Target: Steven Joyce On Budget Priorities

First, delivering better public services for a growing country – providing all New Zealanders with the opportunity to lead successful independent lives... And finally, we remain committed to reducing the tax burden and in particular the impact of marginal tax rates on lower and middle income earners, when we have the room to do so. More>>


JustSpeak Report: Bail Changes To Blame For New Billion Dollar Prison

In 2013 criminal justice spending was falling and the Government was mulling over what to spend the money on. 3 years later there are 10,000 people in prison and a new billion dollar prison is announced. More>>


Get More From Scoop



Search Scoop  
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news