Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


TVNZ Wins Right To Broadcast Confession

16 NOVEMBER 2007

TVNZ Wins Right To Broadcast Confession

In an historic decision, TVNZ today won the right to broadcast footage of a confession to police by Noel Clement Rogers; footage that jurors were prevented from seeing during Rogers' trial for the murder of Katherine Sheffield.

The Supreme Court this morning ruled in favour of TVNZ, ending a two-year court battle to screen an investigation by TV ONE's Sunday programme. The investigation will screen on Sunday this weekend (Sunday 18 November, 7.30pm on TV ONE).

TVNZ Journalists Mike Valintine – now editor of Close Up - and Hunter Wells – now editor of Sunday – spent five years investigating Katherine Sheffield's murder, after Borrie Lloyd, the man originally convicted of Katherine's murder, was acquitted and released from prison in 2002.

Their investigation included a confession in which Rogers returned to the scene of Katherine Sheffield's murder with police and described in detail the events surrounding her death. The confession was recorded on police video, but the tape was ruled inadmissible as evidence in Rogers' trial, being obtained in breach of Mr Rogers' right to have legal counsel and to be silent.

When Rogers was found not guilty, his lawyer gained an injunction in the High Court that prevented the Sunday programme from being broadcast, on the basis that Rogers' privacy rights superseded the principles of open justice.

TVNZ took the case to the Court of Appeal and won the right to screen the programme. Rogers then appealed to the Supreme Court, putting the broadcast on hold for over a year. In today's decision, New Zealand's highest court upheld the decision of the Court of Appeal.

TVNZ Head of News and Current Affairs Anthony Flannery described the decision as an important endorsement of the public's right to know.

"New Zealanders have a legitimate interest in and right to know all information surrounding Katherine Sheffield's tragic death and the process from investigation to trial," he said.

"Any desire to protect the privacy interests of an acquitted person should not outweigh legitimate debate. Full, informed debate cannot take place without the public seeing the video.

"It is immensely satisfying to Hunter, Mike and everyone who has worked on this investigation over the past five years that this story can finally be told."

Supreme Court Justice John McGrath in today's judgement said:

"In the end, in the circumstances of this difficult case, I have reached the conclusion, when balancing the conflicting interests, that the side of open justice carries the greatest weight. Preservation of public confidence in the legal system is directly relevant, because of the circumstances and outcome of the trials of the two accused persons.

There is real risk of damage to public faith in the criminal justice system if the circumstances that led the Court of Appeal to refuse to admit the evidence are not fully transparent.

It is a less than satisfactory response to reason that the end is achieved because the Courts' own descriptions of the events that are depicted in the videotape are full and complete. Open justice strongly supports allowing the media access to primary sources of relevant information rather than having to receive it filtered according to what courts see as relevant. On the other side of the scales, Mr Rogers' rights have been breached, but also vin dicated during the criminal justice process. At this stage they have much less weight."


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Rapid Antigen Testing

National Party leader Christopher Luxon is being allowed to get away with murder. Luxon is not being challenged over his repeated assertions that the rest of the world has enjoyed ready access to rapid antigen tests (aka RATS) for a year, so why aren’t we? In fact, the reality across the Tasman for the past month has seen a colossal shambles unfold over (a) the availability and (b) the affordability of these tests. RATS have become a case of panic buying on steroids. Amid reports of price gouging, stock-piling, socially inequitable access and empty shelves...


Save The Children: Thousands Join Call To Retain New Zealand’s Children’s Commissioner

More than 6000 Kiwis have joined Save the Children New Zealand’s call to retain the vital role of Children’s Commissioner, as the Government considers a new bill proposing major changes to the office, including the removal of a named Children’s Commissioner... More>>

Science Media Centre: Omicron Outbreak Would Move The Country To Red - Expert Reaction

The Prime Minister has announced if Omicron cases spread into the community, the country will move to the traffic light system's Red setting within 48 hours. Jacinda Ardern also mentioned there will be changes to the country's testing regime, with more use of Rapid Antigen Tests... More>>

Government: New Zealand Prepared To Send Support To Tonga

New Zealand is ready to assist Tonga in its recovery from Saturday night’s undersea eruption and tsunami, Foreign Affairs Minister Nanaia Mahuta and Defence Minister Peeni Henare said today... More>>

TradeMe: Property Prices Increase By A Record 25% In One Year
In December, the national average asking price jumped by a quarter year on year, to reach a new high of $956,150, according to the latest Trade Me Property Price Index. Trade Me Property Sales Director Gavin Lloyd said last month’s national average asking price increase was the largest on record... More>>

Statistics: Departures Lift Border Crossing Numbers

The number of people crossing New Zealand’s border went up in November 2021, mostly due to an increase in departures, Stats NZ said today. There were 28,700 border crossings in November 2021, made up of 12,300 arrivals and 16,400 departures... More>>

Financial Services Federation: Open Letter To Government From Non-bank Lenders: The Path Forward On CCCFA Changes
Responsible lenders are not interested in telling the Government “I told you so” when it comes to unintended consequences of changes to lending laws that are now causing grief for everyday Kiwis seeking finance... More>>




InfoPages News Channels